Friday, June 8, 2018

What to read, and not, church documents edition [Updated]

Of the making of many books there is no end, and that goes for official teaching documents of the Catholic Church as well. The church is replete with cardinals, bishops, dicasteries, pontifical commissions, bishops conferences, departments of bishops conferences, and so on and so on, and they all have staffs, and they all put out documents, many of which are lengthy, and all of which are densely written.  Consequently, I  am perpetually behind in my reading.

So I have to pick my spots.  I chose to spend some hours poring over a recent document from the Holy See on the 2007 financial crisis (see blog posts here and here) but so far have not delved into what seems to be a more important teaching document, Pope Francis's new apostolic exhortation,  Gaudete et exsultate, on the call to holiness in the modern world.  That's the kind of document I have a sort of professional obligation to read and digest.  And I'll get around to it.  I promise.  Sooner or later.  When I have the time.

The notion of picking one's spots implies that some spots don't ever get picked, and I'm sorry to confess that there are some Vatican documents I'm extremely unlikely to ever read.   If anyone were to ask me, "What's the church document you're least likely to read?", I'd have had a ready answer: in 2007, one of the Vatican departments issued a document - and it is by no means a short one - on driving etiquette.  Please understand that I am not one to dismiss out of hand the notion that every human action has a moral dimension; and anyone who has learned to drive understands that it can be an occasion of sin.  But really - do I need some priest who teaches at a pontifical university and works on the side ghost-writing for some archbishop in some pontifical department, to tell me how to behave behind the wheel?  Didn't Vatican II, somewhere or other, promote the idea that lay adults can have an adult faith, and it's possible we may know as much, or more, about driving than a guy who walks from his cramped Roman apartment to his cramped Vatican office every day?   I guess that, technically, I'm not a layperson, but on this particular life skill, I really kind of am.

And so, the Holy See announcement last week that it has released a document on sports didn't elicit an enthusiastic response from me.  I didn't do the wave, or waggle a foam finger, or even low-five anyone.  My appetite was further un-whetted when I discovered that it's every bit as long as I feared it would be - 27 single-spaced pages of type in a small font.  My reaction was similar to my reaction to the driving essay: shouldn't folks like us be writing rather than reading those things?

This is the part of the post where I'm supposed to write, "But despite my misgivings, I plowed through the document, and you know what?  It's actually pretty good."  I'm not foreclosing the possibility that I may write that sentence in earnest some day.  Or maybe I am - cf above on the necessity of spot-picking.  I haven't read it, and there's at least a fair chance I won't read it.

As regards sports: I went to Catholic school for something like eight of my thirteen years of primary schooling.  Sports are big in Catholic schools.  They're big in the American Catholic culture.  I know sports and culture.  I've lived through it.  I've been the worst athlete on several teams.  I've been bullied by jocks.  I've seen them get preferential treatment from teachers and school administrators.

I've worked for companies that hire former professional athletes to play golf with their customers.  I've seen them get paid absurd salaries for hanging around the office and doing nothing except groping and harassing the female employees.

Sports aren't all bad. I've been a youth coach (probably a better coach than player).  From time to time I spend a lot of money attending sporting events.  I was a season ticket holder for Northwestern football for a time.  I watch a fair amount of sports on television - I watched a hockey game this evening.

So I admit that sports offers items of interest for discussion.  I just need to be convinced, I guess, that the Holy See has anything important, or even credible, to say about it.  Maybe I'll have to read the damn thing, just to find out what's in it.

Update 6/8/2018: Above, I had heaped scorn on the 2007 document from driving - scoffing at something I haven't actually read, which I guess isn't very admirable, but the point of the post is that some documents are on topics that seem so non-urgent that it's hard to find the motivation to commit to reading them through.  Anyway, I was closing some open tabs on my browser this morning, and discovered that I still had the driving document pulled up (I had opened it to provide the URL in the original post).  Shaking my head again at its intimidating length, and wondering somewhat idly how even a Vatican department can go on and on about something as trivial as driving, I scrolled through the table of contents and discovered it's about much more than driving.  There is a major section on prostitution, a major section on street children, and a major section on homelessness - the last of which is a primary focus of my pastoral ministry these days.  So now I'm actually pretty motivated to read it.  Maybe I'll need to take it all back. 

20 comments:

  1. Jim, LOL! Yeah,I can't think of anything more snooze inducing than a Vatican document on sports. I'm actually a sports fan. Because watching them or doing them keeps other people out of my hair while I do my own thing. When a Cornhusker football game is on is a primo time to go shopping. Even my better half, who really is a sports fan, admits that he sometimes turns on something like a golf tournament to get a nap in the recliner on a weekend afternoon.

    ReplyDelete
  2. A nice Jesuit professor from Seattle U who worked on the document has provided a highly condensed summary over at the America website, just for you, Jim.

    https://www.americamagazine.org/arts-culture/2018/06/07/why-catholic-church-cares-about-sports

    I am not a sports fan. But, someone up there with a wicked sense of humor, saw fit to have me marry a rabid sports fan and give birth to three more. So, every pro and college football and basketball game on TV had four yelling fans in the family room, which was often a good time to do the grocery shopping, since reading was impossible. Fortunately, none liked baseball. But it didn't much matter as far as silencing the roar of the TV crowds during the spring, as basketball season now lasts almost to fourth of July.

    When the boys got to school age, they started in soccer and basketball. Fortunately, none wanted to play football or baseball, or do summer swim team, a blessing for which I tried to remember to thank God every time I passed the community pool during a swim meet in the summer.

    For many years, on every weekend from Sept-June we attended 3 - 5 games in which our loved sons were playing, arranging complicated car pool schedules for games scheduled at the same time in opposite corners of the county, leaving no time or energy for much else on the weekends. They continued in school sports at the high school level - one played high school basketball, one played high school soccer, and one was a rower, as was his dad. I liked the rowing. Lovely days spent on the banks of a pretty river or lake somewhere, with the tension of the race lasting less than 5 minutes. Our rower son was the one who kept going after high school, eventually competing at the college and the international level. Rowing is not a fan sport. The only people who would go to the regattas were girlfriends/boyfriends and parents. Regattas are not shown on TV, except for snippets during the Olympics. In the US, there is no jock glory in rowing. So the rowers stick with it for pure love of the sport. It is probably the best example of pure teamwork in the sports world. Nobody can be the "star" of the crew team. Anyone who tries to row at a different rate than the other 7 in the boat will lose the race for the team. I love watching a really skilled eight - the precision and grace of a skilled crew is a thing of beauty.

    Our experience of Catholic high school sports for our older two boys was that the Catholic teams were often the "dirtiest" players, and their fans among the nastiest crowds. Our two older sons went to a Catholic high school, played in a league with both Catholic and independent private schools. They did not play against public schools except in an occasional tournament. For the most part, the behavior of the players and fans of the not Catholic independent school teams was more "christian" than that of the Catholic school teams.

    I was still an active Catholic when our sons played on their schools' teams, and was sometimes embarrassed by the behavior of the players, coaches and fans of so many of the Catholic teams, including our own. There was a notable exception in the league - the basketball teams coached by Morgan Wootten at De Matha high school, near DC were not only the best teams athletically, the behavior of players and fans was exemplary. The team brought home the championship most years, but what impressed us the most (including our son whose team regularly lost to them, a son who was not a particularly "good sport" himself) was the demeanor of the coach, and the polite behavior of his players and fans.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morgan_Wootten

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anne, that's pretty interesting about Catholic fan misbehavior. My kids attended a public high school, and their fans' behavior, both students and parents, is pretty exemplary. What's kind of a head-scratcher about that is that I'd guess that there is some correlation between social class and fan behavior, but it's difficult to argue these days that Catholic school parents and students are anything other than middle class or higher (at least around here). Because of the way the leagues are arranged, our local high school rarely plays a Catholic school (the Catholic schools have their own league), so I don't get to observe the Catholic fans and players up close. At my own Catholic high school, which is in a smaller town and drew from every available social class in my day, the fans are enthusiastic but not necessarily out of bounds. As for the players: I knew many of them in high school, so I have a pretty good idea of their warts and shortcomings, the ones I associate with jockdom universally: bullying, racism, etc. Maybe the racism was more pronounced in my day (1970s) than today - that's a happy thought. But I'd have to say that they haven't come across as particularly dirty on the field. I think that tone is set by the particular coach, more so than being an aspect of the wider Catholic culture.

      Delete
    2. Oh, and homophobic - that's another jock wart, or was in my day. I considered it as sort of a subset of overall bullying. Maybe that's also reduced nowadays - I hope so.

      Delete
    3. Jim, with the exception of one Catholic high school in DC - more inner city - the Catholic schools in the league had mostly middle to upper middle class families. All the teams were racially mixed. The inner city school team and fans were pretty well behaved, actually. Perhaps since that team was all black, they tried extra hard to be polite. I don't know. It was not a "social class" thing in the Catholic schools. There was something in the culture. I did not see much racism - just poor sportsmanship by a lot of players and their fans.

      I was happy when our sons were out of high school - because that meant no more high school sports, and we were done with the nastiness that too often went along with it. Our older sons were in high school in the 90s, in the DC metro area, and racism was not really evident in their schools or in the games. The frequent nastiness during the basketball games (not so much at soccer games) came from something else. I didnt' go to football games, although the kids did, and my husband often did. I don't know how the players and fans behaved at those games. Maybe it's basketball that brings out the worst in Catholic schools?

      Delete
    4. Jim, you mentioned once that you stayed Catholic in spite of - not because of - your years in Catholic school. We did not like the culture at our two older sons' Catholic high school. I have mentioned this before - but the Episcopal high school our youngest attended offered a much more christian culture than did the Catholic diocesan high school the older boys attended.

      Delete
    5. Anne, right. I don't want to give folks the impression that high school was traumatic for me. Those were actually four pretty good years of my youth. I had a lot of friends, some of whom are still close friends today, I got active in music and theater, and I led a pretty peaceful existence. I got a good education in the the basics (English, math, history).

      What I think I've mentioned that I struggled with from a faith standpoint was mostly the retrograde disciplinary approach of the school administration. They had a "pray and obey" approach to discipleship (admittedly, they didn't ask us to pay - the bills went to our parents), and the "pray" part wasn't actually very well-thought-out or even particularly emphasized. If it weren't for a Teens Encounter Christ (TEC) retreat that I and quite a few of my peers went on my senior year, which was unaffiliated with the school, there is a pretty good chance I would have emerged from high school unchurched. I don't know if Loyola would have appealed to me.

      Now, middle school: *that* was traumatic! I think that's the case for quite a few people, though, at least from my particular era. My own kids got through middle school a lot better than I did. But they went to a good (public) school, whereas I went to a crummy (public) school.

      Delete
    6. Anne, Catholic school? Basketball? Brings out the worst? Guilty. I played trumpet in the spirit band at the St. Joe's games at the Palestra in the late 60's. We had our own version of the Lasalle fight song when we played Lasalle. I'd blast out the intro followed by the Saint Joe's contingent heartily singing out "Go to hell! Go to hell! Go to H-E-double-L, Lasaaaaale eats s**t." I can't remember the proper lyrics.

      Delete
    7. Oh, well. Kids that age.
      We were sitting in the bleachers at a basketball game, and the kid in front of us was wearing a knitted navy watch cap, which folds up all the way around the crown. One of my buddies was eating peanuts, and stuffing the shells into the cap. When the game was over, Brother William, who had been watching, came over and told the kid to empty out his cap. Then he told my buddy to pick up the pieces. My buddy asked where a dust pan might be, and Brother William said, "No dust pan. But you have two fellow malefactors here to help you. I want to see a clean floor when you are done."

      Or then there was the time my youngest's (grade school) team played another Catholic school. Our school was all-white, for sports purposes (there were Hispanics), and the school we were playing was all African-American. BUT both teams had red uniforms. OK, the referee said, "we have to do shirts and skins. I'll flip a coin. Visitors call it."

      Delete
  3. By the way, where has Jack R disappeared to? Hope he's well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Same here. I've been worried about Crystal for some time, too.

      I wish we had a bigger commenting and contributing community. If my posts are driving people away, I hope someone will say something about it. I don't want to alienate anyone.

      Delete
    2. I contacted Crystal privately a couple of months ago. She felt that her liberal pro-choice opinions re abortion had made her persona non grata here and decided to bow out. I do remember a couple of rather harsh comments directed to her, but not by you. I don't have Jack's email, so haven't contacted him.

      Her life experiences were quite different from those of many of us, and her perspectives were educational to me. I miss reading her comments.

      Delete
    3. Patrick Shannon, aka unigidon, is another one that we haven't heard from in a long time. I hope he is okay.

      Delete
    4. Crystal shows up at "America" usually when it's an abortion topic. Yes, I think about Patrick. And now Jack, as well.

      Delete
    5. We haven't actually been talking about abortion much lately.

      Delete
  4. Katherine, yes, golf tournaments are excellent nap-inducers. As every father in America knows, the US Open is scheduled for the Father's Day weekend every year (or maybe the holiday is scheduled to coincide with the golf tournament). It's practically a requirement to fall asleep in front of it on that particular Sunday afternoon.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Sports, good. Sports culture, weird, toxic and collectively stupid.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Jean, as is often the case, you have summed it up nicely.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Rejoice and Be Glad is not a bad read at all. It advocates a sense of humor. As Francis does in the Wim Wenders' documentary no one has mentioned here. When the movie ends, he goes out on a gag line. It's not a bad documentary; it sort of follows the plot of Laudato Si' without being preachy.

    I'd say there is a need for a Vatican document on Christian driving. One of the big topics of our men's group is being a Christian while driving one-handed to keep the fingers of the other hand free for flashing.

    ReplyDelete
  8. A good read, albeit NOT an "official" church document:

    Merchants in The Temple, by Gianluigi Nuzzi. (2015) Subtitled "Inside Pope Francis' Secret Battle Against Corruption in the Vatican/"

    ReplyDelete