Friday, October 30, 2026

"You Can See Everything"

 So latest metadocumentary (is that even a word?) film is "You Can See Everything".

You Can See Everything - Wikipedia

"You Can See Everything is a 2026 American metadocumentary film directed by Nathan Fielder (in his feature directorial debut) and Lance Oppenheim. It follows Elizabeth Holmes, the founder of the defunct health technology company Theranos, and her partner Billy Evans, who invited a film crew to document them beginning in the weeks before Holmes began serving a United States federal prison sentence for defrauding investors.["

No, I'm not going to waste any time on this movie.  I read the book by John Carreúyrou, "Bad Blood", in 2019 Amazon.com: Bad Blood: Secrets and Lies in a Silicon Valley Startup (Audible Audio Edition): John Carreyrou, Will Damron, Random House Audio: Books

"In 2014, Theranos founder and CEO Elizabeth Holmes was widely seen as the next Steve Jobs: a brilliant Stanford dropout whose startup “unicorn” promised to revolutionize the medical industry with its breakthrough device, which performed the whole range of laboratory tests from a single drop of blood. Backed by investors such as Larry Ellison and Tim Draper, Theranos sold shares in a fundraising round that valued the company at more than $9 billion, putting Holmes’s worth at an estimated $4.5 billion. There was just one problem: The technology didn’t work. Erroneous results put patients in danger, leading to misdiagnoses and unnecessary treatments. All the while, Holmes and her partner, Sunny Balwani, worked to silence anyone who voiced misgivings—from journalists to their own employees."

Carreyrou at the time worked for The Wall Street Journal.  He now writes for the New York Times.  His book was a masterful work of journalism.  

I don't know what the purpose of Nathan Fielder's movie is, basically he is an actor in his own story.  And Elizabeth Holmes and her husband, Billy Evans, were actors in their own reality show.  And like most reality shows, it sounds like more show than reality.  Holmes is playing to an audience of one, namely herself, though the movie is being hyped as the greatest thing.

Holmes is an odd character, she claimed to have never told a lie, and that she believed her own story; that a college dropout could invent a medical device that could run a whole panoply of medical tests on a single drop of blood.  Most medical people, even most medical lab technicians, would say that is impossible.  A drop isn't a representative sample.  But that didn't keep her from selling her idea to investors (who appear not to have done due dilligence). She is said to have a charming personality. But in spite of what she claimed, she was found guilty of fraud and sentenced to prison.  And having put patients at risk with the phony numbers generated by her equipment.  

Holmes is effectively barred from working in the U.S. medical field in any capacity that involves federal health programs or funding for the next 90 years.

However, Billy Evans has incorporated a company, Haemanthus, in 2024. Evans has a degree in economics, but not in any medical field or in medical engineering. 

From Wikipedia:  "The company says that it is developing a device which will test blood, urine and saliva samples for disease, similar to the Theranos false claims about the "Edison" device. Haemanthus intends to first test pets and later humans, for which the company says it will make a wearable device to do the testing.[2] The company claims to use Raman spectroscopy, a technique that can be used to characterize the chemical composition of a sample using its response to laser light. The company has one patent, filed in January 2025."

Sounds to me like the pair aren't done scamming yet.


115 comments:

  1. These people need to be banished along with Musk, Zuckerberg, Martin Shkreli, and the rest of our billionaire overlords with 100-yard stares and reptilian brains. They cannot be rewired to live with normal people without scamming them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think you may be right, unfortunately.
      What I don't understand, if they were really so brilliant, and were interested in the field of medical engineering, why wouldn't they finish the degrees, and actually understand what they wanted to do?

      Delete
    2. Yah, it's weird. Combination of greed and arrogance, I guess. I think Holmes also enjoyed honing her image as a tech genius with the messy hair, Steve Jobs turtlenecks, red lipstick, and altered voice. Some kind of weird Dale Carnegie thing going on where they think they can will themselves into fame and fortune.

      Delete
    3. Con artists not worth the time to read about or watch a documentary.

      Delete
    4. I think the documentary movie was to a degree an attempt to spin Elizabeth Holmes into a somewhat sympathetic character (I say that, not having watched it). The John Carryrou book was interesting, and I believe, played a role in stopping the harm that was being done by Theranos. And also showed the degree which people will go to, to squelch an unfavorable truth.

      Delete
    5. I am fascinated by con games and con artists. It seems to be an occupation they enjoy. Like compulsive gamblers, they are master manipulators who have almost limitless faith that they're smarter than everybody else, which, for some, is secondary to the money. When I worked for the lodging industry, a famous con man used to come in to talk about hotel security and con games. He had gone straight, but at times it would cross your mind to wonder if the "expose the con" gig was just another con.

      Delete
    6. Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans did remind me of compulsive gamblers in some ways.

      Delete
    7. "Some kind of weird Dale Carnegie thing going on where they think they can will themselves into fame and fortune."

      This 'produce an outcome via willpower' approach definitely has been embraced by the president. It is why he keeps announcing peace deals for Ukraine and Iran, when the parties themselves pretty clearly aren't interested. He thinks his sheer will can somehow birth it into existence.

      I have read that Trump is a disciple of Norman Vincent Peale.

      Delete
    8. "This 'produce an outcome via willpower' approach definitely has been embraced by the president."

      A con man deluxe who learned from con men like Roy Cohn and Norman Vincent Peale.

      Peale, as you may recall, opposed JFK's candidacy on grounds that a Catholic president would threaten our pure American culture.

      The Art of the Deal basically boils down to puffery and bait-and-switch, basic con tactics.

      Delete
  2. Adam Kinzinger interviews Tyler Schultz, the Theranos whistle blower. They touch on the parallels between business and political fraud, especially how con artists build a complicit workforce who will help keep the con going. Last 10 minutes gets a bit self-congratulatory, but interesting overall.

    https://youtu.be/prsI4T10DKo?si=SOTtN3C832fPVl7e

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for that link, Jean. Very interesting interview. I knew about Tyler from reading Bad Blood. But this makes the point that Elizabeth Holmes absolutely knew she was lying, and that a lot of real people were getting bogus lab test information. I don't know if anyone died as a result, but that was a possibility. It was interesting, and weird, how she scammed these rich old men, who had been in government, but didn't have any scientific knowledge, out of a lot of money. Even coming between Tyler and his family members at one point.
    I guess I don't care if they laid it on a little thick at the end of the interview. Elizabeth Holmes has made it clear that she's still scamming. Sounds like she'll be out of prison and into some kind of house arrest thing by next summer.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I don't want to banish all billionaires. Of course, the ones who commit crimes should be arrested, tried, convicted and punished. And I could wish that billionaires would live lives of gratitude, and walk the walk by targeting their immense wealth toward addressing difficult and complex social problems. Some do; we'd be better off if more would.

    Holmes is a different breed, a grifter.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Let's not fool ourselves that billionaires live under a far different system of crime and punishment than the rest of us. They have lawyers to help them screw people legally, to skirt pesky regulations, and to lobby politicos to get laws they like made or reversed. And they have megabucks to pay complainants to go away when they do commit crimes.

      Hope you have a good voting day out there in Illinois. You are doing God's work today.

      Delete
    2. Everyone has heard the saying "money is the root of all evil". But the actual biblical quote is I Timothy 6:10, "For the love of money is the root of all evils, and some people in their desire for it have strayed from the faith and have pierced themselves with many pains." Love of money is the disordered attraction. Avarice is listed as one of the seven deadly sins.

      Delete
    3. I'd better find my rain jacket, and get ready to go vote. It's been raining all night and showing no signs of stopping anytime soon. Hope it doesn't cause many people to stay home. It's not a deluge, just an inconvenience.

      Delete
    4. Nevertheless, I don't understand why anyone with a billion dollars feels the need for another billion. Their attitude toward money is certainly different from mine. When the lotteries reach a billion, I'll sometimes play. My fun fantasy is giving away a billion dollars, not accumulating more. Some think the capitalist system actively rewards sociopathy. I think this is true in cases like Trump, Musk and Thiel. But there are other psychopathies. Could Warren Buffet, seemingly nice enough guy, have a hoarding complex or just be obsessive? At best, they just like playing the game. Perhaps some or all of these guys believe they have no worth aside from their money? i've said this stuff in forums and been accused of jealousy. But, if a genie appeared and granted me the wish of having either ten billion dollars or a comprehensive understanding of theoretical physics, which do you think I'd choose? If I'm envious of anyone, it's people like Maxwell and Heisenberg. In addition, in my own career, I never chose the more lucrative path of management. I'd have been bored unto death.

      Delete
    5. Yep, call me lazy and unambitious, but a billion dollars or transcribing and translating fragments of Old English parchment and holding them in my actual (gloved) hands? No contest.

      Is that a kind of sociopathy? To turn down $$ that would turn me into a do-gooder for some idiosyncratic thrill? Maybe. I think Raber and The Boy would be pissed. But they'd get it.

      Delete
    6. I guess I look at it this way. People would get mad at me for taking the knowledge instead of the billion which I could then give to the poor. And I would tell them that the rich have billions they don't need which can be taken away from them. It would be a matter of stealing from thieves.

      Delete
  5. So, friends. An unexpected election. Thoughts? What happens now? One thing that I like is that several (nine, I think) progressive Christian candidates won elections — progressive, not evangelical. I think Hamilton and Telerico and the others could make being religious acceptable again. The Catholic bishops could be “ influencers” in a good way, but most seem to have lost their grasp of the gospels. So it may have to be the Methodists, Lutherans and Presbyterians who bring gospel values into politics. Catholics like Vance, DeSantis and Abbott think like evangelicals, not Catholics. And the bishops often seem to think like evangelicals too, unfortunately.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Interesting point about progressive Christians on the Dem slate. I think Catholics will likely stick with the GOP given that pro-choicers are gearing up to lobby for a permissive national abortion law to offset Dobbs.

      Various stats and maps of Michigan show a sharp divide between rural and urban voters. Counties that went for Trump/MAGA in previous elections also went for GOP candidates this time around, and by pretty large margins.

      Rural counties here are all tourism and ag. Tariffs have hurt them, gas prices have hurt them, the Canadian boycott has hurt them, data centers will hurt them, and upcoming cuts to safety net programs will hurt them and threaten their access to doctors and hospitals.

      These points were hammered home relentlessly by El-Sayed, who visited rural areas and the UP often. He met with locals, put up with MAGA plants in audiences demanding he repudiate any number of Islamist groups, and highlighted places damaged by tech operations that locals told him about.

      But the anti-Muslim ads perhaps did the trick with Up North voters.

      Delete
    2. It wasn't unexpected for me, but I was nervous. I thought it would have to be pretty much a blue wave, and not just squeak by, in order to avoid something like a Jan 6 2021 scenario. But we seem to have avoided that. I am guardedly happy about the outcome.
      Of course Nebraska gonna be Nebraska, we're still a red state. But the Rs got a run for their money, and it sent a message. And we did flip our 2nd congressional district blue. I think the blue wave is going to give a lot of people cover for parting company with MAGA. I feel that we reached a turning point for the MAGA movement to be has-been. Of course there's still a ton of work to be done, similar to fixing stuff after a bad (ten year) storm.

      Delete
    3. About people voting against their own interests, the things mentioned by Jean above are true of us as well, we are heavily ag dependent.
      My sister was tearing her hair out because one of the rural hospitals near them is closing. 80% of that county voted to keep our Republican governor and senator, even though the money Congress gave to offset Medicaid cuts apparently didn't get to the rural hospitals.

      Delete
    4. Katherine, I wish people could connect the dots. If you're a rural Repub, it's likely that you benefit indirectly from a lot of "socialist programs"--SNAP benefits help your grocery store, Section 8 helps your landlords collect rents, Medicaid keeps your hospitals going, price supports help your farmers, etc.

      Delete
    5. All this domestic misery is joined at the hip to the death and misery this country inflicts throughout the world. It’s not cheap killing poor people with high tech weapons and high explosives. If Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries retake the leadership, the mountains will have labored and brought forth a mouse. Those two are already busy blunting expectations. This is a last chance for the Democratic Party and democracy. If it fails, the pendulum will swing violently again and the descent into fascism will be permanent. The military budget HAS to be walked back. Israel, the albatross on our neck, has to be abandoned to its own devices, which is also frightening given their nuclear capability. Otherwise we’re heading toward the earth like those unfortunate people whose Lear jet crashed in Florida.

      Delete
    6. All true Stanley. The Dems have a very challenging job. Made MUCH harder because trump loves to destroy—and he has veto power to obstruct the democrats. So I’m praying that the Senate seats in Alaska and Mississippi (MISSISSIPPI— wow!) do flip to blue because with those, and maybe a couple of GOP senators who are now somewhat freed from their chains—the fear of trump’s vengeance—they might be able to override vetos.

      Delete
    7. All that notwithstanding, I think we need to allow ourselves a moment of relief, that we came to a fork in the road, and collectively chose the better of two paths. Doesn't mean there won't be other forks, or that we will necessarily be on a straightforward trajectory. But this is a good moment.

      Delete
    8. Agree Katherine. This historic election provides a glimmer of hope — at last. I had truly believed that there was no hope for America anymore.

      Delete
    9. About the path forward, this is a good short interview of Jake Tapper talking with Pete Buttigieg.
      I thought it was funny at the end when Tapper asked Buttigieg if he had any aspirations toward 2028. It reminded me of what my dad used to say when someone asked him a question he was unwilling to answer, "I don't believe I said."

      Delete
    10. Forgot to include the link to the interview: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=hWnH49Fafzo

      Delete
    11. I do think Democrats need to temper expectations, at least at the federal level, at least for the next couple of years. If they can capture the White House starting in 2029, they can really go to town on federal policy. Until then, even with these large majorities in Congress, the president can suppress their policy dreams pretty easily.

      But at the state level, there should be possibilities to change policy. Certainly, regarding data centers.

      And at the federal level, Congress can certainly investigate, and probably should. Politically, that probably plays into Trump's hands, as it allows him to position himself as under siege by The Swamp, but it's still necessary.

      There are probably quite a few people in the Trump Administration who would qualify for impeachment, but Democrats in Congress need to keep their heads. The impeachments of Trump during his first administration were certainly just, but they didn't result in anything practical - nor did they seem to wound him politically.

      Delete
    12. Fundamentally, my view of this election wipeout of Republicans was a rejection of MAGA excesses and corruption. Full stop. Democrats' job in Congress for the next two years is to be normal and responsible. As lopsided as the results appear to be, I don't see them as an embrace of progressive policy.

      This is what Democrats must be disciplined about. The surest way to pump oxygen into MAGA is to overreach with progressivism.

      Just my view.

      Delete
    13. Jim, what would overreach with progressivism look like to you?

      Delete
    14. I think to focus on culture war issues would be seen as overreach. Also to a degree spending new money. However reapportioning some money that's already in the system needs to be done

      Delete
    15. Our political system, largely thanks to the way the media covers it and the way Trump operates, has become a reality show. I'm not persuaded that half the people who voted for the Blue Wave just want some new twists in the plot: Trump has torn down half of Washington, broken most norms of the presidency, and excoriated diversity. Can the newly elected crew of many ethnicities and gender identities give him his comeuppance? Don't touch that dial!

      I realize that attitude betrays a lot of cynicism on my part, but I don't think the careful measures Jim describes will do much to stop Trump, and I don't think that's what most of the Democrats campaigned on. If my new elected officials, El-Sayed and Will Lawrence are any indication, they're itching to kick ass and take names.

      Delete
    16. And for heaven's sake, can we lock Elon Musk out of our politics somehow? And enforce security requirements so we don't have Jared Kushner and the Trump boys doing Anything in government?

      Delete
    17. Katherine, yes, reapportioning excessive funds that the Big Beautiful Bill gave to ICE, DoD, etc would be good. Thanks for the link to the Tapper interview. Will look at it this afternoon.

      Delete
    18. Actor Mark Ruffalo presents an eloquent reading on Jeffries’ comment about not wanting to “get back” at anyone. Ruffalo frames it as justice and equality under the law, not an optional thing under Jeffries’ personal discretion and largesse.

      https://substack.com/@krigel8/note/c-381261633?r=dug1j&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=notes-share-action

      Delete
    19. If Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer retain leadership, the people that gave them a blue wave will stay home next time. Not vote Republican but just stay home drowning in ennui. If they are in, there will be nothing done by the Democrats. At this point, Jim need not worry about whether the D's will overreach. They'll underreach, not accomplishing anything. Jeffries and Schumer are as dedicated to the corporations, billionaires and the genocide country as the Republicans. I've already heard their disgusting, flaccid statements. "We can't do this and we can't do that. We can't even get rid of ICE. You gave us your votes, young people, now FU very much". The people who voted for them want real change NOW. We ran out of time in 2016. We are ten years behind right now. I expected this from those eunuchs.

      Delete
  6. One of the best analysis of the election came from an Iranian official who said that the war on Iran clearly caused "regime change" in America. That is certainly true for personnel in the House, Senate, and Governor Mansions. How much of a regime change in policy occurs remains to be seen.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree that the Iran war was a big part of it. But there was DOGE and throwing UDAID into the wood chipper, and all the federal employees who lost their jobs. And ICE in Minneapolis. And Chicago. And the naked corruption. All of that happened before the Iran War. It was everything.

      Delete
    2. ...and don't forget the tariffs.

      Delete
  7. Interesting NYT observation:

    Democrats’ midterm victories may raise the chances that enough states sign onto a mechanism that, in theory, could elect the next president effectively by popular vote instead of through the typical rules of the Electoral College.

    The party’s surge in Tuesday’s elections included gaining a hold on the governor’s office and both statehouse chambers in at least four states, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin. Those states could join an agreement called the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, which promises that participants would give all their electoral votes to the presidential ticket that wins the national popular vote.

    But the agreement, which has been more popular among Democrats, takes effect only once signed by states representing a majority of the Electoral College, or at least 270 electoral votes, the amount needed to win the presidency. Eighteen states and the District of Columbia have adopted the compact so far, representing 222 electoral votes.

    If all four of the states that just won total Democratic control were to join the agreement, it would tip the group over the 270-vote threshold. Arizona, which is allotted 11 electoral votes, was also projected to have a blue trifecta, though not all of its races had been called by Thursday evening.

    Lawmakers in key states said on Thursday that they had already begun having conversations this week about introducing legislation to join the agreement in the next session and were hopeful that they would succeed ahead of 2028. But broadening the compact could present a mighty political lift.

    “The time is right,” Carrie Rheingans, a Democrat in the Michigan House of Representatives, said in an interview. “This blue tsunami is really going to help push this forward across the whole nation.”

    Still, Democratic lawmakers “can be apprehensive” with a new majority, said Mattie Daughtry, the Democratic president of Maine’s State Senate. She worked on the compact issue for over a decade before her state joined in 2024.

    “The biggest roadblock is convincing them to use these majorities to do big things,” Ms. Daughtry said.

    In 2019, Nevada’s Democratic governor vetoed a bill to join the agreement, saying it could diminish smaller states’ influence in presidential elections.

    Now, it is unclear whether lawmakers will prioritize passing the compact after running campaigns dominated by other concerns, like easing high costs and imposing guardrails on the Trump administration.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This would be a fine example of overreach.

      Delete
    2. I don't see it as overreach as much as a wrong-headed priority right now, and that's the type of thing Democrats get distracted with.

      You cannot pile a lot of new initiatives on the deck of a ship that is listing dangerously because it is full of holes below the waterline. Those holes are cruel and draconian immigration policies, foreign war entanglements, health care costs, lack of guardrails on the executive, HHS's abandonment of science (and general incompetence of most cabinet secretaries), and the collapse of Social Security.

      Delete
    3. Fixing the electoral college system would be overreach? Really? But that’s a long shot. What else would be overreach in your eyes?

      Delete
    4. News flash. Susie Wiles is gone and Steven Miller is the new chief of staff. I had been worried that trumps fury at the blue tsunami would produce a backlash and even more evil overreach than usual. The hate of this administration is now enshrined in the Oval Office staff. MIller won’t be hiding in the background anymore. The hate will continue full speed ahead.

      Delete
    5. "Fixing the electoral college system would be overreach? Really? But that’s a long shot."

      There is nothing wrong with the electoral college system, except that it allows the other party to win presidential elections from time to time.

      And of course, to blame the "problem" on the electoral college is a bit of misdirection. The real alleged issue is the arrangement that conducts elections as 51 separate state elections rather than a single, popular-vote election.

      The prescribed treatment would be far worse for the patient than the "disease". We should be looking for less populism, not more.

      It's overreach because fiddling with the Constitution isn't why Democrats were elected.

      Delete
    6. Some possibilities for overreach - these are taken from my research assistant Google Gemini's summary of the Congressional Progressive Caucus's legislative priorities:

      * Price controls on insulin and other drugs
      * A trillion-dollar spend on public housing
      * Rent-control pricing regulations
      * "Cracking down on price-fixing by major grocers"
      * Punitive taxes on billionaires and Big Oil
      * "Ending mass incarceration"
      * Defunding the police

      There is a lot more - raising the minimum wage, the Green New Deal, etc.

      Apart from most of these already having been tried and having brought about really bad unintended consequences within our living memory, none of these is the reason that voters who voted for Trump in 2024 turned to Democrats in 2026.

      Delete
    7. I get that some of these things I've listed as progressive priorities could be popular with American voters, and that most of them probably are popular with most people here.

      I also get that, now having achieved an enormous majority in the House and a decisive majority in the Senate, progressives in particular will put pressure on the Democrats in Congress to take "big swings" - to do the opposite of the normal, disciplined approach I called for above. The pundits tell us that the 2028 election campaign has now begun, and Democrats will feel they owe the American people to achieve things with these big majorities.

      I think it's possible to likely that Democrats will spend the next two years in Congress passing progressive agenda items like those I listed in my previous comment, with the certain knowledge that Trump will veto them. Trump, for his part, will relish positioning himself as the Great Thwarter Of The Progressive Agenda. He thrives on conflict and chaos.

      Delete
    8. Jim, while you were busy chatting with Gemini about progressive overreach, I listed the things that I, a real-live progressive, thought Congress should prioritize. I'll list them again: cruel and draconian immigration policies, foreign war entanglements, health care costs, lack of guardrails on the executive, HHS's abandonment of science (and general incompetence of most cabinet secretaries), and the collapse of Social Security.

      I don't see the point of throwing AI listicles at each other when we have real people's ideas to respond to, and generally I leave discussions on here when somebody drags in AI.

      I do agree that Trump will enjoy vetoing things and sending Stephen Miller out to goad Democrats about it. But the above might gain enough Repub support to override vetoes. As a real-live conservative, you could tell us if you think that's likely.

      Delete
    9. Of course Trump will sic Stephen Miller on people like a junkyard dog with rabies. But he's been that all along.
      There are things progressives want the new congress to do, and things conservatives are afraid they will do. But there are things they have to do. One of them is to restore the guardrails on the presidency which are already there, that Trump has been blowing past daily. Another is to work on restoring relationships with our allies. And ending the presences of masked thugs with no accountability on our cities' streets. I don't see them prioritizing most of the things on Jim's Gemini's list, with the exception of some low hanging fruit like price controls on insulin

      Delete
    10. I don't see Gemini Jim's list in the works, either. Bernie was pitching some of them (e.g., the 5 percent billionaire tax, $20 per hour minimum wage, Medicare for all) on his YouTube channel. But Bernie has been pushing this since 1975.

      Reallocating funds to SNAP and Medicaid seems more doable in the next 2 years than a major overhaul in safety net programs. I think those modest fixes need to be the basis for a larger discussion about how Democrats would make our "welfare programs" more streamlined and effective in 2028.

      I saw last night that Trump has signed an EO saying that the Oval Office with all his golden doodads will be a protected heritage site that cannot be altered. If Dems are going to start curtailing EO's, that one would be good to use as a wedge to open the way to nullifying his other idiocies like renaming geographical features.

      Delete
    11. Jean, I already researched that issue. His effort to preserve his tasteless gold gewgaws is not an executive order but a proclamation declaring the rooms to be National Monuments. Future presidents can do what they want. They can rip it all out on Jan 21, 2029. I’m praying that the arch can be stopped until the Dems take their seats. They will control funding. He’s used his handpicked committee to authorize it and wanted to start construction two days ago. Fortunately a DC judge halted it for two weeks so that they could produce documents and cost estimates that have been requested several times but which haven’t appeared. And to be able to hear the lawsuits seeking to stop it from DC, Virginia and some veterans groups. This judge doesn’t like to be blown off, and she stopped the planned construction shortly before midnight of the planned start date. They were of course using their standard game plan - ignore the laws, and do a lot of damage before they can be stopped. The arch is ridiculous to begin with and his desired design is way, way too big - it will look hideous. It will also cause increased traffic problems in a particularly heavy traffic area snd obliterate the sight line between Arlington goon National Cemetery aand the Lincoln Memorial. Trump has hinted that he wants it named after him. What has he done to deserve any permanent monument to his horrible presidency, one of the worst— probably the worst— in American history?

      Delete
    12. Thanks, so his document re Oval Office is a proclamation that does not have the same teeth as an EO? Good to know. The report I read was not really clear about whether this was in any way binding.

      Delete
    13. Sorry about all the typos. It happens all the time on the iPad.

      Delete
    14. "Jim, while you were busy chatting with Gemini about progressive overreach, I listed the things that I, a real-live progressive, thought Congress should prioritize. I'll list them again: cruel and draconian immigration policies, foreign war entanglements, health care costs, lack of guardrails on the executive, HHS's abandonment of science (and general incompetence of most cabinet secretaries), and the collapse of Social Security."

      Yes, you are right (and I apologize for not engaging). Most of the items on your list fall within the broad category of reining in Trump. I think that's exactly why Democrats were elected.

      I see fixing Social Security and Medicare funding as something that should transcend partisanship. It would be wonderful if the president and the Congress could collaborate on that. That would be a more durable legacy for the president than a ballroom or an arch.

      Delete
    15. Thanks for your response, Jim.

      I don't know where the current crop of lawmakers stand on Social Security. A lot of conservatives want to grandfather it out in favor of a 401K type deal or to means test it. A lot of progressives want to tax the rich and establish a guaranteed minimum payment.

      Both parties seem equally happy to raid SS funds, so a good start might be to sequester it, but I don't know all the nuances that might entail.

      I doubt that Trump would see saving SS as a fitting legacy. Nothing to glue his golden doodads on.

      Medicare is a whole different problem, imo. Medicare recipients haven't paid into the program as they have for SS. And Medicare recipients have the most expensive and lingering ailments.

      As a result, Medicare is also part of the broader health care expense problem. The company Dad worked for had excellent Medicare supplemental insurance--surgeries, mental health hospitalizations, drug rehab, the latest meds, loads of second opinions, travel expenses to specialists--were all covered.

      But I read recently where the company said they want to get out from under the admin costs and coverage increases. So next year, they will give retirees a set amount and turn them loose on the marketplace.

      Many/most people, including Medicare recipients, are now living in a situation in which coverage changes every year.

      So my sense is that a fix for Medicare needs to be part of the larger health care debate.

      Delete
  8. Some unsettling news I just read: Stephen Miller is going to take Susie Wiles' place ( I guess she is resigning? Got let go?) I don't know that he can do any more harm in that position than he has already done. But I'd rather not have Nosferatu anywhere near power.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sorry Anne. I didn't see your comment before I posted.

      Delete
  9. Katherine, here's something to help you enjoy this moment of relief you talked about. Bette Midler at 80 belting out Woody Guthrie with Barbara Hershey. Very fun! https://youtu.be/uBj57ivPsxQ?si=GjApR03KLFb88k_d

    ReplyDelete
  10. Those who follow Catholic news more faithfully than I may already have seen this. Apologies in advance if it's old news. NCR breaks down of the midterm "Catholic vote."

    https://www.ncronline.org/opinion/guest-voices/whats-matter-catholic-voters

    ReplyDelete
  11. Jim— what you see as overreach, others see as needed reforms. I don’t see most of the items on the Gemini list as priorities for most progressives. Price caps on insulin actually started with trump’s first term - limited to selected subsgroups of Medicare patients. It was expanded under Biden. I don’t think there are as many caravans to Canada these days. They used to go in groups because they could buy insulin OTC at pharmacies there at $30/vial instead of $100. This should be done with other meds too.

    Price fixing has always been illegal but the government has been looking at some sneaky ways the food industry— not just large grocery chains—is colluding on food prices, especially beef. They are also wanting to look into collusion among suppliers, and at the new technology of '"dynamic" pricing", apparently tailored to the individual while shopping- using facial recognition and changing prices on the shelf dynamically. I have no idea how this works. Walmart has denied doing it even though they now have the ability to change shelf pricing without human help.

    I haven’t heard of rent control as a national issue. My late sister in law lived in a rent controlled apartment in NYC for 55 years. She was a legal librarian and librarians, even in law firms, don’t make a lot of money. I think rent control is mostly a local issue. Because of rent control she was able to stay in her tiny one bedroom apartment for all those years instead of being forced to move out of the city.

    I haven’t heard anything about defunding police since the George Floyd murder. The priority now is reining in ICE.

    Tax reform --Trump pretty much admitted he didn't pay taxes on his millions. I would like to see tax reform that would ensure that multi- millionaires and above can't escape all taxes as trump apparently did ("just means I'm smart.", Plus he went to Congress personally and wangled big tax breaks for real estate developers. I guess machine he repaid them in donations ). I don't think having millionaires and billionaires pay taxes is overreach.
    Continued

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Universal healthcare--I also would like the US to join every other rich country in the world to provide universal healthcare. We pay anywhere from twice as much to eight times as much as any other rich country yet millions are still uninsured. This year average premiums for a family of four will reach $28,000. Those who work for large corporations will have about $20 k of that covered by the company, but others are out of luck. Plus the US is unique in having deductibles and co- pays on top of premiums. Not overreach to fix this but it would mean looking at healthcare as a right of citizenship rather than a profit making business. It's the only profit making healthcare system in the OECD. The minimum wage has been $7.25/hour since 2009 even though inflation has gone up 48% since then. This is why millions of minimum wage workers, including most employees of huge corporations like Walmart and Amazon can't survive without using federal assistance programs. So the taxpayers pay these exploited workers instead of the multimillion $ in profits companies. Not overreach to raise the minimum wage. Have you had raises since 2009, Jim?

      Delete
    2. It seems like the minimum wage has already de facto raised. Pretty much any retail or fast food job here pays $15 an hour (though a lot of them aren't full time) And we're a fly-over red state.

      Delete
    3. Yes, the states can set their own minimum wage and many have raised it to well above the official federal minimum wage. But many workers don’t get benefits because their employers set their hours to be less than full time. Walmart and Amazon are notorious for this. If the law requires benefits for full- time workers and the threshold for that is 30 hours/week they give enployees 29 hours only. Then $15/ hour doesn’t stretch very far. There are 20 states that have only the federal wage of $7.25/hour. Unsurprisingly, all are in red states - except Pennsylvania and North Carolina, which is now almost blue. Washington DC has the highest at $18/ hour.

      Delete
    4. I should clarify that my state hasn't raised their minimum wage to $15. It's just that they can't get reliable people to work for $7.25.

      Delete
    5. The market sets wages more efficiently than government.

      Delete
    6. "They are also wanting to look into collusion among suppliers, and at the new technology of '"dynamic" pricing", apparently tailored to the individual while shopping- using facial recognition and changing prices on the shelf dynamically. I have no idea how this works. Walmart has denied doing it even though they now have the ability to change shelf pricing without human help."

      I don't think it's legal for merchants to have different pricing for different customers at the same time. The rideshare companies like Uber use what they call dynamic pricing. A trip from my home to my office might cost $X during non-peak hours, but $3X during peak hours. I think, as long as the same peak pricing is offered uniformly to all customers during peak hours, that's legal.

      From a technology perspective, I think it would be possible for grocers like Walmart and Target with big online order / home delivery businesses to offer custom pricing to individual consumers. Similarly, travel sites like Expedia or Priceline could do the same for airline travel. But as I say, I don't think that's legal.

      Delete
    7. Yes, Jim, dynamic pricing definitely applies to services like Uber and to airlines. . But from what I have read, some are trying to use dynamic pricing on shelf prices for individuals while customers are shopping in the store personally. I have no idea how this would work. Walmart has denied using it even though they now use some kind of computer controlled price tags — not staff manually changing prices on the shelf. I don’t have any idea how this works. Airlines have used dynamic pricing for years and, if you don’t clean the cache, if you price out a flight but don’t buy, it will remember you if you return to buy a ticket and the price will usually be higher. I use two browsers and I have often seen different prices for the same ticket on them. I’m not sure how clear the law is on airline dynamic pricing. It’s legal. They defend it on the grounds that it’s all a function of supply and demand at the moment you’re looking. Third party services like Expedia or Priceline often reserve a block of tickets and blocks of rooms in hotels, and their prices are more stable until getting close to the trip date. If they haven’t resold all their plane tickets or rooms the price might go down. If their inventory is tight it might go up. But it doesn’t vary every minute as it does with airlines.

      Delete
  12. This may dovetail with Jim's comment above about the need for Democrats to be "disciplined":

    I don't think the country is ready right now for big debates about overhauling national programs and priorities like Medicare for All and the minimum wage, much as I support them. Like any effective tyrant, Trump has exhausted everybody and worn nerves to a frazzle.

    Independents and any Republicans who voted blue to put Democrats over the top just want gas and cartage prices to come down to improve affordability (that's partly predicated on getting out of Iran), and allocations restored that will protect their local hospitals, schools, and services. They also want protections against AI and datacenters. To a lesser degree, they want accountability.

    Given that many states now have a Democratic trifecta, some more progressive initiatives could be pursued there.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I think you’re right, Jean. The very needed, very big reforms like universal healthcare and minimum wage will have to stay on the back burner at least until 2028. If the Dems win thevWH then and maintain a grip on at least one house of Congress it might be possible. Trump’s drastic healthcare cuts won’t really hit voters until a month or two - deliberately timed to be after the mid- terms. Once some of these draconian cuts kick in, along with the steep increases in health insurance costs, voters might decide to stay blue a while longer.

    I mentioned that several progressive Protestants had won election, or reelection. They are fluent in s rupture too. An article in the NYT today discusses the Matthew 25 Democrats. I look at Matthew 25:31-46 as providing the details to Love thy neighbor. I have seen conservative, apparently libertarian, Catholics argue that using “ their money” via taxes to help the poor is wrong, making the same argument as Johnson. Which is ludicrous on the face.

    https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/08/briefing/the-bible-chapter-that-helps-explain-the-new-christian-left.html?unlocked_article_code=1.O1E.dEzp.n39Olp1Sqy_W&smid=nytcore-ios-share

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. One of my friends is currently being driven batty by FB posts from her nutty in-laws "proving" that Democratic Christians are perverting Scripture. I expect the weirder evangelicals will enjoy waging holier-than-thou wars.

      And, yes, the parish line locally is that we are obligated to *help* the poor, but not necessarily with govt programs. One of the Church Ladies says that helping the poor includes not letting them get dependent on handouts. So she hands out nothing.

      Hope you are recovering apace and are doing ok with care for your husband. I know it is very hard to be sick yourself and have family responsibilities that are physically impossible. I started cardiac rehab and have made good gains in the last couple weeks.

      Delete
    2. The FB posts (shared by people I know) that drive me batty are the ones like the one that show pictures of Abdul Al Sayed and Ilhan Omar, saying that Muslim countries wouldn't let Christians run for office, and if we allow them to run, pretty soon we're all going to be under Sharia law. I've tried countering them with actual statistics, such as the percent of Americans who are Muslim is around 1%, and Sharia here is a religious thing practiced voluntarily, and couldn't supercede the Constitution. But it is useless to argue with them because they just want to rant about stupid stuff.

      Delete
    3. Anne and Jean, I hope you are both recovering well. Still praying for you. Jean, glad you are doing cardiac rehab.

      Delete
    4. The rehab folks are great, a few of the dozens who put forth their best effort just to keep one crabby old lady alive! Never in my life have I felt so grateful to so many people. The least I can do to honor their work is to keep up what they started.

      Delete
    5. Jean, I’m glad your recovery is going well. Mine is very slow. I won’t be able to resume a normal diet for at least another two to four weeks.

      My big concern now is that I may be banned from tying my husband’s wheelchair down in our van. I can’t lift more than ten pounds for another four weeks and my husband has dr and rehab appointments. His caregiver will return in the evening to get him into bed with the Hoyer but she has another client at 1 pm. Shes been driving him to all of his appointments because the other client is on vacation but they will be back a week from tomorrow. He can get himself up the ramp if he uses his power wheelchair but he can’t secure it. I will be seeing my surgeon next week and will ask him if I’m really not supposed to do the tie downs until the full six weeks are done. It will complicate everything. But I doubt I can hire someone to come for ten minutes to tie the chair down, and ten minutes again a couple of hours later to release the tie downs. I think releasing shouldn’t be a problem but I may have to call on some neighbors to pull out the retractable tie downs to secure the chair. Sigh.

      Delete
    6. Do they have a handicapped van service in your area?

      Delete
    7. Yes, but I assume they are very expensive. Before we bought our van in San Jose every round trip to a dr or rehab (about 20 minutes away) cost about $150. There was a county service that he was eligible for but they wouldn’t guarantee times for pick up. So we had to use a private service. NYC has taxis with ramps that don’t cost more than regular taxis but I don’t know about here. Good idea. I will look into it.

      Delete
    8. Katherine, you’re brilliant! There are ramp taxis here and they aren’t allowed to charge wheelchair passengers more than regular passengers. This is true in Barcelona too our son tells us. But not in San Jose CA. San Francisco has them as well as NYC but I don’t know who else does.

      Delete
    9. Katherine, please direct prayers from me to my health care workers--the doc who repaired my mitral valve, the anesthetists who clued me in on the lingering effects of the drugs, the OR nurse who held my hand and joked with me during the countdown and gave Raber hourly updates during surgery, the respiratory therapy staff who checked my O2 all night and taught me breathing exercises, the nurses who helped me stand up and walk the day after surgery and followed behind me with a wheel chair, the oncology consults who managed the cancer, the staff who kept me and my room clean, the techs who took out all the tubes and did stitch-ups, the lab people who were good at making blood gas draws painless, the food service folks who always had time to chat, the chaplain, the therapy dog people, the PT techs, the occupational therapists, the surgeon's office staff, the x-ray techs who checked my innards every day, the home oxygen and mobility techs, and the folks at the thoracentisis center.

      We maybe don't think of all the people we depend on on a daily basis until something like this happens and we become helpless for a time.

      Delete
    10. Health care workers of all kinds are unsung heroes. Most of them are there because of a desire to help people. For sure they need our prayers.

      Delete
  14. I don’t follow main stream media so I don’t know how much this has been reported. On Saturday, a shooter drive into the main square of Krakow and shot six people to death and injured fifteen before the cops rammed his car and engaged in fire, wounding him. He has recently died from his injuries. There were three bodies found at his residence. Neighbors said he was troubled. They’re saying now he was right wing. This is taking place during a conflict over high court appointments. By the way, the shooting took place right near the hotel where I stayed. I’m leaving for Poland on Thanksgiving and will be in Krakow for two days. This happens often here but is so far rare in Poland which is why it saddens me. And right before the Christmas festive season.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Guardian has reported on this daily, 6 dead, 16 injured so far. Cops are looking at terrorism as a motive based on insignia the killer, 24, attached to his clothes.

      Seems like a classic mass killing like we see here: "Troubled" young man in teens or 20s gloms on to a gun in the house, offs his family first, then looks to take out as many people as he can in a shooting frenzy before the cops get him.

      My guess is that they'll find evidence that he was inspired by other mass shooters and focused his rage against women, immigrants, co-workers, etc.

      Depressingly familiar story.

      Delete
    2. The Guardian had good coverage. I followed Polsat News as well. I expect the area will have been set off for a memorial when I’m there. I attended the Polish mass this past Sunday and Fr. Wojciech spoke of it during his sermon on the maidens unprepared for the wedding.

      Delete
    3. It’s been covered in the mainstream media - both the NYT and the WaPost ( which really isn’t mainstream anymore but right- wing). We stayed in Krakow for a day and overnight when driving to our son’s wedding in Kazimierz Dolny from Prague. The story makes me sad too - a lovely, peaceful town. A lovely peaceful country. We have exported so much poison to the world. And even in peaceful, safe countries, some drink it.

      Delete
    4. The WaPo moved right when Bezos took over and most of their best opinion writers left. But a couple from the bench stayed. One is Max Boot. His column today summarizes the situation pretty well.

      https://wapo.st/4iCvwl2

      Delete
    5. Anne, flying out on Thanksgiving Day and returning 6 Dec. Agenda is Zakopane, Kraków, Wrocław, Gdańsk. Unfortunately, not Kazimiersz Dolny this time. M has relatives in Gdańsk. Going with M, her daughter and daughter’s boyfriend. When they go to the spa in Gdańsk, I’ll do my Solidarność history tour. One of my substitute Polish teachers in Gdynia used to see Lech Wałęsa at Sunday mass.

      Delete
  15. Ross Douthat does a very creditable job interviewing Prez Trump on 60 Minutes, possibly despite Bari Weiss's hopes he would be her conservative lap dog. https://youtu.be/JklRXlv69t4?si=ksGwq2QOFuVD_tAy

    Mostly Doouthat kept Trump on track and fact-checked except when Trump started to spew word salad about corruption and how he made $3 billion while in office.

    However, things took a strange turn at the end (abt 25 minute mark) where Douthat asks if Trump could forgive his enemies "at the throne of God." The shift from politics and policies of general interest Trump's views on the afterlife struck me as irrelevant and silly.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'll have to watch the whole interview. I just saw the part that Adam Kinzinger shared on his podcast, which was that last part where Douthat asked Trump about his views on the afterlife. I didn't think it was silly. I thought it was chilling to listen to how consumed with bitterness Trump is. I'm not really surprised. But this is who the guy is. He said he can't forgive, and basically doesn't want to. I'll have to pray for him, whether I want to or not.

      Delete
    2. I could see asking whether Trump could work with various personalities he has reviled in the past. But forgiving enemies after death seemed aimed at "proving" something about Trump with a theological/theoretical question that didn't fit the interview.

      Delete
    3. It is telling that none of the people Trump hates and won't forgive did anything like physically harm him or defrauded him. They just said bad things about him and tried to call him to account.

      Delete
    4. M'okay, but "Why are you spending govt resources on what some have called a personal vendetta against James Comey?" strikes me as a better question than what Trump thinks he would do at the throne if God.

      Delete
    5. Well, and about two hundred other questions about pursuing a personal vendetta against the American people. But the American people had an answer of their own to that.

      Delete
    6. I understand your points, Katherine. Best I can do is ask God to fix him before he runs us all off a cliff.

      Just seemed like Douthat's last question was trying to Christian-shame Trump into some kind of humility, which, perhaps indirectly designed to showcase Douthat's own piety. I wasn't surprised by Trump's answer, but who can say how they will feel on their deathbed or at the Throne? Any number of things could happen to Trump to get him to wake up and die right.

      Delete
    7. Jean- “Just seemed like Douthat's last question was trying to Christian-shame Trump into some kind of humility, which, perhaps indirectly designed to showcase Douthat's own piety”.

      That was my first thought too after reading your discussion. I didn’t see the interview (I don’t bother watching either of those two) just based on your discussion of it.

      Delete
    8. I am not sure what Douthat's purpose was in asking that questions. One possibility - and I think, probably the most likely - is that this is something that Douthat is genuinely interested in and asked Trump because he's interested in Trump's personality and character and was interested to hear the answer.

      Another possibility is that Douthat was trying to demonstrate to Trump's Christian MAGA base what a non-Christian they have hitched their political fate to.

      Delete
    9. But Douthat is borderline MAGA himself unless he’s changed a lot since I stopped reading his co,un.

      Delete
    10. As a reporter, Douthat should not be trying to demonstrate anything to Trump's MAGA base. He should be asking neutral questions about how Trump will handle losing his GOP majorities and what he might leave as his legacy.

      Douthat might be personally interested to know what Trump would do at the throne of God. I'm interested in knitting and science fiction. But I would not throw those topics into an interview if my subject had not raised those issues himself.

      Overall, though, I think Douthat did a good job.

      Delete
    11. "But Douthat is borderline MAGA himself unless he’s changed a lot since I stopped reading his co,un."

      I don't think he's MAGA. I don't think the NY Times has ever had an opinion writer, at least during the Trump era, that could be considered MAGA. He is conservative, but I don't think he's Trumpy at all. I'm not really sure how to categorize him. I wouldn't say he's Reaganite or Libertarian or Neocon, either. He writes about politics, foreign affairs, the Catholic church, his health, films - he's pretty wide-ranging.

      Delete
    12. I don't see Douthat as MAGA, either. Country Club Republican, very little awareness about people outside his own privileged class except as abstract "social problems," but probably a good family man and interesting dinner conversationalist, who would find Trump vulgar and dull.

      Delete
    13. "As a reporter, Douthat should not be trying to demonstrate anything to Trump's MAGA base. He should be asking neutral questions about how Trump will handle losing his GOP majorities and what he might leave as his legacy."

      Aren't asking gotcha questions to powerful figures while the cameras roll kind of 60 Minutes' stock in trade?

      I could be wrong - I think the show has been on the air nearly as long as I've been alive, and I've never really been a watcher. I've seen segments and snippets here and there over the years, but it comes on during dinner time!

      Delete
    14. Jim, I said Douthat is borderline MAGA. This comment on a Reddit discussion is pretty close to how I see Douthat.

      “ Let's stop pretending: Ross Douthat isn't some above-the-fray intellectual - he's a MAGA apologist in a bow tie, trying to intellectualize his way into making Trump acceptable while maintaining his "reasonable conservative" credentials.”

      Delete
    15. I disagree with the Reddit comment, too.

      Delete
    16. Well, it seems you are giving him a pass for whatever reasons, and I don’t. Nor does the Reddit poster. He tried to come across as not-trumpy, but he failed. I’m a bit surprised that you don’t see it.

      Delete
    17. I admire anyone normal who can watch any interview with Trump for an extended amount of time. It would be strange to see someone, Douthat or otherwise, conversing with Trump as if he is a human normal in any way, shape or form. Before I was permanently firewalled by America, I had a comment taken down because I said the Trump administration was the country essentially being run by first graders. I feel that was an accurate statement and we shouldn’t, in the cause of inauthentic politeness, treat madmen as if they weren’t madmen.

      Delete
    18. I didn’t watch the interview as I simply can’t stand even looking at photos of Trump. I read Douthat in the NYT —until I stopped because I decided he wasn’t worth the time. So I’ve only read about the interview.

      Stanley, Every one of my comments at America has been automatically held for “review” for several years. That started when I referred to the church’s bad habit of censoring people, including silencing more than 130 theologians, nuns, and priests during the JPII/ Ratzinger/ Benedict years ( some were redeemed once Francis came in) . The censorship included the Vatican’s threat to America that they would have to submit every issue to Rome before publication if they didn’t fire Thomas Reese as editor. America apparently didn’t like me bringing this up.

      Delete
    19. Anne, I agree. America hasn't been the same since Fr. Reese got purged. It's been very tame. And since the Gaza "ceasefire", the endless, horrid suffering inflicted on the Palestinians hasn't gotten a mention. Move on now, nothing to see here. It's as if AIPAC is also a big America donor and who knows anymore? I mourn the loss of the America Magazine I used to love but exists no more.

      Delete
  16. What else would you expect from Ross Douthat?

    ReplyDelete