Sunday, July 31, 2022

Francis on Religion and Politics

Quebec, Canada: 

God does not want us to be slaves, but sons and daughters; he does not want to make decisions for us, or oppress us with a sacral power, exercised in a world governed by religious laws.  No!  He created us to be free, and he asks us to be mature and responsible persons in life and in society.  

Homily to Bishops, Priests, Deacons, Religious & Lay Workers

So let us ask ourselves a question: How are we doing when it comes to joy?  Does our Church express the joy of the Gospel?  Is there a faith in our communities that can attract by the joy it communicates?

Friday, July 29, 2022

Liturgy and gender

The church assigns liturgical texts for many saints based on their gender.  The church might wish to rethink this.

Thursday, July 28, 2022

The Forward Party

 Dozens of former Republican and Democratic officials announced on Wednesday a new national political third party to appeal to millions of voters they say are dismayed with what they see as America's dysfunctional two-party system:

Former Republicans and Democrats form new third U.S. political party | Reuters

From the article:

Monday, July 25, 2022

FORMS OF CAPITAL

 This is the theoretical perspective that generated the previous post comparing time spent in social relationships (social capital) with time spent with television (cultural capital).

Capital here is defined as accumulated labor.

Whenever we accumulate labor as financial capital, or human capital, or social capital, or cultural capital we are able to transfer that labor to other times and places.  For example, when we earn money, we can buy a house with it.

Human capital is defined as labor that adheres to a human person. When we labor, we can improve our health, our physical body, our mind, our talents, our skills and our virtues. (Yes, a Nobel prize winner for his writing on human capital said that virtue is human capital, i.e., a resource or asset that adheres to persons.)

Social capital is defined as labor that builds and maintains social networks.   Institutions are defined as patterns of behavior that support and maintain social networks.  Families, households, workplaces, neighborhoods and parishes are all institutions with associated social networks.  Larger institutions such as parishes can be further divided into smaller institutions, the 5pm Mass, the 7am Mass, the 10am Mass, the choir, lectors etc., all of which have patterns of behavior that are associated with networks of particular people.  Families can be divided into spousal relationships, parent child relationships, sibling relationships, etc.

The time that we spend in social relationships is a key indicator of our social capital investments.

Cultural capital is defined as labor that builds and maintains shared symbolic systems such as languages, music, dance, artistic expressions,etc. and their associated products such as books, CDs, etc.

The time we spend in watching television is a key indicator of our cultural investments.

Why do I like the forms of capital conceptual system?

As a social psychologist it allows me to talk about both persons and organizations within the same conceptual system.

A person can be described as their accumulated human, social and cultural capital. We are our bodies, our minds, our skills, and our virtues. And we are also our participation in households, families, workplaces various other institutions and their social networks. And we are our shared symbol systems, e.g., languages, books that we have read, media that we have watched, music that we have heard or sung, etc. The sum of all this makes each of us very rich and unique. (Now there are some people who like to define themselves and others mainly in terms of their physical and financial capital). 

An organization (church, company, city) can be described as the accumulation of its human, social and culture capital.  Catholicism can be described as the accumulation of those people who call themselves Catholic, institutions (with their associated networks) that are identified as Catholic, and cultures (liturgies, books, music, art, etc.) that are identified as Catholic. The sum of human, social, and cultural capital makes every organization very rich and not able to be defined so easily by any particular persons, institutions, or symbols systems.

When any of us as a person interacts with an organization we enter as a very complex internal capital system into interaction with a very complex external capital system.

Talking about capital can be very inspiring if one remembers that one is always talking about the accumulated labor of persons rather than (as some economists would have it) only about things that can be given a monetary value.   

So, the house in which I live is my own accumulated labor, along with that of the labor of all the people that build the house or provided the materials for its building or maintained it before I bought it.

The parish is the accumulated labor of all the people who over the years built not only the physical buildings but all the institutions and symbolic systems that have become part of the parish.

A bible is the accumulated labor of all the people who have transmitted the scriptures over the centuries and translated them from culture to culture.

We live in a global world that has largely been transformed by accumulated human labor in the form of physical structures, present and past human beings, present and past human institutions, and present and past human symbol systems.

So, whenever we discuss doing anything personally or collectively, the question is how will, what we do impact not only the physical environment but also our human capital, our social capital, and our cultural capital.

Back to question of time spent in social relationships and television.  Our social relationships are places in which we can influence others as well as have them influence us. Television is a symbolic (virtual) reality that influences us far more than we influence it. We can interpret it by means of our social network and other media systems.  However, it is far more likely to make disciples (followers) of us than empower us to be leaders influencing others. 

Sunday, July 24, 2022

The Influence of Television and Social Relationships

 Jim's post on television inspired me to put together the data that I have from the social relationships (Friends) book and the Time and Television summary that I did about ten years ago. It is an interesting way of comparing the potential influence of media and personal relationships in our lives. An immediate limitation of the data is that frequently the two influences interact, i.e., we either watch television or we talk with people (in person or over the phone, or by text) about what we have seen on television.


Friends Data

Average

#persons

Hours/month

Hours/month

Contacts

Individual

Group

Support group

once a week

5

8.5

42.5

Sympathy group

once a month

10

2.0

20.0

Contact group

once a year

135

0.3

40.5

103.0

Television

64.6


Some Observations

Thursday, July 21, 2022

Tuesday, July 19, 2022

Pestering God

For this week's parish bulletin, I wrote this brief reflection on this coming Sunday's Gospel reading.  Offering it here in case it stirs any interest.  I could have said more (thinking of something to say is never my problem!) but I had a word count limit.

The readings for this coming Sunday are here.

Next Sunday's Gospel is According to Q

The Synoptic Gospels (Matthew, Mark, and Luke) are called that because they have passages in common. The two-source theory, widely accepted among Biblical scholars, holds that Matthew and Luke had a copy of Mark when they wrote their Gospels, and that they also had a copy of another document Q, which explains the passages they have in common which are not in Mark.  Of course. since there is no existing copy of Q, it is possible that some pages in Luke were in Q but not copied by Matthew, and that some passages in Matthew come from Q but were not copied by Luke. There is not much agreement about any other Q passages other than those found in Matthew and Luke. 

It is interesting that some of the most widely admired passages, the Beatitudes and the Lord's Prayer come from Q. This Sunday's Gospel is about the Lord's Prayer  

IN THE TABLE BELOW ARE LISTED THE VERSES OF SUNDAY'S GOSPEL WHICH ARE COMMON TO BOTH AND THOSE WHICH ARE SPECIFIC TO LUKE 

All of this material is from BibleWorks; The Douay-Rheims version is used because it is in the public domain. It also is a very literal translation of the Latin Vulgate which is a literal translation of the original Greek

Sunday, July 17, 2022

A Modest Proposal

 If you have not read this interview with Pope Francis by Junno Arocho Esteves, it is very good: It was originally in Spanish, on Catholic News Service.  It is on the NCR site, in English:  On Communion for politicians, pope reiterates: Bishops should be pastoral | National Catholic Reporter (ncronline.org)

The title is "On Communion for Politicians" but it actually deals with several things, including gun violence.  I will quote the part that segues into the subject of my post, which I promise will be short.

Friday, July 15, 2022

A very brief thought about this Sunday's Gospel

The brilliance and challenge of the Martha and Mary anecdote is, everyone nods when told that Mary has chosen the better part, yet we all live Martha lives.

Bernie: Campaigning Again?

Ever since I began supporting Bernie, I have also been deluged with money requests from other Democrats. In the past I have not done anything to discourage them. However, with the Dobbs decision, I have been unsubscribing to Democrats who make requests to support abortion. Bernie is the exception because although Bernie has always supported the "right to abortion" he has never made it central to his campaign and has in fact supported progressive Democrats who are pro-life.

This is today's message from Bernie. Notice how indirect the reference to abortion amid the broader problem of a reactionary Supreme Court. The reference is far down in the list of defensive struggles and has no place in the offensive goal-oriented paragraphs that follow which are very much Bernie's standard program

Tuesday, July 12, 2022

Retirement Home for Francis: Not Vatican Nor Argentina

 

Pope Francis speaks about role of pope emeritus, his possible retirement and Joe Biden taking Communion in new interview

Pope Francis said he would not live in the Vatican or return to his native Argentina if and when he ever retires, but would instead like to find a church in Rome where he could continue hearing confessions.

Monday, July 11, 2022

Trenton: A Model Diocesan Synthesis Report?

I consider the ten- page diocesan syntheses reports to be very valuable information, especially since the page limit forces people to limit and prioritize their remarks. Journalists may rebel at reading these from every diocese in the country, but social scientists may be able to do a good job of analyzing their content.

I think Trenton's report is very encouraging. Their bishop was once president of Catholic University. He was appointed by B16 and is very much in his mold, i.e., the scholar-teacher. As you can see from his remarks at the end, he admits that he is still adjusting to being a listener rather than a teacher.  However, he seems willing to face the problems.

I have outlined the text below. A lot of the sample comments in the complete report are well worth the read.

Synod: Final Report of Trenton Diocesan Phase

Good Samaritan spirituality

 This is my homily for this past weekend, the 15th Sunday in Ordinary Time, Cycle C.  The readings are here.

Saturday, July 9, 2022

How to de-Evangelize


 My friend got his letter from the Paterson Diocese Tribunal informing him that he is free from "spiritual obligations of the first union".  But, in another decision, in italics, they inform him that he cannot be married in the RC Church without first the "express approval of the Paterson Tribunal".

Did his cheating, lying, slandering (but now churchgoing) ex-wife get the same second paragraph?

Is this second decision boilerplate or is it only in certain circumstances and, if so, what are they?

At any rate, this cold perfunctory letter doesn't have a nanogram of Jesus in it.  I certainly am unable to explain the ways of a bureaucratic church to anybody.

At this point, I would say that my friend's daughter has zero chance of remaining Catholic, given his present derision for the Church and the ex-wife and her side being a bunch of obvious hypocrites.

How did the Church of Jesus Christ come to this?

Diocesan Synod Syntheses: Bad News for USCCB?

 The ten-page syntheses that each diocese should produce about their diocesan synod process were due on June 30th in Rome and at the USCCB. They have begun to surface. The Archdiocese of Seattle, and the Archdiocese of Washington have published theirs. They contain some sharp language for the USCCB (the bishops' conference). The USCCB is required to produce its own ten-page synthesis of the syntheses to be sent to Rome on August 15. That could be interesting.  Just imagine Francis sitting down with the American Cardinals shortly afterwards. "When are you going to listen to your people?"

Thursday, July 7, 2022

Good-bye, Boris

I awoke this morning to reports that UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson is stepping down.  His downfall was triggered by a wave of resignations by cabinet members and other officials from his own party.   

Johnson's sins include hypocrisy (attending parties while the country was locked down during the COVID pandemic), and a serial inability to tell the truth.  Those are the sorts of missteps and red flags that, until 2016, would have put immense pressure on a US president, too.  

This post practically writes itself: President Trump's sins are several magnitudes worse, notably including an attempt to overthrow the results of the 2020 presidential election.  And yet he has dodged convictions in two impeachment trials, thanks to senators in his own party notoriously declining to hold him accountable.  The contrast between the GOP leadership and Tory leadership could not be starker.

Trump continues to operate with impunity today, trying to play the kingmaker role during the GOP primary season, and attending rallies where he repeats his trust-eroding lies about the 2020 election.  And he may be announcing his 2024 presidential candidacy at any time.

It's difficult to escape the conclusion that the British system is functioning better than ours these days; and the British people might be better than us right now, too.

Tuesday, July 5, 2022

John O'Malley on the" Papalization" of the Church

John W. O'Malley the Jesuit historian is one of my favorite authors. He is an authority on both the Council of Trent and Vatican II. This article is from America.

How popes became so powerful—and how Pope Francis could reverse the trend

In 2000, Thomas Reese, S.J., then the editor in chief of America, asked me to write an article on how the church differed between the first millennium and the second. I found the assignment easy because one difference stood out like no other: a new centrality of the popes in the church of the second millennium. 

I called this phenomenon the papalization of the church. 

 some of the most important and symptomatic steps in the process were the results of direct actions taken by the popes themselves. The popes were in fact the single most important agents in the papalization process. I describe their actions as self-conferred upgrades. 

Sunday, July 3, 2022

Dealing With Mixed Feelings About July 4th

I came across an article this morning that I needed to read, titled "I can't remember the last time I felt patriotic, can you?" The author was Molly Cahill, and the article appeared on the America Magazine site. 

From the article:

Friday, July 1, 2022

Paul Rose: Sing the Hours

Sing the Hours

is a Virtual Breviary, mostly the creation of one person, a young man, Paul Rose, with the help of his family, especially his dad John Rose. 

Paul wanted to sing the Hours of Morning and Evening Prayer daily. Disappointed that he could find nothing on the internet, he decided to do it himself.  He had the basic musical skills and the production skills which consist of computer programs that combine and edit audio-visual streams. Now more than a year later his YouTube site is a collection of more than a year of Morning and Evening Prayer using the official texts and his free style interpretation of them done in Gregorian Chant. He has almost 15,000 subscribers on YouTube with daily counts now running over 3000.  The Hours are also available as a podcast on Apple and Spotify.  

Paul and his family are converts from an Evangelical background. His dad loves Latin hymns and does some excellent translations of them. I wish they would just sing the English translations and not try to get us to appreciate the Latin poetry. 

Paul thinks the production of the hours that he does is servile work which he does not do on Sundays or even Solemnities. Last Sunday, he first told subscribers there would be no Sunday Vespers production available, then decided it was OK to do Vespers live on YouTube. That resulted in the following hour-long YouTube post.  He has now reposted it with the outline below. You probably will not want to listen to Vespers since it really is not his usual professional production. However, do listen to the first fifteen minutes which give what I would call his "spirituality of the hours."  After Vespers he gives an impromptu lesson in Gregorian chant to convince everyone that Gregorian chant is easy. You can skip that unless you want to learn how to sing Gregorian chant.

Vespers and Chat




Going to sing Vespers live and stick around for a few minutes to answer any questions you might have!