This is from an article on the New Republic site, by the same name. New Republic has never been one of my favorite opinion journal places, but I don't think anything they said in this article is untrue. Seem like they pretty well nailed it:
The Donroe Doctrine Is a Scam | The New Republic
"It’s been quite a busy few days for U.S. foreign policy. First was President Donald Trump’s brazenly illegal abduction of Venezuela’s head of state. Then Secretary of State Marco Rubio threatened to make good on his longtime dream of retaking Cuba, warning that the Cuban government is “in a lot of trouble.” And on Tuesday, Trump’s senior adviser on fascism (or whatever his title is), Stephen Miller, declared that Greenland belongs to the United States and that Trump could take the territory if he wanted. This “Donroe Doctrine,” as they’ve termed it, is based on a single principle: that, as Miller ranted Tuesday, the United States will henceforth “conduct ourselves as a superpower” by using our military “to secure our interests unapologetically in our hemisphere.”
"Here’s the rub: When the Trump administration says “our interests,” they’re not talking about your or my interests, and they’re not talking about the nation’s interests. They’re talking about the interests of corporate elites. The Donroe Doctrine is a racket—nothing more and nothing less—designed to make the U.S. taxpayer underwrite resource imperialism for Trump’s billionaire buddies."
"They don’t appear to be trying very hard to hide this reality. Trump has been pretty explicit that the Venezuelan takeover is not about freedom for Venezuelans. Asked whether he would demand the acting Venezuelan president offer amnesty to opposition figures or release political prisoners, Trump responded, “We haven’t gotten to that. Right now, what we want to do is fix up the oil.” The Venezuelan takeover is not about democracy. Asked about plans for “free and fair elections,” he responded, “Well, it depends.… We’re going to have to have big investments by the oil companies.” According to Trump, kidnapping Maduro wasn’t even about regime change. The new acting president of Venezuela, Delcy Rodríguez, was vice president under Maduro, so the regime running Venezuela today is identical minus one person. When Trump was asked, “What do you need from Delcy Rodríguez?” his singular response was: “Total access. We need access to the oil.” So this gunboat diplomacy is about oil. But it’s not oil for American consumers....So who does stand to gain? The same people as usual: Trump’s billionaire buddies....That includes corporations like ExxonMobil, which has used the controversial investor-state dispute settlement system to claim $15 billion from the Venezuelan government, and ConocoPhillips, which has sought $30 billion via the investor-state dispute settlement system—claims Trump will likely use as a starting point for forced repayments to Big Oil. Both companies’ stocks, as well as Chevron’s, jumped following the Venezuela news on Monday."
"It also includes billionaires like Trump megadonor Paul Singer, whose hedge fund Elliott Management last November acquired Citgo, the U.S.-based subsidiary of PVDSA, Venezuela’s state-run oil company. Citgo’s oil refineries stand to make huge profits from Venezuela’s heavy crude oil reserves, according to the executive director of refining and oil products at the Oil Price Information Service, or OPIS, who called this access “a game changer for U.S. Gulf Coast and West Coast refiners in terms of profitability.” Indeed, Trump has already launched that gravy train: On Tuesday, he announced that Venezuela would be “turning over” 30 to 50 million barrels of oil—he appeared to be referring to stock built up during the U.S. blockade—to be sold at “market price in the U.S. And on Wednesday, Energy Secretary Chris Wright announced that the U.S. would control Venezuela’s oil “indefinitely.” So refineries like those owned by Singer are about to be handed a massive windfall, while Trump—who took to social media to write that “that money will be controlled by me, the President of the United States of America”—gets a new slush fund....In short, the Venezuela takeover is, like most major endeavors across Trump’s business and political career, a scam."
"...We should expect the same approach to any future illegal land grabs by this administration. Should the Trump team proceed with its unhinged plan to annex Greenland next, the minerals and oil and gas reserves buried there will not be safeguarded for our collective national welfare; they’ll go to Trump’s billionaire friends, to be exploited in the most profitable ways available to them."
"....But Democrats need to actually say this. They need to explain why this rewarmed fascist nonsense is a terrible deal for the American taxpayers who’ll be subsidizing those billionaire profits."
All the nonsense we've heard about liberating the Venezuelan people from a brutal dictator is, exactly that, nonsense. Everyone knows Maduro was a brutal dictator. But concern for the Venezuela people had nothing to do with why this operation was carried out. It was all about greed.
As a rule of thumb, I assume everything to come from my government to be a lie or confabulation. They’ve gone complete Nazi “over there” with the attacks and kidnappings and “over here” with mothers being shot in the streets by ICE Gestapo. One thing is for sure, voting is not going to save us especially because action is needed now. America Media had an article on how we need Just War theory. Typical. We need demonstrations, civil disobedience, general strikes. Also, gun control is nowhere near my top priority now. I wish the Democrats would shut up about it. This is not the time.
ReplyDeleteI think gun control is a moot point right now due to the number of guns out there. But I am worried that someone who opposes the fascists will take matters into their own hands, and all hell will break loose. It would be like someone lighting a match in a room filled with spilled gasoline. We need to channel Martin Luther King.
DeleteTrump knows the MAGAs can't win in the midterms and is begging for an excuse to enact martial law.
DeleteThe pathetic excuses given during the fall for bombing small fishing boats were an obvious cover ( and an unconvincing one) for the true agenda - seize Venezuelas oil fields. The bandaid excuse for grabbing Greenland is just as full of holes - the point is gaining control of the rare minerals there. All of this is to help the billionaires, including his own family.
DeleteToday’s Post outlines the Heritage Foundation plan to increase marriages and births ( of white folk at least). It’s a combination of Germany’s Lebensborn and The Handmaids Tale.
What desperate measures will trump take to stop the mid- terms? Whip up a handily timed civil war and declare martial law as Katherine suggests?
I can’t read the news anymore.
About Greenland, Trump has always bragged about his ability to transact deals (in reality his deals were mostly cheating others). But he could actually make a deal for the US to buy minerals from Greenland, benefitting both countries. But nah. He'd rather just take them over and rip them off.
DeleteAnne, about the Heritage Foundation,and Stephen Miller, etc. I think that one thing we have to address once we get out of this awful period (and we will get out, just not soon enough) is the outsized influence exercised by unelected presidential staff and "think tanks". They have power similar to cabinet heads, but weren't subject to any kind of approval by Congress or anyone else. I'm thinking particularly of Stephen Miller and his wife Katie, and Russell Vought, and the extent that Project 2025 has become national policy (after Trump swearing that he " never heard of it").
DeleteA couple of Nebraskans had words to say. Our dumber than a box of rocks governor said that invading Venezuela "protected Nebraska". (?)
ReplyDeleteCongressman Bacon pushed back against Stephen Miller's suggestion of taking Greenland by force, saying, " This is really dumb. Greenland and Denmark are our allies. There is no upside to demeaning our friends."
Invading Venezuela is going to fix it all up so these foreigners can be sent home and stop taking jobs away from nice white people. Not sure what the goal is for Cuba (sugar? detainee prisons? Trump casinos and resorts?), but that seems to be the next stop. And Greenland. Good luck getting all those rare earth materials out from under the glaciers, but maybe that problem is solved when global warnings melts them all away.
Delete"global warming"
DeleteI would not be surprised if the Tech Billionaires, especially Thiel and Musk, had some input on this. Greenland will melt and become more livable. The minerals will be exposed. US capitalists can then extract the minerals for fabrication of our fabulous future. Well, not ours, theirs. I guess they never heard of all the plans of mice and men or think it doesn't apply to transhumans.
DeleteBest news I've heard recently is that Trump takes 4x the recommended dose of daily aspirin, something both my cardiologist and oncologist have warned me about.
ReplyDeleteBetween the blood thinners, age, poor circulation, bad diet, and job stress,Trump seems to be leaning hard on the self-destruct button. I don't think a President Vance would be better, but the demise of Trump would perhaps break up the MAGA cult enough to restore some sanity.
I'm not praying for anyone to be "unalive", but there are some obitiuaries I wouldn't shed any tears over! I don't think Vance would be better than Trump, but he doesn't have the cult following. He is not a likeable person (of course neither is Trump, but he had that reality show so-called magic). I don't think he could win an election. I do think Trump has not faced his own mortality, and there are plenty of people around him willing to play "weekend at Bernie's" with a senior in early, or not so early, dementia. MAGA can't last forever.
DeleteI look forward to Trump’s death and will celebrate. It remains to be seen if the magic hold he has on a large portion of the population can be transferred. I don’t think it matters. The Nazis will cancel the next election and these zombies will just lumber along with it. And the Democrats will say “tsk, tsk, tsk”. If change comes, it will be like the change that came to Nazi Germany, totally imposed externally.
DeleteOh, yah, sure we can all pray for a miracle that Trump comes to Jesus. But until such time as that happy epiphany occurs, he must be removed from office and and his cabinet dismantled. ICE has now shot 3 people in 24 hours, never mind the unknown American citizens and legal immigrants rotting in makeshift prisons. The utter lies pouring out of the administration about how the victims were all domestic terrorists is more than any decent American should tolerate.
Delete"... he must be removed from office and and his cabinet dismantled." 100% agree. His cabinet (both the ones approved by Congress, and the ones that just somehow showed up like a bunch of jackals)are the worst.
DeleteThat the kids whose mom was shot dead in Minneapolis have to watch Kristi Noem in her fat MAGA lips and stupid hats vilify her as a terrorist is more than I can stand.
DeleteWho will remove him from office? Not his cabinet. Not the GOP Congress.
DeleteGoing to a candlelight vigil at 1700 for Renee at Stroudsburg Court Square, for what it’s worth. Candles never stopped Hitler. The Germans never stopped Hitler. Lots of Russians did it with some help from the US and Britain.
DeleteSomebody on another discussion group quoted Dan Rather: "Americans will put up with anything provided it doesn't hold up traffic."
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteStanley, good for you for going to the candlelight vigil. I'll light a candle for her myself at church.
DeleteI saw on a video clip that some people had set up one of those roadside memorial things near where she was shot. There were some candles there. The video showed an ICE agent go over and stomp on the candles. Disgusting. But maybe goes to show that ICE thinks the candles actually do mean something. They can't stomp out all the candles.
It was raining. The inaudible lady speakers needed lessons from the supermarket announcement women. About a hundred-fifty people showed. I think it will take more than non-violent demonstrations. Non-violent civil disobedience and general strikes would do it. But it was good to mourn one fallen in the good cause.
DeleteRobin Kelly, D-Illinois, has filed articles of impeachment against Noem. Would not hurt my feelings if anybody here wrote their congressional reps asking them to support. More here: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/jan/11/kristi-noem-homeland-security-trump
DeleteThanks, Jean.The article makes a good case for doing this even if it’s unlikely to actually happen. Will write to the reps.
DeleteNoem needs to be impeached. It's a toss-up who is the worst member of the administration. It would be between Noem, Hegseth, and RFK Jr.
DeleteI forgot JD Vance, he is among the worst of the worst. Oh hell, they all are.
DeleteJD and Miller are both evil along with Noem. I don’t think RFKJr is evil, just incredibly dumb. Too many drugs in his history destroyed his mind? . Not sure if Hegseth is evil or simply an amoral mindless puppet who unfortunately has the power to kill millions.
DeleteI don't feel the need to try to sort out the evil from the craven from the senile from the criminal from the stupid from the drugged out, tho they all sure seem to be represented whenever there is a cabinet meeting. The bottom line is that Trump policies are bad for our country and exceed constitutional limits, and they need to go for that reason.
DeletePeople keep saying that it doesn’t matter why they need to go, they need to go. But nobody that I am aware of yet has offered a realistic proposal about how to get rid of any of them - evil, stupid, clueless or whatever. Just saying they need to go accomplishes nothing. I just read that of decisions on trump cases by his own judge appointees, more than 100 were judged in his favor and only 12 against him. He owns all three branches of government and nobody has yet come up with a realistic idea as to how to change this. Crying in the wind helplessly while wringing our hands does nothing. I don’t even know if there are ideas out there to fight his attempts to not hold elections this year. He knows MAGA would lose in many places so he will make sure there aren’t any elections. I’m guessing he will foment civil unrest and then declare martial law and suspend elections.
DeleteI don’t have an answer either. America is toast, to quote my sons.
Hand-wringing and crying are not what I'm advocating. I'm advocating telling yr congressman to support Kelly's articles of impeachment.
DeleteI already agreed with that although I’m quite sure it won’t make even the slightest difference. I would like to see some kind of leadership from either Democrats or Republicans in Co greed to take back their authority, become responsible legislators, and begin to undo trumps actions. They could begin hearings on all of trumps many illegal actions carried out by DOGEand then go through all of them systematically since then. They have the constitutional right. But only a couple have shown even a spark of life - mainly Massie. An impeachment move is simply to signal unhappiness. An impeachment move that actually would bring that woman to trial is unlikely, but we can all write our reps and receive a form letter in response. And then nothing will happen. I hope I’m wrong. Even more important would be meaningful action in Congress to thwart trumps attempts to figure out a way to call off the elections this year. Right now a number of GOP reps are running scared - caught between constituent unhappiness with the cuts in healthcare and other support and trump’s threats to primary them. The country needs more of them to shake off their primary fears and go up against trump. But…. I see no big movement towards that. Just isolated republicans here and there. I don’t see a backlash against ICE coming from MAGA land either so Noem is safe.
DeleteI am as dismayed as everyone else by what the mad evil king is doing. But I feel that we are seeing cracks that are starting slow and building. I see the murder of Renee Good as an event similar to Kent State in 1970. It didn't end the Vietnam War but it contributed to its end. Yes it matters that Ms. Good was a white woman. Of course it should have mattered when it happened to a person of color. But we're talking about MAGA. Shooting an unarmed white woman will bite ICE in the @ss.
DeleteI don't know if any of you listened to Jerome Powell's statement (today, I think?). The day Trump's meddling with interest rates threatens the US dollar's place as reliable currency is the day that MAGA is over.
This is the link to Jerome Powell's speech. It is less than 3 minutes:
Deletev=KckGHaBLSn4&t=41s&pp=2AEpkAIB
I don't know that I see cracks in hardcore MAGAs here, but there are some Repubs who feel that Trump has got out of hand. Mike Rogers, a formerly moderate Michigan congressman now hoping to flip a current Democratic Senate seat on MAGA talking points, is my bellwether. He is raking in millions for his November bid, while Democrats are underfunded and disorganized.
DeleteAnne and family have the money to emigrate, and I don't think that's an irrational response. But those of us without the means to leave will have to fight harder to make up for their loss.
Thanks for the Powell link.
DeleteSorry, that link doesn't appear to work, try this one:
DeleteJerome Powell's speech today
Eldest son plans to emigrate in June. Youngest son plans to move back to Europe in June 2028. I fear my husband and I are sort of stuck. We could move, but the health considerations are a big obstacle. He’s an 85 year old paraplegic and he really fears leaving all the doctors here who speak English, even though Spains healthcare system is ranked way higher than the US. On average. But We are spoiled by proximity to top hospitals like Johns Hopkins here, and UCLA and Stanford when we were in California. The rehab facility here that he goes to twice/ week is probably the best in the world. If it were just me, I would be gone in June also. My husband and I are in the low risk pool for violence from government goons. Our mixed race African American grandchildren, especially our almost 12 year old grandson, are in the high risk pool. Unfortunately I think we’re stuck here with the rest of you. It breaks my heart that they feel they have to leave to protect their children.
DeleteThey aren’t alone. More than 40% of moms say they would like to emigrate if they could.
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/01/10/opinion/leaving-america-gun-violence.html?unlocked_article_code=1.DlA.g8dy.d0FbtDR6Uzpn&smid=nytcore-ios-share
Katherine, still no link.
DeleteThe Guardian says Trump is denying having ordered the DoJ to investigate Powell. Whenever things heat up, he denies he had anything to do with it. The man has never had the spine to admit his own blunders or to accept the consequences of his actions. What a PoS coward.
DeleteJean, try this one:
Deletehttps://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speech/powell20260111a.htm
Glad he is not mincing any words! I think the hallmark of Trumpism is to make decisions based on prejudices and whim vs evidence and expertise.
DeleteAround 15 years ago, I attended Mass in a North New Jersey Church. The priest was an imported Venezuelan priest. all I remember now about his homily was his complaints about how Venezuela had become under Chavez. He even complained about Venezuela's standing in the Miss Universe contest which I guess was Chavez' fault, as well. I got from all this that he was from the bourgeousie class and not to happy with Chavez' socialistic changes. At that time, I thought it would be nice to hear the opinion a poor Venezuelan. It must be remembered that the United States wages financial warfare against any socialist regime. Also that Venezuela was not trading oil in petrodollars. A cardinal sin. I understand that Venezuela wanted to join BRICS but was blocked by President Lula of Brazil, leaving that country more exposed to American interference.
ReplyDeleteI actually haven't heard too much good about Chavez. He might have improved life for ordinary people for awhile, but then managed to tank the economy (with some outside help, I'm sure.). I would like to see the US actually practice America first , that is, not meddling in other countries' affairs.We used to do it in a good way sometimes, with things like USAID, but we fed that into the wood chipper. So now we'd better just concentrate on not feeding ourselves into the wood chipper.
DeleteI presume Chavez, like most socialist/communist regimes was anti-Church.
DeleteWhatever Chavez was, he wasn’t a US puppet and that’s where we had a problem. Chavez probably criticized the Church but I don’t know of any persecution. Meanwhile, Netanyahu is pursuing a genocide that has cost hundreds of thousands of lives and we’re fine with him. Compared to Netanyahu, Chavez was a boy scout who smokes.
DeleteIf you need a little encouragement, listen to Heather Cox Richardson's latest substack episode:
ReplyDeletehttps://substack.com/home/post/p-183971950
She feels that we have reached a "Kent State" moment, and backs up that thought with some late developments.
For anybody who thinks it will do some good to write Congress: NATO Rotection Act and Greenland Sovereignty Act have been introduced to try to curb takeover of Greenland. Otherwise, now that Trump has turned life on the homefront into a complete effing paradise, he's gonna march into Greenland like Hitler into Poland.
ReplyDeleteNATO Protection Act
DeleteThanks Jean. I hadn't heard about that yet. Glad to read that it is bipartisan. It certainly needs to pass.
DeleteThe MSM is not very good at covering these Congressional initiatives. I had to kinda dig to find them. Many of our elected GOP reps (like my Congressman) need our support in order to grow a spine strong enough to stand against MAGA.
DeleteKatherine, I don’t know if you can access this article in The Atlantic. Unfortunately I think this writer is correct that MAGA isn’t showing real cracks.
Deletehttps://www.theatlantic.com/politics/2026/01/maga-trump-base-schism-exaggerated/685598/?utm_campaign=deep-shtetl&utm_content=20260113&utm_source=newsletter&utm_medium=email&lctg=6050eaab4953a53f14906b93&utm_term=Deep%20Shtetl
I am a subscriber to Atlantic online, I will have to read that article. I know hardcore MAGA won't give up. I do feel that some of the ones who are self -gaslighting can be peeled off.
DeleteI don't expect much change from the MAGA cohort. Their brains are in a do loop or something. Educated people run on wishful thinking and prejudice, too. Not all MAGAs are working class and/or uneducated although they're portrayed that way. Nobody likes to admit they were stupidly wrong and maybe that's a factor. I am wary of lionizing anyone so how people can become so emotionally invested in a gargoyle like Trump is one of the scariest things in my life.
DeleteStanley, all the pro- trump people I know - all family and friends - are well educated, many with advanced degrees, and they are affluent. Most were not from working class backgrounds and they were NOT the first in their families to graduate from college, including me and my siblings - our parents both had college degrees in the early 1930s. And they not only claim to be Christians, but flaunt their devout Christianity/Catholicism on their sleeves.
DeleteIn the last few years I learned that the crucifix wearing Catholics basically seized on the abortion issue to cover up their racism - politely hidden for most of their lives. After all, affluent, educated white Catholics couldn’t openly admit to their racism. It simply “wasn’t done”. I really didn’t realize how racist a couple of my sibs were until trump came along. Then the bishops basically made abortion THE only issue that Catholics could vote on, providing the cover they needed.
Anne, I have some MAGA people in my family too. But different than your relatives, in that these are people who never went to college, and have never lived anywhere but the place where they were born. The ones who got a higher education and work in professional jobs aren't MAGA.
DeleteI believe that people do change over time based on the people they associate with. People who were a little racist or bigotted end up being a lot that way if the news they consume is Fox, etc., and their friends are comfortable saying things that were formerly not said in polite society. There is a saying "Tell me who your friends are and I'll tell you who you are."
It told my anecdotes about my friends and family simply to respond to Stanley, who pointed out the misperception that MAGAs are generally working class with less education than others when, in reality, plenty of highly educated, affluent people are also MAGA - and this has nothing to do with the closing of factories in their towns (and suburbs). I have come to believe that a lot of people didn’t vote trump because they live in a rust belt town that has lots of unemployed, but because he said out loud things they thought but had always hidden. White Catholics especially had the added advantage of being able to use the abortion issue as cover for their true motives in supporting trump. It seems they really didn’t like poor , brown people who speak Spanish even if they are Catholics. So much for “ welcome the stranger”.
DeleteUnfortunately Catholics pushing the "single issue" thing with abortion bear a lot of responsibility for how we got to the present situation. I don't know how that is pro life in any meaningful sense of the word.
DeleteWe haven't heard from Jim for awhile. I hope he and his family are okay, and he and Therese are just on vacation somewhere where it isn't cold.
ReplyDeleteI had noticed Jim’s absence too. Prayers that he and his family are all ok.
DeleteHe mentioned he was worried about job security. Maybe avoiding all our political handwringing in favor of concerns closer to home.
DeleteJim isn’t an avoider I don’t think. I worry it’s a family emergency of some kind in his large extended family. He is one of seven I think. His parents are in their 80s and he has lots of nieces and nephews. Or maybe they decided to go ice fishing in Canada and he doesn’t have a cellphone signal. Let us pray….
Delete