This past spring, my daughter graduated from Loyola with a degree in education. She did well in college, well enough that she was given an award for academic achievement by the department. The School of Education held an award ceremony at its downtown Water Tower Campus for the seniors receiving these awards, a brunch to which us parents also were invited. Several of the graduating seniors were invited to speak, and it was quite interesting that, while most of the seniors planned to get jobs as teachers in the Chicago area immediately after graduation, several of them had accepted offers to give one or two years of service by teaching in underserved areas, either in the United States or overseas, where qualified teachers are desperately needed. Those who had chosen this path attributed their time spent at Loyola as inspiring them to give up a prime year or two of their lives in this service. As a Loyola grad myself, it warmed my heart to hear that alma mater was still having this kind of effect on its students
“If your
hand causes you to sin, cut it off!”, exhorts Jesus in today’s Gospel passage. Following Jesus isn’t a casual or half-hearted
enterprise: either you’re in or you’re out; and if you’re in, you’re all the
way in. It’s more important than
everything: more important than our jobs, even more important than our families. We must be prepared to give up all our money,
and even the limbs of our very bodies, said Jesus in today’s Gospel.
I think it’s fair to say that all of us here
today have reaped the benefits of being served by those who are all the way in,
who have made significant sacrifices in their lives to serve us. I’d put our two priests, Fr. Darrio and Fr.
Rodolfo, in that category: becoming a priest means giving up many of the pleasures
and comforts of life to serve God’s people.
Surely, we can say the same of the religious women who are members of
our faith community. But of course, you
don’t have to be a priest or a religious to serve God and his people. My daughter works today as a Catholic school
teacher. One thing we can say with
certainty about school teachers is that the probability of their growing rich
doing this work is zero. Yet she is one
of many teachers who are members of the St. Edna faith community – in fact, I’ve
never seen a place that turns out as many teachers as St. Edna does. This is one of the things I love about St.
Edna: our pews are filled with teachers, nurses, health care workers, social workers and
others who are dedicating their lives to serving one another and God. I’ve spoken with parishioners who have set
aside years of their lives to care for an ailing parent or family member, sometimes
walking away from their careers and moving hundreds of miles away to perform this
service of love.
And then
there are those who have given even more: those who have given, not only a few
years or their careers, and not only a hand or an eye, but their very lives. Like many of you who are my age or older, we
grew up attending mass with what today is called Eucharistic Prayer no. 1, with
its two magnificent lists of ancient martyrs: Linus, Cletus, Clement, Sixtus,
Cornelius and so on; and the ancient women martyrs of the Roman church:
Felicity, Perpetua, Agatha, Lucy, Agnes, Cecilia, Anastasia. In most cases, we know almost nothing about
their lives, except the most important thing: that they gave their lives for
the sake of the kingdom of God. I’ve
heard it said that the blood of these first Christian and Roman martyrs watered
the young and vulnerable early church the way the spring rains water the grass
and flowers that are just starting to sprout.
Not all
martyrs are from ancient times; the world is still making martyrs today. In a couple of weeks, on October 14th,
Pope Francis is going to canonize one, a great and holy man, Oscar Romero, the
archbishop of San Salvador, who was assassinated in 1980 for continually
opposing the military regime that ruled El Salvador and terrorized and killed
the poor farmers of the country. Oscar
Romero died for the poor of El Salvador, the campesinos and their widows and orphans. I wish I had time to tell you everything I
know about his life, how being exposed to the atrocities to which the Salvadoran poor were subjected brought about a change in heart for Romero and led him to speak out
so forcefully and effectively against a regime which expected the archbishop of
the capital city to be its ally rather than its enemy. Oscar Romero was a great man, and I encourage
you to read everything you can in the next few days as the media helps us remember
this martyr who lived and who died during many of our own lifetimes. We must remember our martyrs.
I don’t know
how much it’s recalled these days that Romero wasn’t the only martyr of El
Salvador’s civil war. There were other
Salvadoran priests, religious and lay church employees and volunteers who also
were killed. And there were four American Catholic women, doing missionary work
in El Salvador, who were brutally martyred.
Two of them, Maura Clarke and Ita Ford, were Maryknoll sisters from New
York City. A third, Dorothy Kazel, was
an Ursuline sister from Cleveland. It’s
the fourth, Jean Donovan, about whom I’d like to say a few words today.
Unlike the
other three women, Jean was a layperson.
She was born in 1953, so she was a Baby Boomer. She grew up in a Catholic family in a middle-class
community in Connecticut that in some ways probably wasn’t too different from
Arlington Heights and Buffalo Grove. Like
many of the kids in our community, she went off to college, during which time
she spent a year in Ireland as an exchange student. When she returned to the United States, she
finished college and then earned an MBA, and got hired as a management
consultant at Arthur Andersen. Jean clearly
was a bright and hardworking young woman, and her life was following the same
trajectory that I could wish my own kids’ lives to follow – probably many of us
harbor similar hopes for our children and grandchildren. She became engaged to a young doctor. She thought she would get married and dreamed
of being a mom. This is what life in the
United States offered Catholic Baby Boomers.
But God
offered her other paths. As a young
adult, Jean was living in Cleveland and doing youth ministry volunteer
work. She was given the opportunity to
join the diocese’s Mission Project in El Salvador. It turns out that, while she had been in
Ireland as an exchange student, she had befriended a priest who had done
missionary work in Peru, and he had planted the seed in her that missionary
work is worthwhile and critically needed.
So she decided to go to El Salvador for a time. She went there in 1979, when she was 26 – not much older than my oldest child. She found herself in the midst of violence, war and many human rights violations. She worked with Maryknoll sisters in El
Salvador to help refugees of the war.
She admired Oscar Romero and went often to hear him preach.
Helping poor
refugees of the Salvadoran civil war is work that we would admire, but it was
enough to earn the enmity of the ruling regime.
She knew she was running a risk by staying. A few weeks before she died, she wrote a
friend, “The Peace Corps left today and my heart sank low. The danger is extreme, and they were right to
leave … Now I must assess my own position, because I am not up for suicide.
Several times I have decided to leave El Salvador. I almost could, except for the children, the
poor, bruised victims of this insanity.
Who would care for them? Whose
heart could be so staunch as to favor the reasonable thing in a sea of their tears
and loneliness? Not mine.” I hope you’ll forgive me if my eyes tear up a
little bit here. She had a choice
between her own safety and serving the children, and she chose the kids. And it seems she understood what that
meant. This may have been the moment
when she embraced the possibility of martyrdom.
On December
2nd, 1980, Jean Donovan, along with Sister Dorothy Kazel, drove to
the airport to meet Sisters Ita Ford and Maura Clarke, who were returning from
a conference in Nicaragua. National
Guardsmen were surveilling them, and when the women’s vehicle left the airport,
the guardsmen stopped them. The four
women were taken away to a secluded spot, and there the guardsmen beat, and
then raped, and then murdered Jean Donovan and the three religious
sisters. Their bodies were left in a
ditch. The government ordered the bodies
of the women be buried in a common grave, but Oscar Romero’s successor, Arturo
Rivera Damas, and the US Ambassador, Robert White, had the bodies
exhumed. Jean Donovan’s body was flown
back to the United States and returned to her parents. I can’t imagine their grief.
Jean Donovan’s
work on behalf of the suffering in El Salvador is inspiring, but the most
arresting witness – the word “martyr” means “witness” - is the witness of her
death. There is no simpler way to put it
than that, in dying for the Salvadoran children, she died for Jesus and for us. She gave everything she had to the one who
gave everything for us. In a few
minutes, in our Eucharistic prayer, we’ll give thanks to Jesus for that gift of
all of himself. We might also offer a quiet
word of thanks for the witness of martyrs like Jean Donovan, a person who was like
us, but who was “all in” for the Kingdom of God.
Without wishing to take anything away from these holy martyrs, I am reminded of what our old priest used to tell us: we are all martyrs for Christ. Some martyrs die violent deaths. Some are willing to die to their old lives to be born again through conversion. And some slowly empty our lives in service to others--family, friends, and communities.
ReplyDeleteWishing your daughter the very best as a teacher, Jim. It is a profession under fire these days, and those who take it on are often slow martyrs to educational theorists, administrators, government regulations and politicians, parents, and the kids themselves. Bless them!
Jean, I think that's really insightful from your old priest - something I'd wish to think about.
DeleteJesus's words are a big challenge for me. I suspect I'd find myself ready to stop well short of losing a limb. I've passed on ministry opportunities that would involve losing out on a few hours of sleep.
Thanks for the good wishes for my daughter. Catholic schools being in the precarious financial position they are, I think if her school stays open for a year beyond this one, it's a victory.
I think Catholic schools are moving into a "third phase" that might lead to a resurgence.
DeleteFirst phase was run by nuns or brothers, second phase was run by lay people who were taught by nuns and brothers and tried (often badly) to recreate the experience.
Third phase has no ties to those old days and is dealing with a more diverse student population. They might feel more free to reimagine Catholic education in ways that serve the entire community.
Kudos, Jim, for delivering the homily I've been waiting in vain to hear. Every year, as the Dec. 2 date of the assassinations nears, I feel like nagging the parish priests to take note. After all, these were four American women martyred for their faith. (Bl. Stanley Rother could be added -- killed in Guatemala, not El Salvador, but by the same kinds of people, for the same reason. Or is he to be a local Oklahoma saint?). But, of course, they all are controversial. At the time, the U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations said they probably were Marxists, and the Secretary of State said something like "Stalin blessed their rosary beads." As good and holy Catholics would have said of St. Francis Xavier, had they been among the quick in his time, it's what you get for interfering where you don't belong.
ReplyDeleteHowever, I have expected more from our bishops, who are always quick to add a new Marian memorial on grounds that it will "show more clearly her Son's contribution to our salvation." It's true, Holy Mother Church hasn't gotten around to canonizing them yet, but those good and holy Catholics who think they were baptizing with Volga water are the U.S. bishops' sheep, and they are grazing around the wolf's lair.
I also think you made, very nicely, your point that not everyone is called to go to Latin America during civil wars, but they are called to witness, as Ms. Donovan and the sisters did, where the Spirit leads them. Bottom line: Thanks,Jim.
Tom, I really think Dec 2 should be on the calendar of saints for the US. Maybe the date is already occupied.
DeleteAccording to my breviary (I misplaced my ordo for this year somehow -- maybe your wife gave it to someone who needed it more :-)), December 2nd isn't already taken by a saint on the universal calendar. December 3rd is Francis Xavier, so maybe there's some sort of adjacent-days symmetry between the four American women and Francis X - I'd need to think about it a bit.
DeleteThe beatification of Bl. Stanley Rother was a big deal here. There was a write-up of the occasion in the diocesan paper, as well as the regional daily. I think there were even some area people who attended the ceremony.
DeleteI am ashamed to say I hadn't heard of him before, either. Thank you, Tom and Katherine.
DeleteThanks Jim, for the information on these martyrs. I had heard of Sister Dorothy Stang, but not Sister Dorothy Kazel. And I hadn't realized that Jean Donovan was a lay woman. How sad that they suffered so terribly at the hands of guardsmen who were probably at least baptized, but apparently sold their souls.
ReplyDeleteI had heard the name Dorothy Stang before, but knew nothing about her until you mentioned her. And now I see that she taught in the Chicago Archdiocese in the 1950s. I need to figure out if those parishes are still open and whether I know any deacons at them ...
Delete... and now, looking into it, I see that one of them, St. Victor parish in Calumet City, IL, is slated to close in 2020, with the parishioners and staff merging with two other parishes in Calumet City. Coincidentally, I spent all day today and will spend all day tomorrow in an archdiocesan-wide conference about the program, Renew My Church, which is driving this consolidation/closure (as well as other consolidations, clustering, etc. around the archdicoese).
When St. Victor closes, a connection with Dorothy Stang would also go away, unless they take care to preserve it somehow.
... and according to this history of the parish and school, which manages to not mention Sr. Dorothy, St. Victor's school, where she taught, closed in 2004.
http://www.svs78.com/class_custom2.cfm
Regarding the other school, St. Alexander in Villa Park, which turns out to be in the next county over (DuPage County) and therefore in the Joliet Diocese, it's a similar situation: the school closed in 2015. The parish's website's history page indicates that the school opened but there is no mention of its closing, nor of Sr. Dorothy Stang's presence at the school.
No wonder none of us are aware of these heroic women. It's like institutional amnesia.
Institutional amnesia is a good name for it. Sister Dorothy was martyred in Brazil, not Central America, and her killers were motivated as much by greed as by ideology, as I understand it. But she belongs with the Central American martyrs because they all, in one way or another, died because their homeland was more interested in extirpating communism than in bringing in the reign of justice. Americans, above all, need to know and ponder their stories.
DeleteOf course, we have to clear them through the Vatican saint-makers before we can make it official. But Bl.Oscar Romero makes it a week from next Sunday, so there is hope all around, with a current pope who "gets it."
Sad that this is the world we live in, that who does or doesn't make sainthood is political.
DeleteJim speaks of Jean Donovan, the lay missionary murdered along with the three nuns in December, 1980. Here's my review of "Roses in December," a documentary film about her.
ReplyDeleteNational Catholic Reporter
August 27, 1982
“Roses in December:” a Document of Courage
By Gene Palumbo
“Remember?” said Ana Carrigan, to her co-producer, Bernard Stone. “Remember when we came back from those first interviews, and you said, ‘If we get to the end of this film, we’re going to be different people’?” He nodded, and they agreed he’d been right.
Their film, Roses in December, is likely to change other people, as it did them. It tells the story of Jean Donovan, the lay missioner who, along with three nuns, was raped and killed by members of El Salvador’s security forces in December, 1980.
Carrigan and Stone, along with co-producer David Meyer, tell the story through a combination of interviews with Donovan’s family and friends, excerpts from her diary and letters and film clips from the United States and El Salvador.
Carrigan and Stone said that in the beginning they were constantly asked, “Why isn’t the film about the nuns?”
“They were extraordinary,” said Carrigan, “but in a way, being nuns categorized them. An audience could respond by saying, ‘they’re special, they’re different, that could never be me.’” There was, Carrigan and Stone felt, a greater chance that an audience might identify with Jean.
She was surely no Therese of Lisieux. In the film one of her friends from Cleveland recalls how “I used to get terrified before we’d go into a bar. Jean would say, ‘No problem.’ We’d walk up and there’d be a bouncer at the door. He’d say, ‘Can I see your I.D., please?’ Jean would open her wallet, hand him her MasterCard and say, ‘Does anyone you know under 21 carry one of these?’”
In late 1977 Donovan surprised everyone when she announced that she was going to El Salvador as a lay missionary, as part of a team from the Cleveland diocese. Her parents went out to buy a map “to find out where El Salvador was.” Jean’s brother, Mike, thought she was joking. A friend in Cleveland asked why she was going: “I said to her, ‘You’ve got a beautiful apartment, a car and a motorcycle, and a job that other people would love to have.’ But she said she needed more.”
* * * * *
From the time she arrived in El Salvador in September, 1979, the words of her friend, Irish missionary Father Michael Crowley, began to be fulfilled: “If you stand with the poor, identify with them, feel their insecurity, their rejection, then you begin to understand in a new way.”
The first stage of Donovan’s new understanding was reflected in an early letter from El Salvador. “I can’t quite put my finger on it, but something inside me is different…. The social structure is much different here….It’s all so unfair.”
As for standing with the poor and feeling their insecurity, that was taken care of for her as the violence closed in. From her diary: “It’s unbelievable. People are being killed daily. We just found out that three people from one of our areas were taken, tortured and hacked to death.” Later her best friend in El Salvador was murdered outside her house.
(to be continued)
The film has interviews with a wide range of people who tried to persuade her to leave El Salvador. They felt they simply hadn’t reached her. That may be right, and not so surprising. It brings to mind what Wilfrid Sheed said after reading the essays Albert Camus wrote during World War II: “Camus’s feeling seems to be that violence so alters one’s total experience that those outside it cannot give rational advice to those inside it. They would simply be talking about different things.”
ReplyDeleteDonovan was “inside it,” living out her daily life in the midst of an undeclared war, helping the parish priest to bury the mangled, dismembered bodies of the casualties of that war.
She had other reasons for staying. Those “reasons” were people, Salvadorans she knew who had chosen to stay on, even in the face of death threats. She told me she revered Archbishop Oscar Romero – threatened innumerable times before finally being killed – and she may well have had in mind a sermon he gave after the murder of a priest and four teenagers. The killers, he said, were hoping to terrorize the church into silence and inaction, “and if we should oblige them, they will have won. But I do not believe the murders of these five have been in vain. They have preceded us in the experience of the resurrection. We live by that power that even death cannot destroy. We honor them and our faith by living unafraid, in the knowledge that evil has no future.”
Donovan gave no complicated answers herself. Her letters and diary entries, her statements to friends, were simple. During her final visit to Ireland, Crowley asked her to speak to a group of teenagers. Says one of them in the film: “She said she knew there was a good chance that she would be killed when she went back. But she said, ‘I belong there. I have to go back.’”
“I came to see,” said Carrigan, speaking of Donovan and the three women she died with, “that the meaning of their lives was so rich that death was not ultimately important. Every single day, when they got up, they had to know that that day might be ‘it,’ the end, as it had been for so many of their friends and so many people all around them. But it was like the biblical saying, ‘Death, where is thy sting?’ It wasn’t a factor for them. If it had been, they could never have done what they did. They simply couldn’t have functioned.”
Roses in December gives us a sense of that richness of life which Donovan had discovered. She who had been willing to lose her life, had found it. This story of one woman’s “yes” may help us utter our own.
I think we call can see, based on what Gene is posting here, what a rich source of knowledge and history he is.
DeleteOne thing I've sort been scratching my head about, not about this in particular but more in general: if I want to see a film like Roses in December, how would I find it? If it's not on NetFlix and not in my local public library, what other options do I have?
It's available on Amazon. It is very good. It would make a nice gift for your parish library. I would not show it to kids under 14.
Deletehttps://www.amazon.com/Roses-December-Jean-Donovan/dp/B000WC398G
Yeah. I got it from Amazon.
DeleteI sort of suspected Gene would recommend Roses in December, and so here is my pre-planned P.S. Yes, it should be seen. Parts of it are hard to look at; they should be especially seen.