Sunday, October 4, 2026

When did compassion become a sin?

 Compassion and empathy are now seen as bad things. The first time I heard about this understanding of these traits that is rapidly spreading in MAGA circles was a quote from Elon Musk—“ "the fundamental weakness of Western civilization is empathy“.   This idea is now even supported by none other than Robert Barron.    

Hannah Arendt warned “ The death of human empathy is one of the earliest and most telling signs of a culture about to fall into barbarism.  I think we’re pretty close to barbarism right now. 

Reactions? Thoughts ?  

Article from The Atlantic

https://tinyurl.com/msk7f4ma


97 comments:

  1. More on this topic here: https://www.ncronline.org/news/bishop-barron-word-fire-fuels-debate-empathys-role-society

    To me it looks like a bunch of men (BP Barron, Elon, JD) united by the fear that somebody's going to use "empathy" to get one over on them somehow. And they want everybody to know they're by-god rootin' tootin' red-blooded hard-asses.

    What's likely to happen is that women, who "traditionally" are supposed to have more empathy than men, will become objects of derision and increasingly sidelined by the anti-empathy goons.

    Bad times ahead, since these guys have a lot of social capital to spend.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Possibly Adam Kinzinger's musings on empathy and MAGA as a man of faith are germane here. Hopefully there are still enough men like this out there to make a diff.

      https://youtu.be/bS76lZL9luo?si=E9ue_8ExLc1NIgGk

      Delete
  2. Funny how the people promoting this line of thought are the usual suspects. Elon Musk, JD Vance, Peter Thiel, etc. Mostly billionaires afraid that they might have to part with any of their wealth if they start feeling sorry for people.
    The Atlantic article by Elizabeth Bruenig references a couple of books.: ".......the degree that books such as Saad’s are meant to help conservatives resolve their internal conflicts and ignore their consciences, they are basically right-wing self-help guides. Stuckey’s Toxic Empathy seems especially targeted at conservative Christians who feel torn about subjects such as immigration and welfare. Stuckey is at pains to reassure her readers that any dissonance they might feel between their religious duties and politil interests is a treacherous mirage generated by the left."
    Barron ought to know better but he's too busy fighting communism and sitting at the cool kids table. I notice he does a lot of dancing up to the line but not quite crossing it of contradicting things the pope has said on the subject.
    I am not quite as pessimistic as the Atlantic article is about the slide into barbarism. The social capital the billionaire tech bros have is mainly shared by people like them and those who want to become like them.

    ReplyDelete
  3. As I am rather conservative in many matters, I may be more empathy-deficient than others here.

    I hadn't encountered this topic until I saw Anne's post - it had passed me by completely until now. So I don't claim to be well-read on this.

    The claim of civilizational suicide seems pretty overwrought.

    It appears the critics of empathy are targeting such notions as "toxic empathy" or "unbounded empathy". That suggests that there may be more reasonably limited expressions or experiences of empathy (non-toxic empathy? bounded empathy?) that are not problematic.

    What other things might serve to reasonably limit one's empathy? Here is a quote from Barron in the NCR article: "If you put empathy, so defined, in the center of your preoccupation, truth, reality, justice and love are going to be threatened." Bounding empathy with truth, reality, justice and love doesn't sound unreasonable to me.

    For myself, I would also make a distinction between the empathy we feel as persons, and (allegedly-)empathetic government policies. I'd like the latter to be more limited than the former (no doubt, that's my conservatism coming out again).

    To offer a concrete example: I'd like to think I can be personally empathetic toward a trans person whose innate psychological sense of his sexual identity varies from his physical attributes. But as I've mentioned here in the past, I'm not comfortable with a legal regime that, for example, would allow minors to choose sex-change treatments without parental consent. (Honestly, not even comfortable with it *with* parental consent.) Perhaps Barron, and some of the other authors mentioned, would view sex changes for minors as unbridled empathy.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jim, I agree with you that the claim of civilizational suicide seems overwrought.
      When the ones promoting the concept of "toxic empathy" are billionaires and wannabee trillionaires, it's pretty transparently niche and self-seeking.
      The "Golden Rule" is not named in Scripture, but the concept is. Matthew 7:12; "So in everything, do to others what you would have them do to you, for this sums up the Law and the Prophets." And of course there are the Beatitudes. Some version of the Golden Rule is taught by all the major religions.
      I don't think sex change really enters into the "toxic empathy" concern, it's about money.

      Delete
    2. I can easily believe that lacking the empathy gene is a help in becoming a billionaire. And there is something about human nature that makes us disposed to listen to billionaires, even on topics on which there is no reason to believe they know anything more than the guy on the next barstool (Tevya: "When you're rich, they think you really know.")

      Here is how I think empathy enters into the sex change for minors conversation: I am supposing that those who support these policies of permitting them, are largely motivated by empathy. It is not difficult to find heart-rending testimony from trans persons on how much they suffer. Personally, I find it difficult to read or listen to this testimony without thinking, "Can't something be done for this person?"

      But we must balance this (admirably) empathetic response with other testimony - e.g. that some places that offer treatments and sex-change procedures have been doing so irresponsibly; that some minors who have had the procedures, come to regret it after a few years; and so on. I think we must balance empathy with wisdom and prudence. I don't say the problem of minors who are suffering from gender dysphoria is an easy conundrum to resolve. I am saying that we can't let empathy, by itself, be our only guide to policy.

      Delete
    3. I am against medical interventions for minors who express gender dysphoria. Listening and accompaniment are always appropriate, and not insisting on rigid gender roles for those young people (that would seem to be part of empathy). Once they reach adulthood, they'll need to figure out their own lives going forward.

      Delete
    4. Jim, did you read the Atlantic article? The notion that empathy and compassion are going to mean the end of our culture is not focused on surgery for trans kids. As it happens, I’m with you and Katherine on that. Once they are 18 then they can decide. The big focus is on immigration and refugee policy, including, apparently, persuading evangelical and other conservative Christians that any compassion they feel due to religious qualms for people suffering from our policies - for children ripped away from their parents, for example— is wrong. Compassion for the homeless, for people losing health benefits, etc is wrong in their view. Compassion for the global poor is wrong. This doesn’t come through in the NCR article. Remember — the very first week they closed down almost all humanitarian aid for the global poor in those sh***hole countries.

      BTW, since you are pro-life and not just anti- abortion (I hope,) I’m wondering why there is no outcry from the anti- abortion forces who call themselves pro- life for the now more than 750,000 who have died (500,000 children) because of the cut off of humanitarian aid. It will hit a million deaths pretty soon and keep climbing. Apparently someone got through a little as they are giving CRS money for a couple of projects, including in Cuba. Maybe Rubio’s Catholic- formed conscience is bothering him.

      Delete
  4. Perhaps. But I believe Barron is like Doyle — far more interested in being able to sit with the cool kids, as Katherine puts it, than following the instructions Jesus gave in Matthew 25:31-44. I have read more than one article about this in the last few months. The concern does not seem to focus on transgender surgery. I haven’t seen any allusions towards this. Trans people are a minuscule segment of the population.

    The focus is on two groups - the American poor - get rid of all the programs that help them so they can pull themselves up by their bootstraps, and immigration. They especially that believe empathy for the global poor is committing cultural suicide— empathy for a few thousand white South African farmers is ok because they’re white ( I suppose Elon had something to do with this policy) , but no empathy for immigrants of non-white, or non-western religious descent who seek safety from violence in their home countries, or seek a place that offers more opportunities for a better life for themselves and their children. All of those of us who chat here are descendants of people who came to the US for one or both of those reasons. Since Steven Miller is a major driver of these policies, it’s not just white Christian nationalists— those of white Jewish descent are also acceptable. They fear the great replacement. I wonder what kind of the interpersonal relationship the Millers and the Vances have.

    JD is pushing the notion that only “ heritage” Americans are truly American. There is now a hierarchy based on when your ancestors got here and whether or not they fought in the civil war. I think only Jean would qualify as a heritage American since most of our group’s ancestors (Polish, Irish, German) arrived after the civil war. My grandchildren provide an interesting case. All are descendants of 1630s English immigrants, and have ancestors who fought in the civil war, but include two whose ancestors were slaves in Jamaica (Jamaica freed its slaves before America did), and two of non- white Viet Namese heritage, whose mom was a refugee who would not be allowed in these days. Would they still be considered “ heritage “ Americans?

    The anti-empathy movement is toxic.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Two of the last people I want driving policy or teaching people how to think are Steven Miller and JD Vance.

      I don't consider Barron to be in their circle, nor to share their odious and sinful policy preferences.

      Delete
    2. My sister has done geneological research showing that some of our family's WASP forebears came here in the 1600s (whereupon some of them owned slaves). Other forebears migrated here from Europe in the 1800s and 1900s. So I guess I am semi-heritage. I identify way more with the immigrants, none of whom ever owned slaves.

      Anne, I don't know if you've had the pleasure of reading the Harry Potter books to your grandchildren. In the wizarding world, there is a concept called "mudbloods" - people with wizarding powers who are descended from non-wizard families. Hermione Granger is one. Harry is one, too, through his mother's family. Draco Malfoy, a fair proxy for Steven Miller, introduces the notion of mudbloods; the Malfoys are the sort of wizarding family that disdains mudbloods (and also are followers of Lord Voldemort, although that storyline gets complicated by the end of the books).

      Why anyone in real life would want to be like the Malfoys is something I genuinely don't understand.

      Delete
    3. Jim, I don't consider Barron to be like Stephen Miller either. Or like JD Vance . JD's. problem seems to be the lack of an internal compass, I don't think he really knows who he is.
      My ancestors that I know much about were like yours, came here from Europe in the 1800s and early 1900s. My nephew who is into genealogical research turned up someone on my mom's side named Recompense Stansberry. That sounds like he could have been one of the Puritans.
      I think I missed my timeline to read the Harry Potter series. We did watch the first movie, and kind of enjoyed Hogwarts.

      Delete
    4. I am definitely not a heritage American. But at least my undesirable-to-Miller-and-Trump brown and latte grandchildren are. Trump is not even close to this exalted status as an American, and, of course, he’s had two immigrant wives. But they are/were both white.

      I tried reading Harry Potter three times. I forced myself to read a hundred pages the last time, but threw in the towel again and gave up.

      I wouldn’t be so sure that Barron isn’t as racist as Miler, Vance and Trump. He’s thrilled to be MAGA’s favorite bishop now that Doyle is gone.

      Delete
    5. The whole notion that some people have inculcated more American values than others because their ancestors came here longer ago is idiotic.

      Khizr Khan, a Pakistani immigrant who gave a wonderful speech at the 2016 DNC, carried a copy of the US Constitution around with him and went on to hold forums about American freedoms in schools across the country. THAT is inculcating and disseminating American values.

      Delete
    6. Barron pretty much toe’s the line of Vatican and USCCB statements. Basically that countries have a right to control immigration, that ICE should focus on criminals in arrests, that detainees should have access to pastoral care and Holy Communion, that immigration reform is needed ( duh).

      Delete
  5. Imo, what the anti-empathy people are doing is conflating empathy with imprudence.

    I feel empathy for the homeless, for ex, but it is beyond my means to buy them a house. Empathy can/should/does, however, push me to see how else I can help--an extra coat, mittens, lunch distribution, writing letters to those in a position to do more, etc.

    However, once you've established that empathy, generally speaking, is merely some kind of bleeding-heart nonsense, you can excuse a lot of institutional cruelty like deporting people en masse, dismantling public health programs, cutting off foreign aid, etc.

    I guess that leaves more $$ for ballroom bunkers and testosterone shots for soldiers.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "...once you've established that empathy, generally speaking, is merely some kind of bleeding-heart nonsense, you can excuse a lot of institutional cruelty like deporting people en masse, dismantling public health programs, cutting off foreign aid, etc."
      Jean, yes, I would agree with that.

      Delete
    2. I agree that complaining about empathy sounds like warmed-over "bleeding heart liberal" rhetoric.

      Delete
    3. The anti-empathy crowd also seems to want to tie empathy in with "wokeness" and "identity politics." I guess the idea is to root out empathy, which is at the core of these perceived evils.

      Anti-empathy also goes along with effective altruism, the notion that we should not factor feelings into policy decisions, but impartially come up with solutions that do the greatest good for the greatest number. Sounds good ... unless the greatest number to benefit just happen to be Heritage Americans.

      Delete
    4. If anyone comes up to me and says I’m too empathetic, I’ll say “OK”, followed by whiplike karate kicking them in the crotch and then come down with a double hammer fist to the base of their skull as they bend over. Then say, “Damn! You’re right! That felt great!” Only joking. Well, maybe.

      Delete
    5. Ha ha! I've got some candidates you could practice on ...

      Delete
    6. I need to be cured of my empathy. Silly me.

      Delete
    7. "Katherine, yes, trying to turn social security into an “ entitlement “ makes it sound like a “gift” that was not earned. But the GOP does this constantly because it refuses to raise taxes on the rich and on corporations. "

      That is true of old-school conservatives like me (although, in fact, I'm not as hardcore anti-tax as some old-school conservatives. I'm not from the Grover Nordquist tax-cut-pledge branch).

      But the new-school populist converatives could conceivably be prepared to raise taxes on billionaires, or large corporations, or other populist bogeymen. That this really hasn't happened under Trump, probably is more due to the faux nature of Trump's populism; he seems to be just fine hanging out with billionaires, and they certainly try to curry his favor.

      Delete
  6. I guess I don't know why Bp Barron is cautioning against unbridled empathy. Seems like Catholic clergy, with their eyes on the poor and "least ones," might more logically wonder if there is enough of it to go around.

    Maybe also important not to conflate generosity with empathy. Lots of people give generously because they like their names on things, want a tax break, or hope to promote something their family's involved in.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's all true about generosity. And there are government policies enmeshed in some of those motives - certainly, that is true for tax breaks. Traditional conservatives tend to be more in favor of tax incentives than in entitlement spending.

      Delete
    2. All government spending is designed to get votes and influence, whether it's food stamps or milk price supports or grants to Elon and Bezos for their rockets or free vaccines at the county health department. It's a wholly transactional exchange.

      Delete
    3. Jim, what programs are entitlement spending? How are they defined?

      Delete
    4. They keep trying to call Social Security an entitlement, even though we pay into it our whole working lives. There are things they could do to ensure its solvency into the future, other than keep increasing the age of eligibility.

      Delete
    5. "Jim, what programs are entitlement spending? How are they defined?"

      Here is how my pal Google Gemini defines it, apparently drawing from the USAFacts site and congress.gov:

      "A public program that guarantees specific benefits or payments to any individual or entity that meets eligibility criteria established by law"

      That would include such federal programs as Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid and SNAP. It also includes the program I had in mind when I made the comment about preferring tax policy to entitlement programs: unemployment insurance.

      I don't oppose unemployment insurance. I think of it as, well, an empathetic entitlement program to provide a financial bridge that sustains individuals and families from one job to the next.

      There are limits to unemployement insurance. In Illinois, it is limited to 26 weeks per 52-week period. (And I believe recipients must be actively looking for a job during that period.) Occasionally, one will encounter the belief that the 26-week limit should be extended, or even abolished. I believe this is proposed out of a sense of empathy for those who aren't working. The traditional conservative response is that government payouts disincentivize work. If workers know that they can get paid for a year or longer without working, some will choose not to work, even though wages almost always are higher than unemployment payments. Hence conservatives see it as prudent to cap unemployment payments.

      Delete
    6. Katherine, yes, trying to turn social security into an “ entitlement “ makes it sound like a “gift” that was not earned. But the GOP does this constantly because it refuses to raise taxes on the rich and on corporations. Raising the age on eligibility though, does make some sense. They need to figure out how to fix this, and soon. People live longer now than when social security first passed, which means that they collect for more years than anticipated. In 1940, when SS started, men who reached age 65 lived another 11.9 years on average, to age 77, and women another 13 years to 78. Now men who are 65 live to about 83 and 65 year old women usually to 85 on average .

      Delete
    7. Since SS and Medicare are NOT entitlements, I’m curious about how entitlements are defined and what is included. I haven’t ever thought much about this. So, since Jim is our resident conservative, I’m hoping he can enlighten us about entitlements.

      Delete
    8. Ok. I just saw your answer. Unemployment insurance is funded primarily by a tax on employers. Not by general taxes. The length of eligibility and the requirements can be debated. Perhaps the length should somehow be linked to the unemployment rate. In Maryland people on unemployment have to provide evidence of job seeking with names of potential employers contacted, information about the job being sought and qualifications etc ( if someone applies to drive tractor trailers but aren’t qualified with the right license, that won’t count as a real application); every two weeks to remain eligible. Most states have a 26 week eligibility period. Unemployment benefits are taxed, just as social security benefits are. If people don”t get a job during the time allowed for unemployment then they have to apply for “ welfare” benefits instead. So what are the tax incentives preferred over entitlements? Since unemployment benefits are not funded by government, but by private employers, what do you call it an entitlement? Florida has a 12 week limit. Massachusetts is more generous with a 30 week limit. SS and Medicare are funded by individual taxes throughout our working lives, so are earned and not entitlements in the sense of being a “ gift” from the government.

      Delete
    9. I should also point out that someone is only eligible for unemployment if they are fired or laid off. You aren’t eligible for unemployment if you quit your job.

      Delete
    10. "Raising the age on eligibility though, does make some sense. They need to figure out how to fix this, and soon. People live longer now than when social security first passed, which means that they collect for more years than anticipated. In 1940, when SS started, men who reached age 65 lived another 11.9 years on average, to age 77, and women another 13 years to 78. Now men who are 65 live to about 83 and 65 year old women usually to 85 on average ."

      I say this as one who is now 65: even though we live longer today than our grandparents did, our work ability doesn't necessarily extend farther/older than it did before. (Cf. Joe Biden and now Donald Trump trying to be president as old men.)

      Given that the age to receive "full Social Security" benefits has been pushed from 65 to 67 for people my age, a humane accommodation would be to allow Social Security benefits to "ramp up", say between the ages of 62-70. And for the work day to "ramp down" over those ages, perhaps to six hours and then five hours per day, or to four and then three days per week.

      (As the program exists today, workers are eligible to start drawing Social Security as young as age 62. But workers who elect to start receiving Social Security at age 62 are "locked in" for that reduced amount for the remainder of their lives. Perhaps that arrangement could stay in place; but workers who continue to work and contribute FICA taxes beyond 62 could earn more at retirement, even as their work "ramps down" during that decade.)

      Delete
    11. "Since unemployment benefits are not funded by government, but by private employers, what do you call it an entitlement? Florida has a 12 week limit. Massachusetts is more generous with a 30 week limit. SS and Medicare are funded by individual taxes throughout our working lives, so are earned and not entitlements in the sense of being a “ gift” from the government."

      I call it an entitlement according to the definition I supplied above: "A public program that guarantees specific benefits or payments to any individual or entity that meets eligibility criteria established by law". In other words: state governments (and employers) can't elect which employees receive the benefit and which don't; all former employees who meet the legal eligibility requirements, must receive the benefit. States can't claim, "Sorry, we're out of money this budget year, so no more unemployement checks." And employers can't claim, "Sorry, we lost money last year, so we're not going to contribute to unemployment insurance."

      My original point in raising the example of unemployment insurance is, it's an empathy-driven program: it exisets because we feel empathy for those out of work. And at various times there have been empathy-driven attempts to increase the amounts, and/or to extend the number of weeks or months of eligibility.

      Btw, I wasn't aware of tax-policy mechanisms that would somehow make unemployment insurance less of a budget risk for states or more generous for workers. But apparently there are a variety of ideas out there.

      Delete
    12. "...even though we live longer today than our grandparents did, our work ability doesn't necessarily extend farther/older than it did before."
      Jim, that is true. I am finding out that my energy levels really have gone down. I don't think I could work an 8 hour day anymore. I like to kid myself that I still have the same mental acuity as I ever did. But that is a self deception. I am grateful for retirement.

      Delete
    13. Jim, states don’t really have a budget risk because of unemployment benefits. The states administer and disburse unemployment benefits. But they don’t fund them. So theoretically the employers could handle that the administrative tasks themselves.

      Delete
  7. Jean, that youtube video of Adam Kinzinger that you linked above at 7:44 yesterday was good.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have lots of respect for him. A bit conservative for my taste when he was in office, but he seems to have a lot of decency. Did that super rain in Nebraska come your way?

      Delete
    2. We just got a more or less ordinary heavy rain. Omaha and Lincoln got the super rain. Our oldest son and daughter in law in Omaha had water in their basement and some carpet ruined. But they said it could have been worse, and for some people it was.

      Delete
    3. We are far enough north that remnants of Gulf storms blow out before they get here. At least until climate change worsens and the Great Lakes start fueling big rainstorms. But it looked bad/sad for a lot of people down there.

      Delete
  8. Here is an excerpt from the transcript of the beginning of a Word on Fire video in which the host introduces the topic ("suicidal empathy") he will discuss with Bishop Barron:

    I'm Matthew Petrusk, senior director of the Word on Fire Institute and the host of the Word on Fire Show. Thank you for joining us. The evolutionary behavioral scientist and public intellectual Gad Saad has recently published an influential book entitled Suicidal Empathy: Dying to Be Kind. In it, Saad argues that much of the West has unfortunately come to embrace a perversely deficient understanding of empathy, twisting the natural and otherwise noble human capacity to feel and respond to other people's sufferings into a moral license to upend the moral, economic, and political order. According to the dictates of suicidal empathy, for example, society should prioritize criminals over victims, illegal immigrants over citizens, lawbreakers over law abiders, racial identity over competence, adult sexual expression over childhood innocence, and trans women, that is men pretending to be women, over real women. Suicidal empathy's endgame, Sad warns, is nothing less than societal ruin and the eventual totalitarian eclipse of the individual.

    Barron quite reasonably, it seems to me, opposes elevating empathy over and above reason, love, and justice. However, he claims that empathy requires the avoidance of "hurting the feelings" of those for whom we have empathy.

    Instead of arguing against misplaced empathy or overreactions in the name of empathy, the whole enterprise seems to me an attempt to unfairly and unjustly taint all feelings of empathy and all efforts to seek the welfare of those with whom we empathize.

    It's evil.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nJRLK2h-aQ4

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, David. I guess I would like Gad Saad to actually produce anybody who wants to upend life as we know it because their empathy has run away with them. The nutcase empath is a boogeyman invented by right-wingers.

      Delete
    2. Wow. I can’t imagine that this guy’s rather extreme analysis of western policies gets any credence at all. But apparently a lot of people are buying this nonsense.

      Delete
    3. "I can’t imagine that this guy’s rather extreme analysis of western policies gets any credence at all. But apparently a lot of people are buying this nonsense."

      It's a strand of post-liberalism. Post-liberalism is extreme, it's frightening, and Americans have voted it into the White House without understanding the philosophy nor anticipating that, once in power, its proponents would intimidate Congress into enacting it - or at least into declining to oppose it - and try to foist it on a country that didn't ask for it.

      November's election could be a great day in American history, if both houses of Congress can be wrenched away from the post-liberalists' control.

      Delete
    4. Btw, according to the RealClearPolitics (RCP) polling averages for Senate races, the following races show Democrats leading in races for seats currently held by Republicans:

      * Texas: Talarico +3.1%
      * Ohio: Brown +3.2%
      * Iowa: Turek + 0.7%
      * Maine: Jackson +0.7%
      * Alaska: Peltola +1.8%
      * North Carolina: Cooper +9%

      In addition, I don't see that Republicans are leading in any Senate races for seats currently held by Democrats. If all these current polls hold through the actual election (which is definitely not a sure thing, with the apparent exception of NC), Democrats would flip the Senate - I believe they would hold a 53-47 advantage.

      For the House, the RCP Average shows 226 seats landing in the Democrats' column, meaning these are seats that are either likely to go to Democrats or lean toward Democrats. 218 seats are needed for a majority. Beyond the 226 seats, the RCP Average shows 22 toss-up districts. If half of those toss-up seats break Democrats' way, then the split becomes Democrats 237, Republicans 198 - a comfortable 39-seat majority.

      Delete
    5. "However, he claims that empathy requires the avoidance of "hurting the feelings" of those for whom we have empathy."

      I understood from one of the referenced articles that Barron would say that genuine love (Christian charity, the type of love for which the Greek term "agape" would be used) may require that we be willing to hurt the feelings of those for whom we have empathy.

      Delete
    6. I feel pain when I see children and their parents being mercilessly and sadistically starved, dehydrated, bombed and shot. On the other hand, I felt good when I woke to hear bloodthirsty Lindsay Grahame had kicked the bucket. So, I would tell Bishop Barron that it all sort of balances out and not to worry about a pandemic of empathy. Many Americans are immune to that disease.

      Delete
    7. Complementary to Jim's post re Real Politics, Kalshi has odds on House and Senate numbers plus specific Senate elections: https://kalshi.com/category/elections

      I'm surprised Abdul El Sayed here in Michigan has such high odds. Opponent Mike Rogers, whose victory would flip a Dem seat, has rolled out a lot of money for some very provocative attack ads.

      Delete
    8. Gahh! Another month until the Nov. election is over. We are drowning in political ads. All of them nasty. On TV and in our mailbox. I guess Nebraska is sort of swingy this time?
      We have a rather corrupt and inept governor (R) running for a second term against a woman who has served in the state legislature, and seems pretty balanced and moderate. She's a Democrat, and they're trying to paint her as someone who favors transgender stuff. I don't know that she's ever said anything on the subject. And of course there's Independent Senate candidate Dan Osborn running against incumbent billionaire Pete Ricketts. He's the guy who brought back the death penalty in NE as governor by using his family's money to float a referendum.

      Delete
    9. Rogers's ads contend that Abdul is poised to enact Sharia law, is a Muslim zealot, will dismantle police forces, and is a socialist. Scare scare scare. Rogers, weirdly, is not running on his pretty-moderate record as a former congressman and has so far refused debate invites. My assumption is that he's in it for the $$ and influence he can amass during Trump's remaining years as prez.

      Delete
    10. The most concrete evidence for a Blue wave here in Ohio is the local Democratic precinct. Had not heard from them since the 2008 Obama election, a blue wave here and elsewhere.

      Got a real nice mailer inviting me to meet the candidate for Congress, and the two County Commissioners candidates. They may know I contributed the maximum amount to the second Obama campaign which merited me a similar invitation to meet Hilary, I chose Bernie instead. Got an e-mail from Bernie last weekend inviting me to a zoom session where he and fellow senators promoted Brown. I gave a hundred dollars. I told that story to the local Democrats, and offered them a hundred dollars for local campaigning, yard signs etc. for Democratic candidates.

      As for signs in my yard, I told them I have generally not allowed partisan signs except for Obama and Sanders both of which had vision. While the Democrats may win the House and Senate this year by running as moderates against the far-right Trump crowd, in 2028 the Republicans may turn back to " conservative moderation" with a "contract with America" that captures what people want, winning back the House, Senate as well as the Presidency. Democrats need at least a moderate vision (Obama's hope) or a progressive vision like Sanders (but framed as FDR Democracy rather than Democratic socialism) to win 2028.

      I gave them links to my website and invited them to use the nonpartisan discussion materials there to formulate a strategy for 2028 through e-mail discussion both now and in the next year. Obama's strategy was to encourage grassroots organizing between elections around issues such as healthcare. I went to two county meetings where nothing much happened.

      If the blue wave captures the House and Senate nothing much will happen in the next two years except a probably failed attempt impeach Trump.

      Delete
    11. I could only hope that Sayed were a real socialist and as antizionist as they say. Muslims in office like Mamdani backpedal on a lot of their previously “radical” ideas. Mamdani kept a zionist woman as head of the NY police. He’s even catering to the virtue signaling “antisemitism is a problem” crowd. Sayed is already distancing himself from socialism. If elected, I expect him to change flavor to the usual Democratic vanilla. I may vote Democratic this election. I don’t expect the Democrats to accomplish anything for the US people if they win. That’s not what they’re being paid by the billionaires to do. But, perhaps, at least we’ll have some fighting between the parties unlike the totally one party system we have now. If Genghis Khan and Attila the Hun are fighting, maybe there’s a chance for the rest of us.

      Delete
    12. Jim —“ If all these current polls hold through the actual election (which is definitely not a sure thing)”….

      I stopped reading polls after 2016. I don’t trust them anymore and I now worry that Dems will get complacent and not vote.

      I am not a Democrat but vote for them now always even if I don’t line the candidate because I think it’s a matter of the country’s survival that control of Congress flips blue, at least in one chamber.

      As an Independent I get almost no election stuff in the snail mail. My husband reregistered as Dem and gets a lot of email. But little snail mail . Our state and county are deep blue and spending a lot of money here on blue candidates is pretty much a waste. I don’t get any political email. We don’t watch much tv, streaming only, mostly PBS, so we don’t see the ads. I occasionally get text messages from various Dem candidates in Louisiana. I’ve been trying to get off their list for years now. I have no idea how I got on their list. They think my name is Jennifer and that I live in the Baton Rouge parish. The phone numbers change constantly and I assume it’s because volunteers are sending the messages using their own phones.

      Delete
    13. Stanley, how do you decide if a politician is a real socialist? In strict economic terms, Sayed, Mamdani, Sanders etc are not socialists. I haven’t heard that they support state ownership and control of all the factors of production.

      Delete
    14. Stanley, you might want to read up more on El-Sayed. Bernie supports him, but he has never described himself as or aligned himself with the Social Democrats.

      Delete
    15. Jean, too many things goin on at once. Yes,, apparently El Sayyed sticks to the Warren line. Capitalist but with taxes on the rich and some benefits and relief for the plebes. I should also mention that I believe that the state should own/run utilities, including media and social media with public oversight.. It should also make structural changes to facilitate experiments in and forms of worker-owned enterprises. Anne, socialism does not necessarily mean state ownership.

      Delete
  9. At the level of psychology our emotions of anger, anxiety, fear and empathy all have adaptive value. They help us survive. However, emotions when carried to extremes can become maladaptive. Hence the need for moderation.

    In Classical Civilization various philosophies took rational approaches to moderating our emotions so that notions of virtue emerged, closely related to the stem word "vir" Latin for male. The notion was that real males, e.g. the Roman elite did not let themselves give into their emotions like women did. Of course, the Romans governed the world by military force, e.g. crucifixion, and bread and circuses, including gladiator games, and public executions of Christians who refused to burn incense and sacrifice to the emperors. All very rational!!!

    In the Judeo-Christian tradition, care for widows, orphans, foreign residents were not due to empathy or rationality. It was part of a covenant initiated by God. Jesus extended that covenant when he defined neighbor by the parable of the good Samaritan and said that we should love our enemies.

    The history of Christianity and Western Civilization, especially Christian theology, has been to reconcile the rational approach of the Greeks and Romans with the covenant of the people of God as witnessed in the life of Christ and Christian saints. So, we got a lot of things like just wars, the holocaust, slavery, torture and capital punishment which recent Popes have decided are at least out of date and most likely contrary to our covenant with God.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What covenant with God do you refer to? Where in scripture? It often seems to me that the understanding of God of the ancient tribes of Israel in the OT and the understanding of God that is given by Jesus in the NT are extremely different. It’s difficult to harmonize the portrayals of God in the Hebrew and Christian scriptures.

      The warlike, punitive, angry God of the OT scriptures who kills innocents, including children, and the God of love portrayed by Jesus in the NT are dramatically different portrayals of God. Slavery, torture, capital punishment and the scapegoating of Jews that led to the Holocaust definitely seem very “ dated”, - perhaps the result of OT thinking that some rationalize to justify war, violence, and cruelty, which is why I have a serious problem with the OT. Evangelical Christians focus heavily on the OT and so do the alleged “Christians“ in this Administration and in the GOP. God is reported to have made explicit covenants with Noah, Abraham, David about the blessings they will receive if they are obedient. Where in the NT does a similar covenant occur— Jesus’s promises that those who follow him will have their sins forgiven and they will know eternal life in heaven?

      Jesus preached about a God of love, forgiveness and mercy. He told us to turn the other cheek and love the stranger and that we must also love, forgive and be merciful. However, he also said that in loving we might need to lay down our lives for our friends. Does that justify war? Or was he talking only about his own death? About standing up for the “ right”, the truth might mean having to lay down our lives? The notion of just war must have come from this teaching somehow. Defending our friends? I haven’t read just war theology but I’m quite sure that attacking a country to seize control of its assets ( like oil, minerals, water and and waterways) is not considered just war.

      Is there anything in the NT that justifies capital punishment, slavery, torture , or wiping out entire peoples such as occurred in the Holocaust? Saying that these things are possibly considered “ out of date” by recent popes is a bit of a statement. It seems to me that Jesus’s teachings 2000 years ago definitely made those ideas out of date.

      The scriptures weren’t written by God or by Gods human scribes. They are the human expressions of how the ancient Hebrew people interpreted the world around them (violent and cruel), trying to understand how God acted in this world they lived in. They understood the magnificence of.creation as coming from God. But they also saw God as someone who would save them from enemies, using violence to destroy them. So war, cruelty and violence were rationalized as being of God. That is not the understanding of God that the disciples received from Jesus. Notions that rationalize violence and cruelty have been out of date for at least 2000 years.
      .

      Delete
    2. Anne,

      Read chapter 2 on the People of God which I have posted on my website.

      https://lakeohioweal.blogspot.com/2026/09/the-people-of-god.html

      Liberals and conservatives, Christian or not, have difficulty grounding human rights and dignity on reason and/or empathy without invoking revelation.

      Protestants have difficulty because they believe in personal interpretation of revelation rather than organizational interpretation of revelation which allows them to pick and choose among scripture.

      Catholics get into difficulty when they try to invoke the catechism or magisterium rather than relying upon scripture as taught by the liturgy and the lives of the saints.

      Delete
  10. Related to David's "Evil" post below, philosopher Susan Neiman is interviewed by Chris Hedges on his podcast.

    https://youtu.be/isge-IKQLQM?si=wCUVNg5EeVJBLhaB

    ReplyDelete
  11. I understood from one of the referenced articles that Barron would say that genuine love (Christian charity, the type of love for which the Greek term "agape" would be used) may require that we be willing to hurt the feelings of those for whom we have empathy.

    We don't need to appeal to agape here. Common sense dictates that it is ridiculous to hold as your highest guiding principle to avoid hurting the feelings of those for whom you have empathy. One of Barron's examples of "suicidal empathy" is letting an inferior musician play for the Chicago Symphony Orchestra rather than hurt his or her feelings. Of course it would be insane to let "empathy" determine who should be engaged for merit-based positions. Who would argue otherwise? What Barron is doing, in reality, is giving aid and comfort to bigots who claim black people shouldn't be airplane pilots or surgeons because they must be "DEI hires." Look at Pete Hegseth denying promotions to black and female career military members.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Amen. Barron, wittingly or not, might be said to be giving religious cover to Hegseth and his ilk.

      Delete
    2. Yes, he is giving cover to them and I’m guessing he is well aware of it. He’s also set up a straw man argument that he knows darn well is simply a ludicrous diversion from the real issues. I have zero respect for Barron. His ambition is blinding him.

      Delete
    3. "Look at Pete Hegseth denying promotions to black and female career military members."

      Right - that is dispicable.

      At the same time: "DEI hires" doesn't always have to be in scare quotes. Examples of genuine DEI hires are not difficult to find. The most recent that springs to mind is that poor fool who was granted a professorship at Cambridge and then committed suicide when his apparently entirely fictional CV was brought to light.

      The whole business of Ivy League colleges not only engaging in "DEI admittances" for identity groups which are deemed empathy-worthy, but also working actively *not* to admit applicants who belong to identity groups which apparently have been deemed empathy-unworthy, is profoundly unjust. One isn't a bigot for calling this out (although anyone who calls this out will almost invariably be branded a bigot).

      Delete
    4. "Barron, wittingly or not, might be said to be giving religious cover to Hegseth and his ilk."

      I am sorry, but I don't think Barron should be silenced from speaking or writing what is true, simply because there are evil people like Hegseth in the world.

      One sees this dynamic among those who insist that any criticism of Netanyahu and the state of Israel is to give comfort to Nazis, Hamas and other murderous anti-Semites.

      We should be able to hold two ideas (anti-Semitism is bad; Netanyahu's government does evil things) in our mind at the same time.

      If Barron is going to speak out against "toxic empathy", then maybe he also has an obligation to speak out against those would use their opposition to "toxic empathy" as cover for committing evil acts. Whether Barron has done this, I don't know.

      Delete
    5. What silence? On the contrary, I want all the "toxic empathy" people to be talk far and wide about their beliefs so I can avoid the hell out of them.

      I just don't get Barron's interest in taking up a call against "toxic empathy" when so many prominent people could use some. It doesn't strike me as something in line with his evangelization efforts, either, unless he's sussed out the fact that the people who want to join the Church are into the "toxic empathy" shtick.

      I don't know what his obligation is to talk moderation. He's one of yours, not mine.

      Delete
    6. Barron? I don't much care about him. I don't teach any classes so I don't have occasion to use Word on Fire materials.
      Our archbishop spends a lot of time doing things like, running the archdiocese. He's in our town today, for a clergy conference. He actually goes out to the towns which aren't Omaha or its suburbs. Seems like he's a busy person. Maybe I'm mistaken, but I get the idea that the diocese Barron is in actually charge of is kind of an afterthought.

      Delete
    7. Word on Fire Catholic Ministries is a highly successful, multi-million dollar media and educational apostolate that has experienced rapid financial growth. Founded in 2000 by Bishop Robert Barron, the 501(c)(3) nonprofit operates as a premier modern Catholic media enterprise.

      Financial Scope & Size (FY2025)

      According to the organization's Form 990 tax filings, Word on Fire has evolved into a heavy-hitting financial operation:
      • Total Revenue: $30.7 million (up from $21.6M in FY2023 and $1.9M in 2011).
      • Total Expenses: $26.2 million.
      • Net Income: $4.5 million.
      • Total Assets: $56.6 million.
      • Staff Size: 83 employees, led by CEO Fr. Steve Grunow and a executive team with top compensations hovering around $175,000 to $245,000.

      Core Operational Segments

      The enterprise's footprint spans across heavy digital media presence, physical publishing, and academic programming:
      • The Word on Fire Institute: An educational arm boasting over 30,000 active members that partners directly with the Catholic University of America.
      • Digital & Media Reach: A dominant global digital presence anchored by Bishop Barron's flagship YouTube channel, which commands over 2 million subscribers.
      • Publishing House: A highly active press with dozens of proprietary titles. Notably, the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) selected Word on Fire to publish the official new second edition of the Liturgy of the Hours, marking the first Vatican-approved English translation of the daily prayer texts in 50 years.
      • Real Estate Expansion: Reflecting its asset growth, the ministry has begun acquiring physical properties, such as a former church facility in Minnesota purchased for $1.95 million to scale up operations.

      Delete
  12. I’ve fallen behind.somewhere Jim, you complain about colleges using DEI in admissions, I am familiar with admissions at “elite” colleges, including those in the Ivy League. My middle son aimed pretty high when he was applying to college. We didn’t use paid college advisors in those days as many do now, but I did buy college guides. When #2 son decided to apply to several reaches ( and some safe schools) I found a guide that described itself as a guide for applicants to America’s top colleges— the Ivies and several “ Public Ivies” like Michigan, Virginia, UCLA etc. . I think there were 18 schools on the list. It was written by a former admissions person at Dartmouth. Even then people were complaining about “ affirmative action” in college admissions. The author pointed out something that I’ve not forgotten. She said colleges are communities, and like all communities, include a range of citizens with different backgrounds, abilities, talents, interests etc. the admissions dept tries to create a balance in admitting students. So they admit a top football or basketball player with decent grades and decent SATs over a top student with higher SATs. (I don’t hear MAGAs complaining about athletes getting preference, nor about legacies getting it in private schools);. These schools receive far more applicants than they can admit. She said that the vast majority of applicants could succeed at these schools, but since there is only space for fewer than 10% of applicants they look at other things besides academics. So one year the college orchestra might need a talented oboist because their best one is graduating and a lucky high school oboist with lower grades than someone else gets in. They might admit an African American student from a mediocre high school who founded and edited a non- official school publication over the math genius because they already have several of those and a talented writer/journalist with exceptional initiative beats out the Valedictorian/National Honor Society white, upper middle class kid . They admit athletes, musicians, artists, student organizers, actors, dancers, writers etc. They admit students from impoverished backgrounds who did well in spite of it (not just racial minorities but people like JD) . They believe that college students grow more if their fellow students don’t all come from the same background, especially those who came from privileged, white middle or upper middle class backgrounds. All three sons (white, upper middle, suburban) went to a top 25 private university. One son’s freshman year roommate was of Indian heritage and also farming - his family had a huge almond farm in California’s Central Valley (where 2/3 of the nation’s produce is grown). My son learned a lot from not rooming with another suburban, upper middle class white kid. His best friends there included two Viet Namese Americans (one of whom introduced him to his Viet Namese wife), and a Russian whose parents taught at University of Iowa. Another had a Mexican American roommate - family lived on the border in El Paso, and most of the proud relatives who were there to see him move in came from the other side of the border. All of these students were qualified to succeed as students at their highly competitive universities even though there were straight A kids from top high schools with perfect SATs and National Merit Finalist status who didn’t make it. DEI admissions enriched the community environment at our sons’ colleges. They learned so much by being away from their comfortable, mostly white, upper middle class suburban community and schools.

    ReplyDelete
  13. The whole business of Ivy League colleges not only engaging in "DEI admittances" for identity groups which are deemed empathy-worthy, but also working actively *not* to admit applicants who belong to identity groups which apparently have been deemed empathy-unworthy, is profoundly unjust. One isn't a bigot for calling this out (although anyone who calls this out will almost invariably be branded a bigot).

    First, I wonder how many people who would make this argument are thinking of black students being admitted to Ivy League schools taking spots that should have gone to whites. (The Supreme Court decision against Harvard's admissions policies found that it was Asian students who were disadvantaged.)

    ChatGPT makes an interesting point:

    Should justice in college admissions be understood primarily as fairness between individual applicants, or can justice sometimes require institutions to consider inequalities between social groups?

    That is a genuine philosophical disagreement, not merely a dispute about political correctness.

    And it leads to an even more difficult question: If society has systematically disadvantaged a group for generations, what obligations, if any, do institutions have to correct that disadvantage when doing so may impose costs on individuals who were not responsible for creating it?


    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. David, the bolded paragraphs make the point. Those of us with privileged backgrounds ( meaning— we are white and educated) need to reflect on this.

      Delete
    2. "Should justice in college admissions be understood primarily as fairness between individual applicants, or can justice sometimes require institutions to consider inequalities between social groups?"

      It should be understood primarily as fairness between individual applicants.

      To try to rectify historical (and continuing) inequalities among demographic groups via college admissions is to pile one more injustice on top of the others.

      To be clear: it was the Asian students that i had in mind when I wrote the comment to which you responded.

      Delete
    3. Do you really think it’s possible to create perfect fairness aKong individual applicants? The Asian American students often excel at academics because of their family and culture. My daughter in law is Asian and has a Masters from an Ivy (Cornell), and a second masters and a PhD from Cal. I’ve seen this culture up close. Her younger sister has a similar academic resume. But not her brother, who seems to have fallen victim to the mostly white manosphere culture that blames DEI for their failure to keep up with women.

      The student body at our neighborhood high school is more than 38% Asian American, mostly Chinese American. This is a public school that sends a large percentage of their students to the private and public ivies — even though not a magnet school. In the county (153,000 students) the Asian American students are between 45-57% of the magnet school students. Asian Americans are 16% of the total county population. Asian Americans at the top universities in California Cal, UCLA, and Stanford are about 35% of the undergraduate student bodies. In the 25%+ in the Ivies. Closer to 50% at MIT and Cal Tech. At colleges and universities with caps on enrollment, the Asian American kids could theoretically fill close to 100% of every class. DEI would probably help white kids, not just black and Latino kids.

      If colleges and universities can’t try to diversify the racial makeup of their communities then how would you suggest they create a just admissions system? Or should Asian Americans get every slot? Asian culture excels at producing academically strong students. Should we try to figure out a way to impose Asian culture on all? Is academic strength the only important consideration?

      Delete
  14. Our sons went to colleges in the state are university system. They had decent but not stellar grades in high school. We helped them as much as we could with college expenses but they had to carry some student loans. Both ended up in careers they are happy with (only one of them in the field he majored in). Non-Ivy public colleges are a perfectly good option.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Typo, "are" doesn't belong in the first sentence.

      Delete
    2. Katherine, I don’t think DEI admissions are a controversial issue for most state colleges. The overwhelming majority of students do not go to Ivies or even to the huge state universities called “public ivies”. Most are happy where they end up, and most do well in life.Having a college degree is a career boost, but it doesn’t really matter a whole lot where the degree was earned unless someone is looking to join a hot- shot Wall Street firm.

      The MAGA unhappiness about racial preferences for fully qualified students who aren’t number one in their high school class is focused on the hardest colleges to get into. Like Harvard. The Dartmouth admissions officer presents a good explanation of how preferences based on racial diversity is simply one of several categories of preferences, ranging from athletic admissions to legacy preferences. Being white and number one in his upper middle class school class helped Hegseth get into Princeton, but he is a great example of the real world failure of some who go to the “best” universities. But he is not doubted the way Obama is. Since Obama is black he couldn’t have gotten into,Harvard Law on his merit says MAGA. Yet they never mention Thomas, who very likely benefited from affirmative action in getting into Yale law school

      The war on DEI seems an excuse to avoid admitting that women and minorities can be just as smart and capable as white males. But according to the DEI warriors, they only got where they are because of DEI, not from brains, talent and hard work. I’m guessing that Margaret Hamilton (who just died) was not a DEI hire but someone was smart enough to recognize the brains and talent she had and made a good hiring decision. Trump’s admission to Penn, on the other hand, was probably a rich kid admit, a member of a preference group of the very wealthy who might donate lots of money to the school . Of course, he doesn’t contribute to anything except his own bank accounts.

      https://tinyurl.com/7jy5djsb

      Delete
  15. The ultimate DEI in colleges will be the “spots” going to only those who can afford it. I hear of tuitions of $70,000 per year. While super-achievers and athletes might get a scholarship, what happens to the next tier of people who have ability but not enough to get scholarships? They could become competent doctors, engineers and other but will either not attend or will start their adult lives with overbearing debt. Social and financial stratification, something we thought was of the past.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Stanley, some of the Ivies ( with the largest endowments) are no longer charging tuition for students whose families have less than $200,000 income. Small liberal arts colleges can’t afford to do this, and they keep closing their doors. Several major universities cover 100% of undergraduate tuition for families earning under $200,000 per year with typical assets.

      * [Harvard University](https://www.harvard.edu): Covers full tuition for families making under $200,000; families making under $100,000 pay nothing for total cost of attendance (tuition, housing, and food). [2, 3]
      * [Yale University](https://www.yale.edu): Offers free tuition for households earning less than $200,000, and covers all costs for families earning under $100,000. [4]
      * [MIT](https://www.mit.edu): Eliminates tuition for families earning under $200,000 and covers full cost of attendance for incomes below $100,000.
      * [University of Pennsylvania](https://www.upenn.edu): Provides free tuition under its Quaker Commitment for families with incomes of $200,000 or less.
      * [Johns Hopkins University](https://www.jhu.edu): Operates a Tuition-Free program covering tuition for families earning up to $200,000, plus living expenses for those under $100,000.
      * [Emory University](https://www.emory.edu): Covers full tuition for undergraduate students whose families earn $200,000 or less.
      * [Boston University](https://www.bu.edu): Enforces the BU Promise, covering full tuition for domestic first-year students from families making under $200,000.
      * [California Institute of Technology](https://www.caltech.edu): Offers free tuition to families making less than $200,000 and no-loan packages for lower-income brackets.

      ## Higher Thresholds ($250,000)

      * [Princeton University](https://www.princeton.edu): Covers full tuition for families making up to $250,000 and the full cost of attendance for those under $150,000.
      * [University of Chicago](https://www.uchicago.edu): Extends free tuition coverage to families

      Delete
    2. Sounds good, Anne. My friend's daughter, pretty much disowned by her mother's family (where the money is since my friend was financially ruined from fighting his ex's scurrilous accusations) because she came out as gay, is applying to many schools, some Ivy League. She is an excellent high-scoring student who has already taken college level courses. It'll be interesting to see how she does versus the information you gave me. Sometimes a decimal place in grade average can make the difference.

      Delete
    3. DEI also includes students from "underserved" regions. My old boyfriend from the UP said he likely got into U-M law school bc they set aside a certain number of seats for Michigan students from the hinterlands. He then went back to the UP to represent one of the Native tribes. There is a perception that DEI students are somehow "less than," which is not true. They all still have to qualify for admissions.

      Delete
    4. Jean, thank you for making the point far more succinctly than I have. DEI admits are just as qualified as others. Your point about your old boyfriend may apply to JD Vance too. His Appalachian background and military stint ( a long way from the fighting, but military) may have given him an edge for Yale law school. He did ok in college and probably had decent law boards, but he did not have a typical white middle class background. He may have been a DEI admit - who, like most DEI admits, was qualified.

      Delete
    5. That would be interesting to know abt JD.

      Having had recently, as I'm sure you have too, quite a snoot full of doctors, I would say that widening the pool to as many different people as possible is good for the profession.

      Yes, we all want qualified doctors admitted and trained under stringent conditions. But having doctors who know how to listen, talk to people, hire good staff, and not rush patients thru decisions helps recovery as much as anything. You really can't measure those skills on an admissions test.

      Delete
    6. Stanley, If she is willing to commit, she should apply early decision as the admit rate is higher in that category. This list is only Ivy League and MIT but most colleges offer early decision these days - it’s binding so students who need financial aid usually wait to see who has the best package of grants v loans. Not all of the Ivies offer free tuition to families earning less than $200k. Nor do all have a binding early decision option. Our youngest applied to his college early decision. So we knew before Christmas where he was going, which was a big relief compared to his older brothers. Applying ED takes some stress out of the process, The son who applied to 13 colleges did end up at one of the “reach” schools. He had good grades and good SATs but not 4.0 or 1600 SAT. Yet he did better in acceptances than the valedictorian and some perfect or nearly perfect SAT kids. He worked really hard on his essays (he was a good writer)— one of his essays literally made me laugh at loud (it was very non- traditional) and I think if he made an admissions officer laugh it probably helped. A couple of his teachers wrote exceptionally strong and specific letters of recommendation. But the regular school college counselors told him he was reaching too high and should stick with the safer schools on his list (it upset him. It didn’t deter him). He was accepted to four of his six reach schools. So I hope this take from long ago encourages your friends daughter! She doesn’t have to max her test scores and grades since she’s pretty solid there it seems. Times have changed a whole as has the college application process lot since he was applying to college in 1998!

      AI says
      “Across the Ivy League and MIT, applying in the early round yields a significantly higher acceptance rate compared to Regular Decision. For several Ivy League schools, the early acceptance rate is three to four times higher than the regular pool, though much of this "advantage" includes recruited athletes and legacy applicants. [1, 2]
      The early round structures differ by school: [1]
      * Early Decision (ED): Binding. If accepted, you must enroll (Brown, Columbia, Cornell, Dartmouth, Penn).
      * Single-Choice / Restrictive Early Action (SCEA/REA): Non-binding, but you cannot apply early to other private universities (Harvard, Princeton, Yale).
      * Early Action (EA): Non-binding and non-restrictive (MIT). [1, 3, 4]
      ## Early vs. Regular Acceptance Rates (Class of 2030 / Latest Data)

      | University | Early Round Type | Early Admit Rate | Regular Decision Rate | Overall Admit Rate |
      Brown | ED | 16.46% | 3.5% | 5.35% |
      | Dartmouth | ED | 16.0% | 3.5% | 5.80% |
      | Columbia | ED | 11.5% | 2.8% | 4.23% |
      | Yale | SCEA | 10.5% | 3.4% | 4.24% |
      | Penn | ED | 15.0% | 4.0% | 5.84% |
      | Cornell | ED | 19.5% | 6.7% | 9.22% |
      | Harvard | REA | 8.5% | 2.5% | Pending |
      | Princeton | SCEA | 12.0% | 3.0% | Pending |
      | MIT | EA | 5.5% | 3.9% | 4.60% |
      *Schools with binding Early Decision (like Brown and Dartmouth) show the largest statistical inflation in early rounds. They use this round to lock in a large percentage of their incoming freshman class (often filling 40% to 50% of the entire class early). Because MIT uses standard, non-binding Early Action, their early rate (5.5%) is only slightly higher than their regular rate (3.9%). They do not offer a major statistical advantage for applying early, as applicants are not locked in.

      AI also offered to help me with my strategy for applying to these schools.😁 I would advise her NOT to use AI for any part of her applications!

      Delete
    7. Jean, I met with three oncologists - all highly qualified. I went with the doc who met these criteria

      Delete
    8. Published the last comment too soon - agree completely with this — “ But having doctors who know how to listen, talk to people, hire good staff, and not rush patients thru decisions helps recovery as much as anything. You really can't measure those skills on an admissions test.”. Amen!

      Delete
  16. The same DEI-driven (mostly racial) resentments that have been highly publicized in Ivy admissions, play out elsewhere as well. It happens in Chicago surrounding admissions to its so-called magnet high schools. It seems Asian and white kids qualify in disproportionate numbers. Some politicians now advocate abolishing the magnet schools as a way to end the controversy.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What are the results of the magnet schools? Do kids do better with them? We don't have them here, but they do in Omaha. They're middle schools, I don't think there are any magnet high schools there. Results are mixed. One in particular had some violence issues.

      Delete
    2. I would be interested in knowing how they measure the results of magnet schools. We have them here, and one in Virginia was the center of a major lawsuit— a science and technology high school. If they measure the success by where they go to college I would guess that the same kids in a normal public school would end up in the same colleges as if they graduated from a magnet.,

      Delete
    3. I stand corrected, there are two magnet high schools in Omaha. Both are in not-so-great areas.
      Anne, good question, about how they measure results.

      Delete
    4. "I would be interested in knowing how they measure the results of magnet schools."

      From what I can tell, there are three basic ways they measure magnet schools, at least in Chicago:

      1. Entrance exams - not required for neighborhood high schools, but required for admittance to a magnet high school. Exam results are one but not the only criterion.

      2. The magnet schools are audited by an outside agency who scores them on academics and probably a number of other dimensions

      3,. College acceptance rates, including to elite colleges.

      Of course, the best way to measure their effectiveness would be via standardized tests; but the political reality in Chicago is, the teachers have too much political clout to permit standardized test scores to be used in any way that might allow administrators and the public to measure teaching ability.

      Delete
    5. If the kids who get into the magnet school are the best and the brightest, it seems that they would get into elite colleges even if they had gone to the neighborhood public high school. Ideally they would have two groups of comparable students they could compare as far as college admissions go. Magnet schools who have entrance exams should have close to 100% going to college somewhere. Did being in a magnet program really help them get into an elite colleges.? Our local public high school sends lots of kids to elite colleges. I wonder how it compares to the magnet high schools in the county. Should these schools be treated by college admissions folk as they treat elite private high schools? Are they better prepared for college work than the kids who are in their admit class who graduated from regular high schools?
      I had a very good friend ( sadly, she died two years ago) who testified at lots of school board meetings fighting for budget for the GT program in elementary schools, and magnets for junior high and high school. Her older daughter went to one. Her second daughter went to the regular high school. I don’t see that it made a lot of difference in their college choices. Anyway, I can’t discuss with her anymore. She knew far more about the pros and cons of magnet programs than I did. Or do.maybe they’re not actually needed. I don’t know.

      Delete
  17. Jim, you might be interested in the lawsuit against the northern Virginia science- tech magnet school. Before the lawsuit, about 75% of the students were Asian American. It dropped to about 50% when affirmative action steps were taken. Before reading this wiki article, I was unaware of the school’s collusion with China and of its extensive support by big DOD contractors. It IS a public school so hadn’t realized how much private funding it had. Lots of controversy with it. One of our youngest son’s closest friends went there - a white kid who then went to Princeton ( they became friends while in a DC area summer rowing program). His friend cashed out shares he received when working for a Silicon Valley crypto startup- selling his shares at the peak. He was a multi millionaire at 30. Silicon Valley startups often give shares to attract employees because they skimp on salaries and benefits. Apparently National Review was involved in pushing the lawsuit.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Forgot the link. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Jefferson_High_School_for_Science_and_Technology

      Delete
  18. Thanks Anne, for your extensive comments about your experience with admission to elite schools. Already when I was an undergraduate, research was coming to the conclusion that one's peers were as important as the prestige of the school and the talents of the faculty. Educational institutions were taking note of that research and beginning to structure admissions around getting a diversity of student talent. That, of course, led to competition among students for extracurriculars as well as grades, and test scores. Obviously combining all those makes for a complex admissions process.

    In my own undergraduate education, many of my peers influenced me as much as my professors. Although I choose Saint John's University, Collegeville Minnesota because I was interested in the priesthood and it allowed divinity student to room with regular students and not have a diocese or a religious school sponsor. It also allowed students to choose a major other than philosophy. In other words, during Vatican II it was already a post Vatican II institution.

    A mentally ill person when asked what he wanted from the mental health system, replied not the most expensive one, nor the one with the latest best practices, but one that he had helped to shape and would be there when he needed it. I think that is true of educational institutions as well.

    While I was an English major at Saint John's I took psychology courses at U Washington-Seattle and U Minnesota during their summer quarters. (So, I had the equivalent of a psychology major from good schools.) Saint John's also had a good sociology department, so I decided I wanted an interdisciplinary graduate degree in psychology and sociology. There were few such programs I did not get into the ones at Harvard and University of Michigan but I did get a scholarship to a new program funded by the National Science Foundation at the University of Missouri in Columbia. That eventually led to a National Institute of Mental Health postdoctoral Fellowship with a person who had one of their longest running grants.

    People have often asked me about the difference between small liberal arts colleges and large state universities. My experience has been that students do get much more attention at small liberal arts schools however those who go to large state universities will get the same attention and perhaps even better professors if they seek them out. So you can get a better and cheaper education at state schools if you are a self-starter. Those professors are often better plugged into graduate programs around the country than professors from liberal arts colleges at least in the discipline of psychology.

    Finally, nothing beats practical experience. The University of Massachusetts had an extensive program of credits for practice experience that started with a pre-course from the regular syllabus, e.g. social psychology, supervised experience, then a special studies course integrating the whole experience.

    ReplyDelete