There is an interesting article on the America Media site by Father James Martin on the choice of a papal name, and what it means:
https://www.americamagazine.org/faith/2025/05/05/what-name-new-pope-choose-250590
"The choice of a papal name is said to be the new pope’s first important decision. It is also the second thing we will hear from the balcony of St. Peter’s on the day of the election, after the announcement of the choice of the cardinal-electors. After the words “Habemus papam” (“We have a pope”), we will hear the cardinal’s name followed by the words “qui sibi nomen imposuit” (“who has chosen the name”). The name that follows will be on everyone’s lips for the next few years."
"Here are a few names that may be likely, along with some possible implications. The next pope may choose something brand new, or his choice may be out of devotion to a saint he likes. But, as ever—and as with Jorge Mario Bergoglio, who chose his name to honor St. Francis of Assisi, the apostle of the poor—his answer to the question posed to him at the end of the conclave, “What name do you choose?” will offer an early preview of his papacy."
"Paul VII: A steady hand to guide some of the reforms of Francis and perhaps a calming influence (that is, a Pope Paul VI to Francis’ Pope John XXIII).
Pius XIII: A desire to return to more of a “pre-conciliar” (that is, pre-Vatican II) style.
John XXIV: A continuation of a more reform-minded papacy, with a possible emphasis on the Second Vatican Council, which was convened by “Good Pope John.” Pope Francis himself joked that his successor might be John XXIV.
Francis II: Obvious. Also, for that reason, it will probably not be taken. My prediction is that the next pope may not want to be seen as a carbon copy of his predecessor.
John Paul III: A traditionalist, firm in standing against the excesses of the modern world, activist in the global political sphere.
Benedict XVII: A traditionalist, thoughtful, perhaps more focused on Europe, even on what Benedict called a “smaller, purer church.”
Leo XIV: An emphasis on Catholic social teaching and, perhaps specifically the rights of workers and the poor."
"Other options might include a nod to the founder of a religious order (four cardinal electors are members). For example, Cardinal Timothy Radcliffe might choose “Dominic,” Cardinal Joseph Tobin “Alphonsus,” and Cardinal Robert Prevost “Augustine.” A newly elected pope might choose the name of a local saint (that is, from their part of the world); an ancient “church father” whose writings have been influential in their lives; a pope from the early church whose life they find inspirational; or an apostle or figure from the New Testament they feel close to (or they feel has been overlooked)."
"Finally, the new pope could simply choose to keep his baptismal name. This was the tack taken in the fictional 1960s film “The Shoes of the Fisherman” (the “Conclave” of its day) in which a Ukrainian cardinal named Kiril Lakota is asked, “By what name do you wish to be called?” He says: “We choose to be called by our own name, Kiril. He was the saint that brought the Gospels to our country.”
"In our excitement over the choice of a new pope, we should also pay attention to his first one-word message to us: his name."
"Keep praying for the cardinal electors!"
And a personal note, please keep me in your prayers. I am having surgery for endometrial cancer on May 19. It was caught early, and I am in hopes that no further treatment will be needed. The surgery is supposed to be "minimally invasive", and I should be able to go home the next day. But just the word "cancer" brings up a lot of anxiety. But I am fortunate that if I have to lose a body part, it is one that is no longer useful to me.
Prayers for you, of course. I am so sorry. Hoping for a full recovery.
ReplyDeleteThanks Jean!
DeleteLikewise our prayers for your full recovery.
DeletePraying for your health, Katherine.
DeleteKatherine, I am so sorry to learn that you have to undergo this invasive cancer treatment. Thank God it has been caught early. It’s been 3 1/2 years since my breast cancer surgery and radiation. First milestone for breathing easier. Then the 5 year mark will be a the real “ you can probably stop looking over your shoulder now” mark. You are an active person so mind your doctor and take it easy after your surgery for as long as they say. Don’t decide you are fine and go back to taking care of everyone else! Let them take care of you. Friends who have had this surgery usually had to take it easy for about a month. Prayers ascending🙏
DeleteThanks everyone! The prayers and encouragement help, especially with the anxiety.
DeleteAnne, I plan on taking it easy in recovery. For one thing there will be a 10 pound lifting restriction for six weeks afterwards. Fortunately I have good family support.
I have wondered what I would have done if I didn't have Medicare, or had a plan with a high deductible. Would I have gone in to check out a minor symptom, and would I be having surgery at the best hospital for women's cancer in Omaha? Probably not.
Acute gynecological cancers like yours are relatively well understood and good supports are in place for patients. Take advantage of what's on offer. The hospital nurses usually explain stuff better than docs. A navigator really helps if you need follow-up treatment. Have yr husband involved if you can persuade him to be your info point person. If not, ask if there are pamphlets to hand people. Sounds dumb, but it can get exhausting explaining things over and over to spouse and family. And you might want to tell people now if you want visitors. It really helps some folks to have people popping in. After my mom's open heart surgery, one of my brother's friends visited out of the blue, and it was a huge boost to her spirits. Me, I take my audio books, unplug the phone, and hang the No Visitors sign on the door. Everyone convalesces differently.
DeleteAfter my consultation with the surgeon, he brought my husband and my oldest son (who had accompanied us) into a conference room, and explained everything to them, even drew a diagram on a piece of paper. So I didn't have to explain it all, which I appreciated.
DeleteHe sounds like a really good doctor, and you will be in good hands.
DeleteOf course I'll pray, Katherine. Glad they seem to have caught it early, but I imagine it is frightening just the same.
DeleteI think people will be looking for somethings that may be more important clues than the name.
ReplyDeleteHow does the new pope dress? Does he ask the people to pray for him? Does he decide to live in the apostolic palace?
The new pope will be faced with all these decisions in the first hours of his being pope. Francis will be a tough act to follow.
I agree that Francis will be a tough act to follow!
DeleteThe name a pope picks is not one of the most consequential decisions he makes, except that it does give a clue as to his priorities
One hopes that the electors will pay less attention to things such as nation of origin and politics, and focus on ability to carry out the Church's mission of evangelization.
I started paying attention to the RCC again mostly because of
DeletePope Francis. We haven’t gone to church since Covid. Local EC changed rectors and we’re not crazy about him. Local RC parishes swerved right and became evangelical christian with liturgy, smells , bells, Scott Hahn and Robert Barron, and I’m not comfortable in them. My husband and I have never prayed out loud together. Sometimes we watch the services at the Washington National Cathedral. I prefer the prayers of the liturgy from the Book of Common Prayer to the RC translations.
But I started to reclaim my RC identity because of Francis - his choice of name, and all the things Jack mentioned - no ermine, no silk slippers, a Ford focus, washing the feet of prisoners. and women , no gilded papal apartment, asking the people to pray for him. So I paid attention. The trip to Lampedusa really caught me. A Pope who truly cared for the poor? Poor immigrants? Refugees? Not focused on pelvic issues? Recognizing that God loves all his creation including the marginalized? Those who aren’t Christian? Todos, todos, todos? Focus on orthopraxy not orthodoxy? Jesus didn’t focus on “ right belief” - he focused on “right action”. The outcasts. Todos, todos, todos. Jesus told us not to judge ( I really have a hard time with this when it comes to MAGA from the top down. I judge trump supporters a lot - especially the wearing their Catholicism on their sleeves Catholic relatives) but Francis said “ Who am I to judge”. I try, but it’s really, really hard for me. I will be semi- estranged from my eldest sister and her family for the rest of my life I suspect. He chose the name of the saint most known for loving all God’s creation - the poor, the outcasts, the natural world, the animals, brother sun and sister moon. Finally a Pope I could follow even if he didn’t do everything I personally would have liked to see.
I don’t read the coverage about who might be next. But it may determine to whom I make my dying confession if I have the luxury of time to call a priest. I haven’t gone to confession since I was about 35. I discuss my sins with God. But I might like a human to hold my hand for the final one. My dear, loved Lifelong friend who was my spiritual advisor and confessor for most of my life has Alzheimer’s so I so t be able to turn to her at the end. Even by phone. Long letters, phone calls and e-mails. A friendship like none other in my life although I have been blessed with several really great friends. So I pray with gratitude and don’t worry about who the next pope will be. I would like to see another Francis, but I have other spiritual teachers, including Bishop Marianne at the Cathedral. Running out the door so sorry for typos and autocorrects!
There have been a lot of Pope Innocents. Anyone know what that name signifies?
DeleteI'd be sorry if Pius is retired because it means pre-Vatican II. Even though Pius XII had gone to heaven before the Council (and perhaps would never have thought of having a Council), he did institute some important reforms that laid some groundwork for the 2nd Vatican Council. I certainly don't see him as an implacable enemy of modernity, even though he did, I think, get hauled around in the sedan chair.
Among a lot of other things, Pope Pius XII encouraged Bible study. I just pulled out the student Bible I had in what would now be called middle school. The introduction was the Encyclical Letter of His Holiness, Pius XII, "On the Most Opportune Way to Promote Biblical Studies".
DeleteBible study by lay people hadn't been a "given" prior to that.
Another thing he encouraged was the dialogue Mass, in which the congregation said the Latin responses with the servers. We didn't do that with Sunday Masses, but we did in the daily school Masses. So this could be seen in a way as a prologue to Vatican II.
The document on the liturgy was the first document approved by Vatican II. There were many changes in the Liturgy under Pius XII. Unlike most of the other documents, the initial draft by the Curia was accepted as the basis for discussion even though there were many improvements. It was approved in part because leading Cardinals argued it was the logical conclusion of the work begun by Pius XII.
DeletePius XII was also strongly in favor of the renewal of women religious that began here in the US before Vatican II. It encouraged women to get the advanced degrees that helped them run educational, health and social service agencies.
Not a lot of Bible reading in our Unitarian home growing up, but my mom had an old KJV and a book of Bible stories I liked. The Catholic family we were close to as kids was very excited about getting their Jerusalem Bible and showing it to us. My Catholic boyfriend at the time got me one when I was baptized by the Episcopalians. I liked the footnotes.
Delete