We haven't talked much about synodality here recently. It didn't die with Francis; Pope Leo has expressed his strong support for it. The Holy See is planning a worldwide synodal assembly for 2028. According to the timetable, last year and this year are to be diocesan-level synodal listening sessions and assemblies. Then, as before, the "output" from the diocesan levels will roll up to broader consultations, culminating in the worldwide session in a couple of years.
My parish is one of the sites for a listening session in our vicariate (a vicariate is an administrative district within an archdiocese; it is headed by an auxiliary bishop). It takes place next month. I registered for it. I am looking forward to it.
As I related here a few years ago, I attended a listening session once before, in the pre-Francis / pre-synodality days. I am sure bishops and other high officials fear them, because by the sessions' nature they are risky: nobody knows ahead of time what will be said nor what the experience will be. Some corporate leaders have learned to embrace the risk, because they think it is good for them and theor organizations to know what people think.
I hope bishops, priests and deacons (and lay leaders in the church) can learn to adopt the same attitude and grow comfortable with the risk - and even to adopt synodality as a way of life. Synodality should encompass more than occasional listening sessions; it should be a spirituality that infuses parish pastoral ministry.
Jim, I'll be interested in your takes on the listening session. A lot of people, including me, are not quite sure what synodality is supposed to do. Pretty sure a listening session isn't supposed to devolve into a gripe session, or people just "blue skying" it. There have been a couple of them in our archdiocese, but we weren't involved. It wasn't a matter of simply signing up for it ( not sure how one got invited?)
ReplyDeleteIn our case, there is a page on the archdiocesan website with a link to register, and I received an email from the archdiocese about it (as a member of staff, as opposed to a person in the pews). I hope we will announce it in our parish bulletin and on our parish website - I'll try to find out.
DeleteI cannot think of anything we discussed at a work-related SOFT retreats in the private sector that made one iota of difference to my work or to the larger organization's modus operandi.
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed the meetings because they were held in a nice location with an extra good lunch. And we all said a lot of quasi-constructive blah blah that the CEO reading the meeting report would not get pissed off about.
I see synodality as a similar effort--a way of making participants feel pleased with themselves/more holy. But unlikely to have any effect.
Maybe Jim could tell us how synodality has changed or improved his approach to the diaconate or ministering to his parishioners.
"Maybe Jim could tell us how synodality has changed or improved his approach to the diaconate or ministering to his parishioners."
DeleteYeah, good question. I guess the simple answer is, I can't point to anything concrete. Maybe that's not too surprising. It's still early days in synodality, and my formal involvement up to now has been nonexistent.
I think Francis would have said that the process is at least as important as any formal results that come of the local sessions and the worldwide sessions.
I think of synodality's purpose as an antidote or alternative to clericalism, which Francis loathed. I don't think I'm part of the problem, although I could have blinders on. I do think I should do more listening than talking at next month's session.
What is the point of a process without results?
Delete“Synodality” as practiced by organizations can be much more than listening. Let me describe my experience in the public mental health system in Ohio.
ReplyDeleteMoney in the Ohio public mental health system (Federal State, and local levy taxes) are administered by county Boards of 14 members, half of which are appointed by officials in the Ohio Departmental of Behavioral Health, and half appointed by county commissioners. The commissioners are elected by the public. Applications to be a board member are public, and submissions to either the state or county are encouraged. Some of the state appointments are targeted, e.g. at least one member must be a consumer, one a family member and one a behavioral health professional.
The Executive Director of the Board in Toledo once said that he would never try to encourage and discourage people for the Board. He found that about a third of board members became members to support the agencies. Another third became members to encourage board staff to improve the agencies. The final third became members to protect the public from both agencies and board staff. He felt that was a good mix.
The services are provided by contract agencies. The board provides planning, monitoring and evaluation services for the system. While the board cannot hire and fire people in contract agencies, it can exert a lot of influence by reducing the money available to the agency.
The monthly board meeting as well as committee meetings function under the sunshine law which has only limited exceptions to discuss personnel issues or receive legal advice. There is a section at the beginning of the meeting in which guests (agency, consumers, family members, public) introduce themselves and are allowed to comment on agenda items. This gives them an opportunity to frame the discussion without inhibiting the board discussion. There are even more opportunities in the committee meetings to actually participate and shape the discussion.
During my tenure as planner, we wrote long range plans for the severely mentally disabled, children, substance abuse, and the elderly. These gathered people from agencies, consumers, family members and systems, court, police, welfare, education, health, etc. to craft what services, and outcomes where needed. In the case of children, we passed an additional tax levy by sixty percent of the voters when we usually just get in the low 50’s for renewal levies (they have to renewed every ten years). If you want to get money from all the stakeholders let them shape how it is going to be spent.
As you can image with myself as Director of Planning, Research and Evaluation I used a lot of data to move things forward. I always began processing data at the lowest level, clinicians, program directors, consumers and family members before bringing it to the Board and its committees. I liked to make the data as simple and clear as possible without making any recommendations. When someone stated what they thought were the obvious implications, I would simply begin the discussion by asking what others thought. If one begins with implications, people forget the data. My object was always to put the facts that every could agree upon at the center of the process rather than my ideas or anyone else's ideas about them. That way I became the servant of all rather than just a representative of the Board.
Listening is key to the Board's function and well expressed by its motto “YOU.ME.US There is no them.” To me that is what synodality wishes to accomplish. However, it takes a whole structure of processes to foster the listening and make it effective.
Possibly the key is "sunshine law." Your board was accountable to the public. Synodal efforts are accountable to ???
DeleteI don't want to be a pest, but one reason I've given up on organized religion is because they're run by hierarchies that aren't accountable outside of a select few, and, in the case of the RCC, operate in secrecy a large part of the time.
Yes, very little transparency. I was on pastoral council for four years. The pastor never consulted us on what he was going to do. He did often tell us before the parish once pastoral staff had made a decision. perhaps to test out our reactions.
DeleteWhile we regularly were greeters once a month at Masses, where people could bring up anything they were concerned about, we usually did nothing about their concerns. While in theory anyone could come to a pastoral council meeting in practice no one ever came. Our main function was to show up at parish events and make people feel good about coming to them and in general to contribute to the idea that we are a very good parish that does a lot of good things. Which is a partial truth.
Your mental health board seemed to sort itself out into what you call a "good mix." I think synodality runs the risk of being invitation-only, limited to people whom the priests and bishops want to listen to. That is certainly how the first round of listening sessions went hereabouts.
DeleteAlso, Catholics have deacons who are supposed to bring the needs of the faithful and larger community to the priest and parish. Aren't they the natural"listeners" in any synodal effort?
My sense is that this role has been stunted as the priesthood dwindles. Deacons now are handling baptisms, funerals, weddings, giving sermons, and assisting with admin duties--all stuff the priests normally handled when there were two or three of them per parish.
No shade on deacons. The local deacon here is a wonderful and dedicated man. But he's older than me, run ragged over 2 parishes, and he isn't going to be around forever.
"The pastor never consulted us on what he was going to do. He did often tell us before the parish once pastoral staff had made a decision. perhaps to test out our reactions."
DeleteIn our parish, we have commissions and councils as formal structures to connect parishioners with staff and bring them into the oversight and leadership process. Fwiw, I am on Worship Commission. We also have a pastoral council, but I have never served on it. Maybe after retirement.
I am also theoretically a member of parish staff, but almost never attend their meetings, for the simple reason that they meet during the workday. Our other deacon is retired, and he attends. Reading the minutes, it's not clear that he speaks up, but I don't think speaking up is his style. (I am a speaker-upper.)
Whether these formal structures are effective or not, very much depends on the commitment and attitude of the pastor. Pastors could, and some do, ignore the commissions and councils, and even the staff. We had one of those once. Everyone was miserable. The parishioners on these parish groups are there because they want to help and make a difference. For a pastor to ignore them is malpractice of the worst kind.
I suspect, Jack, that you were a rare leader - very much a servant leader. Probably there are other boards in other counties whose leaders aren't that way, and consequently are less effective.
"Catholics have deacons who are supposed to bring the needs of the faithful and larger community to the priest and parish. Aren't they the natural"listeners" in any synodal effort?"
DeleteYes, we should be. Some of us are better than others at this.
The thing about deacons is, we have one foot in the community, and one in the clergy/hierarchy. In my case, I lean more toward community. I have to sort of work at the clergy aspect. Other guys are the other way around. To be candid, I find them off-putting.
You may know that bringing the community's needs to the church is the reason deacons read the prayers of the Faithful. Even though we don't write them, and are as apt to mispronounce parishioners' names as anyone else.
It's a fine line to walk, I'm sure. One person cannot be all things to all people.
Delete"Synodality should encompass more than occasional listening sessions; it should be a spirituality that infuses parish pastoral ministry."
ReplyDeleteWhat is "a spirituality"? How is synodality "a spirituality"? A way of being "spiritual," i.e., tending to the souls of the flock?
This all sounds like insider jargon to me.
Does it manifest in treating people with kindness and hearing them out, being open to dialogue, offering insights, praying for them?
ISTM that a priest or deacon can listen nicely all they want to, but at some point they have to lay down the law about the essentials of faith and sometimes advise folks that they should not present themselves for Communion or otherwise hold their feet to the fire.