Wednesday, March 31, 2021

Mass Obligation

 I read this afternoon that the three bishops in my state have announced that the dispensation from the Sunday or weekend Mass obligation which has been in place is ending May 1.  There is still a lot of wiggle room; people are not obligated if they have fears for their health, or they are taking care of someone in  a vulnerable category.  It won't affect us personally, we have been going in person since the beginning of last June.  But I feel the bishops are jumping the gun.  The state has just now opened up vaccination to all adults. They can sign up for appointments regardless of age. But by no means everyone will be covered by May 1, especially if they are getting the Pfizer or Moderna shots, which are two appointments 3 and 4 weeks apart respectively. I feel that they should wait until everyone who wants to be vaccinated has had the chance, and enough time (2 to 3 weeks?) has gone by for full immunity to take place. 

How about your area, is the dispensation from the Mass obligation ending soon also?

Tuesday, March 30, 2021

Monday, March 29, 2021

The NY Times' Biden/Trump geography quiz


I frittered away a good deal of my lunchtime today taking this pictorial quiz from the NY Times.  It works as follows: the website displays a 360-degree snapshot of a residential neighborhood, somewhere in the US.  Your mission, should you choose to accept it, is to size up whatever you can from the pictures: housing, yards, vehicles, surrounding area, vegetation, etc., and decide whether the precinct you are looking at went for Biden or Trump in the last election.

I looked at 20 photos.  I started out on fire: had 8 out of the first 10 correct, including one or two which the vast majority of NY Times readers had missed.  But then I cooled off considerably.  I think I finished with 11 out of 20, which was a pretty middling (or worse) performance: I finished in the upper 75%.  

I will offer one hint: it's worth waiting to see the camera rotate the entire 360 degrees before making up your mind, as some of the photos are taken from streets which have one characteristic (e.g. rural fields) on one side and another characteristic (suburban housing tract) on the other.

The newspaper apparently has over 10,000 photos available, and assuming the photos are presented to you at random, you will not be quizzed on the same photos I was.    

Friday, March 26, 2021

Immigration

Some of you may have seen Jim McCrea's email thread in which he links an article by Andrew Sullivan, titled What Biden Doesn't Get On Immigration. Sullivan takes Biden sharply to task. I commented on the article.  I am bringing my comment, and the link to the Sullivan article, over here for discussion. 

Thursday, March 25, 2021

Will the vaccines out run the variants?

This appears to be good news. Take a look at the article it has some nice graphs.  I  pay a lot of attention to the daily data from the NY Times. The rapid fall for the last two months leveled off into a slower fall a few weeks ago and now is either plateauing or going up again.  

U.S. COVID cases are climbing again. The same thing happened in Israel — before vaccination crushed the variants.


It’s official: After falling for more than two straight months, the average number of daily COVID-19 cases across the U.S. has begun — just barely — to rise again, inching up from a low of 54,059 earlier this week to 57,322 on Wednesday.

So is this the start of the variant-driven “fourth wave” that Americans have been fearing ever since the end of our horrific holiday surge?

The answer, reassuringly, appears to be no — at least not if America’s path out of the pandemic looks anything like Israel’s.

To date, more than a quarter of the U.S. population (25.3 percent) has received at least one dose of a safe and effective COVID-19 vaccine. In Israel, that number is more than 57 percent. Because of its rapid vaccine rollout — and because the more contagious “U.K. variant” known as B.1.1.7 that’s now spreading in the U.S. has already been dominant in Israel for months — experts have been eyeing Israel for early signs of how the pitched battle between vaccination and variants is likely to play out in America.

When Israel launched its vaccination campaign on Dec. 19, the virus was already surging; a few days later, the country entered its third national lockdown. Over the next month, however, cases continued to climb another 150 percent. By Jan. 25, B.1.1.7 had superseded all other strains in the country.

“The vaccine works against the British mutation, but the virus infection rate is much faster than the vaccine rate,” Sharon Alroy-Preis, head of public health at the Health Ministry, told the Knesset. “We are at a record number of people on ventilators. It’s unprecedented.”

Before long, the nation’s strict lockdown had its desired effect, and Israel’s curve finally began to bend downward. But that’s when researchers realized something else as well: The curve was bending even more among the first seniors to be immunized. Distancing wasn’t the only factor at play. Vaccination seemed to be working.

But despite moments during the winter when it seemed as if Israel’s case count was leveling off or even rebounding, vaccination access, eligibility and uptake continued to increase — and another wave never arrived. Now more than 50 percent of Israelis have been fully vaccinated, and the country is averaging fewer than 1,000 new daily cases for the first time since November — a number that has plummeted nearly 75 percent over the last two and a half weeks alone.

Crucially, that sharp drop in infections came after Israel partially reopened in February, and it has continued in the weeks since the country fully reopened on March 7. 

My comment: It looks like Israel did more than vaccinate, it also had lock downs that sound like they were more serious than ours have been.  It looks like we will be able to vaccinate everyone who wants it. I am not sure enough will actually take up the offer. 

 Here in the Ohio the State legislature just handcuffed the Governor's ability to issue health mandates by overriding his veto. Not sure we are safe as long as we have Republican majorities in our state legislatures. Legislatures micromanaging pandemics is not healthy. 


Wednesday, March 24, 2021

Dreams

 Any dream interpreters out there?

Preaching the Bad News

Update 3/24/2021 9:19 am CST: I see that, as I was preparing this post, Jack contributed a post based on the same story.  Interesting to see another viewpoint!

-----

Every morning I receive an enewsletter from David Leonhardt of the New York Times.  Today he reports on research which seems to show that the US national media consistently emphasized the negative aspects of the COVID-19 pandemic, even when there was positive news to share.

Negative bias in Nation Media Coverage of Covid

Hopefully because it is Covid coverage this is not behind a paywall, but I have quoted it extensively just in case 

Covid Coverage by National Media in US is an Outlier

The coverage by U.S. publications with a national audience has been much more negative than coverage by any other source that the researchers analyzed, including scientific journals, major international publications and regional U.S. media. “The most well-read U.S. media are outliers in terms of their negativity,” Molly Cook, a co-author of the study, told me.

About 87 percent of Covid coverage in national U.S. media last year was negative. The share was 51 percent in international media, 53 percent in U.S. regional media and 64 percent in scientific journals.

Notably, the coverage was negative in both U.S. media outlets with liberal audiences (like MSNBC) and those with conservative audiences (like Fox News).

Sacerdote is careful to emphasize that he does not think journalists usually report falsehoods. The issue is which facts they emphasize. Still, the new study — which the National Bureau of Economic Research has published as a working paper, titled, “Why is all Covid-19 news bad news?” — calls for some self-reflection from those of us in the media.

The researchers say they are not sure what explains their findings, but they do have a leading contender: The U.S. media is giving the audience what it wants.

When the researchers examined which stories were the most read or the most shared on Facebook, they tended to be the most negative stories. To put it another way, the stories that people choose to read skew even more negative than the stories that media organizations choose to publish. “Human beings, particularly consumers of major media, like negativity in their stories,” Sacerdote said. “We think the major media are responding to consumer demand.”

That idea is consistent with the patterns in the data, Sacerdote added: It makes sense that national publications have better instincts about reaching a large audience than, say, science journals. And overseas, some of the most influential English-language media organizations — like the BBC — have long received government funding, potentially making them less focused on consumer demand.

All of that sounds plausible to me, but I don’t think it is the full explanation.

In the modern era of journalism — dating roughly to the Vietnam War and Watergate — we tend to equate impact with asking tough questions and exposing problems. There are some good reasons for that. We are inundated by politicians, business executives, movie stars and others trying to portray themselves in the best light. Our job is to cut through the self-promotion and find the truth. If we don’t tell you the bad news, you may never hear it.

Sometimes, though, our healthy skepticism can turn into reflexive cynicism, and we end up telling something less than the complete story.

My take on the findings and explanations:

Monday, March 22, 2021

Silly COVID songs - Updated

 Discovered during idle moments on the world's longest work conference call this past weekend:

This is the Phoenix Chamber Choir, which is based, not in Arizona but Vancouver: an a capella rewrite of Billy Joel's "For the Longest Time".  Observe the use of the Clorox Wipes container as a rhythm instrument.  We'd classify this one as mildly silly. [Update: original post had the link to a silly song on some other topic - now corrected. H/T, Jim McCrea.]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LpAKcQufacc

Raising (or lowering) the silliness quotient to an entirely different level, this one-person re-imagining of Queen's "Bohemian Rhapsody".  Very silly, but some pretty impressive vocals by Raul Irabien.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Eo9M4-BrJA


Sunday, March 21, 2021

Sir, we would like to see Jesus

 This is my homily for today, the 5th Sunday of Lent, Cycle B. 

 Note: many parishes use the Cycle A readings during the 3rd, 4th and 5th Sundays of Lent, even during the years of Cycle B and C.  That is because those parishes have candidates who are going through RCIA to be initiated, and the Cycle A readings are appropriate on this Sunday, regardless of the year, whenever RCIA is active, as this would be one of the RCIA Scrutiny Sundays.  Somewhat ironically in light of the homily which follows, which (spoiler alert) is about seeking and initiation, our parish doesn't have any candidates this year, so we are using the readings appointed for Cycle B.  

The Cycle B readings for today are here.  The Cycle B Gospel reading for today isn't proclaimed very frequently on weekends in our parish (as most years we do have RCIA running) - if you didn't hear it proclaimed in your parish this weekend, it may be worth taking a moment to read it before reading the homily.

The Gender and Sexuality Wars

With the Equality Act in the news, discussions of gender and sexuality have remained heated.  Proponents say that its focus is to prevent discrimination.  Opponents say that it does more than that; that it erodes religious freedom and enforces an unscientific definition of sexual identity.  Everyone, it seems has a dog in the fight. It is hard to find anything resembling an objective discussion of the sexuality and gender issues. 

This article in the Atlantic Magazine is a couple of years old, but I thought it was a good discussion, especially as regards parenting, and didn't jump uncritically on the gender theory bandwagon. From the article:

Saturday, March 20, 2021

Praying in a Pigsty

Morning Prayer – Saturday, 20th March 2021 | Canterbury Cathedral

Join Dean Robert - and nine surprise arrivals 🐷 - for today’s Morning Prayer from The Deanery Garden at Canterbury Cathedral.

The Dean appears very comfortable in the pigsty. 

Betty grew up on a farm and so loves all sorts of animals. My grandparents were tenant dairy farmers; I remember work horses, and chickens in addition to the cows and a bull, and of course cats and a ferocious dog.. I think there were pigs at an earlier farm they rented when I was very young.

Thursday, March 18, 2021

Were we irresponsible?

This is a real-life story problem.  See if you agree with my solution.

Good news for carnivores

Just saw a notice that our local bishop, Cardinal Cupich, has waived the no-meat-on-Fridays-during-Lent rule for this coming Friday, March 19.  This is in observance of St. Joseph's Day, which is a Solemnity (highest-ranking category of saints' days) on the universal church calendar and so supersedes the normally penitential Friday of Lent.  

I confess that I don't suffer too much by not consuming protein on a few Fridays each year.  For one thing, I probably consume more meat throughout the rest of the year than some developing-world villages do, and almost certainly more than is good for me.  Also, my wife and I are sufficiently proficient in the kitchen (not to mention being blessed with ample carry-in options) that we have many (usually) tasty and (mostly) nutritious alternatives which don't run afoul of church rules.  If anything, Fridays during Lent become a nice change of pace.  

If that last observation strikes you as not exactly harmonious with the penitential intent of the season, I can only say you're not wrong.  But there is a certain spirituality in which we observe these dietary laws out of simple fidelity to the law, because fidelity to the law is a good thing, and perhaps that is enough.  Still: unreflective fidelity to the Law was the kind of thing for which Jesus slammed Pharisees in Mark's Gospel.  So maybe we can do better.  Starting a week from Friday.  For this Friday: something Italian (-American): maybe some Chicken Parmesan...  

Tuesday, March 16, 2021

Vaccinated

I went to Walgreens during lunchtime yesterday and got my first vaccination.  They gave me the Moderna vaccine, so I wasn't obligated to Google the USCCB website for any moral guidance.  (That's tongue in cheek.)  My arm is a little sore, and I've been draggy and headachy all afternoon and evening, although it's quite possible the latter two symptoms are more from this past weekend's "spring forward" time change than the vaccine.

I confess I'm relieved.  

Monday, March 15, 2021

Jesus and Nicodemus


 Yesterday's Gospel reading was that of the meeting of Jesus and Nicodemus, in which Nicodemus came to Jesus at night.  It is an example of Jesus meeting people where they are.  Jesus patiently answer's Nicodemus' questions.  The reading is from John 3:1-21, which includes the beloved John 3:16 verse, "..For God so loved the world..."

Sunday, March 14, 2021

Will the Real Biden Please Stand Up?

 My discipline, social psychology, emphasizes that while behavior is strongly determined by the social situation,  people usually view behavior as determined by personal characteristics such as personality, attitudes, beliefs and values. We habitually view people as agents of their own behavior rather than looking at the environmental influences.

As the media begins interpreting the Biden administration it is amusing how they are interpreting him. It is like the old television show in which panelists where asked to determine by questions which of three guests was the real X. The questions ended with the host asking for the real X to please stand up.

I started  thinking about this from the following article from The Civilta Cattolica, representing the mind of the Vatican since 1850, because it is read by the of office of the Vatican Secretary of State before being published by the Jesuits. The author is an American Jesuit

The United States from Trump to Biden: From insurrection to inauguration

Tuesday, March 9, 2021

This Commonweal Blog vs Cleveland Commonweal Local Community

Today is the fourth anniversary of NewGathering. 

Our first posts were on March 9, 2017. Thanks are due to everyone, both those who put this blog together and those who have kept it running.

On March 6, 2017 I signed up for the Cleveland Commonweal Local Community.


So I thought it might be interesting to compare the two.

Monday, March 8, 2021

Pope Francis' Trip to Iraq

 There has been a lot of media coverage of the pope's trip to Iraq, including articles in NCR and America Magazine (if you can get past the paywall). 

In an NCR article, Pope Francis "... urged Iraqi Christians not to lose hope and not to seek vengeance over their suffering during the brutal Islamic State regime, in a pair of poignant and dramatic visits March 7 to churches that were desecrated and destroyed by the terrorist militant group."

"Standing amid piles of the sand-colored brick rubble of four churches in a square in Mosul, under ISIS control from 2014 to 2017, the pontiff lamented the "tragic consequences of war and hostility," but said the desire for peace "can never be silenced by the blood spilled by those who pervert the name of God."

Friday, March 5, 2021

Have you ever heard of this organization? and its parish survey? UPDATE

An Eight Minute Introduction to the Survey by my Pastor

evidently this is being done everywhere in the Diocese of Cleveland

Faithful asked to participate in survey to assess spiritual health of parish life


Dan Cellucci, CEO of CLI, said the survey is a pilot program funded by an endowment. “The goal is to help parishes and priests thrive in ministry,” he said.

The Cleveland Diocese is one of 40 in the United States and Canada to participate in the survey. He estimated 1,500 parishes are involved, amounting to more than 250,000 parishioners. The survey is available in 14 languages.

He first connected with the diocese a few years ago while teaching a sabbatical class in Rome. Father Dan Schlegel, diocesan vicar for clergy and religious, was in the class and they stayed in touch, Cellucci said. He also has had a long relationship with Philadelphia Archbishop – and former Cleveland Bishop -- Nelson Perez, who participated in a CLI leadership program during the early years of his priesthood in Pennsylvania.

Saenz and Cellucci said the seeds for the survey were sown a couple of years ago, while Archbishop Perez was still leading the Cleveland Diocese. The idea was presented to and approved by the Presbyteral Council and other diocesan leaders before the survey was offered. Because of the grant CLI received, there is no cost for the diocese to participate in this survey.

The Disciple Maker Index (DMI) is a survey tool, created by Catholic Leadership Institute to:

  • Allow parishioners to reflect upon their spiritual growth and discipleship;
  • Identify the ways in which the parish effectively supports that growth and look at opportunities to support that growth more in the future;
  • Provide valuable input to help pastors and parish leaders make decisions and plan effectively;
  • Help pastors and parish leaders have a sense of where to focus their evangelization efforts.

The Disciple Maker Index Survey

Today I got an e-mail from my parish with a link to take the Disciple Maker Index Survey. I found that I came out very well in the reflections on my spiritual growth and discipleship. At the same time the parish came out very poorly since I haven't been there for a year. There was nothing in the survey about the pandemic. Now it is possible that by giving the survey they have always been giving they might detect effects across parishes. However without a pre and post test it will be very difficult to tell what is peculiar to a parish or an effect of the pandemic.

I had never heard of this place or this survey. They say they consult widely across the country. Has anyone seen or heard of them? They originated in Philadelphia area.

Catholic Leadership Institute

Wednesday, March 3, 2021

We won't all be vaccinated by May

President Biden has made headlines with his announcement that (to quote the NY Times news story) "there would be enough doses of the coronavirus vaccine available for the entire adult population in the United States by the end of May".  It's wonderful news.  It left me with the uplifting feeling that maybe we've finally tossed the lasso over COVID-19 and are cinching it tight.  It's the kind of news that helps explain, at least on a psychological level, why some states are lifting COVID restrictions already.

But. 

Vaccine Ethics, Again

You may have seen Jim McCrea's email share of this article on the America site.  It discusses a statement by the archdiocese of New Orleans questioning the morality of accepting the Johnson and Johnson vaccine because of the use of a cell line derived from an abortion that occurred decades ago. Presumable their archbishop wrote the statement, though it was unsigned. 

Tuesday, March 2, 2021

Should Governor Cuomo resign?

Governor Cuomo is being tossed about in a sea of scandals.  Should he try to ride out the storm?