Monday, December 30, 2024

Rest in Peace, Jimmy Carter

Former President Jimmy Carter passed away on December 29, 2024.  He was 100 years old, the only US president who has lived to that age.

There is a good article about his presidency, and its challenges and accomplishments, by Heather Cox Richardson:  December 29, 2024 - by Heather Cox Richardson

From the article (and some personal notes at the end):

"James Earl Carter Jr. was born on October 1, 1924, in Plains, in southwestern Georgia, about half an hour from the site of the infamous Andersonville Prison, where United States soldiers died of disease and hunger during the Civil War only sixty years earlier. He was the first U.S. president to be born in a hospital."

"Carter’s South was impoverished. He grew up on a dirt road about three miles from Plains, in the tiny, majority-Black village of Archery, where his father owned a farm and the family grew corn, cotton, peanuts, and sugar cane. The young Carters and the children of the village’s Black sharecroppers grew up together as the Depression that crashed down in 1929 drained away what little prosperity there was in Archery."

"After undergraduate coursework at Georgia Southwestern College and at the Georgia Institute of Technology, Carter completed his undergraduate degree at the U.S. Naval Academy. In the Navy he rose to the rank of lieutenant, serving on submarines—including early nuclear submarines—in both the Atlantic and Pacific fleets."

"In 1946, Carter married Rosalynn Smith, a friend of his sister’s, who grew up in Plains. When his father died in 1953, Carter resigned his naval commission and took his family back to the Carters’ Georgia farm... Arriving back in Georgia just a year before the U.S. Supreme Court’s Brown v. Board of Education decision declared racial segregation in public schools unconstitutional, Carter quickly became involved in local politics. In 1962 he challenged a fraudulent election for a Georgia state senate seat, and in the runoff, voters elected him. The Carters became supporters of Democratic president John F. Kennedy in a state whose dominant Democratic Party was in turmoil as white supremacists clashed with Georgians eager to leave their past behind. Kennedy had sent troops to desegregate the University of Mississippi."

"Carter ran for governor in 1966, the year after Congress passed the Voting Rights Act. He lost the primary, coming in third behind another liberal Democrat and a staunch segregationist Democrat, Lester Maddox, who won it and went on to win the governorship. When Carter ran again in 1970, he emphasized his populism rather than Black rights, appealing to racist whites. He won the Democratic primary with 60% of the vote and, in a state that was still Democrat-dominated, easily won the governorship."

"Carter brought to office a focus not only on civil rights but also on cleaning up and streamlining the state’s government. He consolidated more than 200 government offices into 20 and backed austerity measures to save money while also supporting new social programs, including equalizing aid to poor and wealthy schools, prison reform and early childhood development programs, and community centers for mentally disabled children."

"At the time, the state constitution prohibited Carter from reelection, so he built recognition in the national Democratic Party and turned his sights on the presidency. In the wake of the scandals that brought down both President Richard Nixon and Vice President Spiro Agnew, as well as many of their staff, when it seemed to many Americans that all of Washington was corrupt, voters welcomed the newcomer Carter as an outsider who would work for the people."

"Elected by just over 50% of American voters over Republican candidate Gerald R. Ford’s count of about 48%, Carter’s outsider status and determination to govern based on the will of the people sparked opposition from within Washington—including in the Democratic Party—and stories that he was buffeted about by the breezes of polls. But Carter's domestic policy advisor Stuart Eizenstat once said that Carter believed an elected president should “park politics at the Oval Office door” and try to win election by doing the right thing. He took pride in ignoring political interests—a stance that would hurt his ability to get things done in Washington, D.C."

"Carter instituted ethics reforms to reclaim the honor of the presidency after Nixon’s behavior had tarnished it. He put independent inspectors in every department and established that corporations could not bribe foreign officials to get contracts. He expanded education programs, establishing the Department of Education, and tried to relieve the country from reliance on foreign oil by establishing the Department of Energy."

"Concerned that the new regulatory agencies that Congress had created since the mid-1960s might be captured by industries and that they were causing prices to rise, Carter began the deregulation movement to increase competition. He began with the airlines and moved to the trucking industry, railroad lines, and long-distance phone service....

But Carter inherited slow economic growth and the inflation that had plagued presidents since Nixon, and the 1979 drop in oil production after the Iranian revolution exacerbated both."

"...Carter also focused on protecting the environment. He was the first president to undertake the federal cleanup of a hazardous waste site, declaring a federal emergency in the New York neighborhood of Love Canal and using federal disaster money to remediate the chemicals that had been stored underground there.

Carter placed 56 million acres of land in Alaska under federal protection as a national monument, saying: “These areas contain resources of unequaled scientific, historic and cultural value, and include some of the most spectacular scenery and wildlife in the world,” he said. "

"...Carter’s foreign policy emphasized human rights. Carter echoed the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights established by the United Nations, promising he would promote “human freedom” while protecting “the individual from the arbitrary power of the state.” He was best known for the Camp David Accords that achieved peace between Israel and Egypt after they had fought a series of wars. Those accords, negotiated with Anwar Sadat of Egypt and Menachem Begin of Israel paved the way for others. Carter credited the religious faith of the three men for making the agreement possible."

"...To Carter also fell the Iran hostage crisis in which Muslim fundamentalists overran the American embassy in the Iranian capital Tehran, seizing 66 Americans and holding them hostage for 444 days, in return for a promise that the American-backed Mohammad Reza Shah Pahlavi, whom Carter had admitted to the U.S. for cancer treatment, be returned to Iran for trial. Carter immediately froze Iranian assets and began secret negotiations, while Americans watched on TV as Iranian mobs chanted “Death to America.” A secret mission to rescue the hostages failed when one of the eight helicopters dispatched to rescue the hostages crashed, killing eight soldiers. Before he left office, Carter successfully negotiated for the hostages’ return; they were released the day of Reagan’s inauguration....Carter left office in January 1981"


I didn't vote for Carter either time, but I always respected him as a person.  The country went through some challenging times while he was president, and maybe he wasn't the right person to lead at that time. But a distance of 44 years is to a certain extent a 30,000 foot view of his presidency. And it is kinder to his time in office than was media coverage at the time, He had a moral compass We're going to miss that in the four years to come. He was ahead of the times with human rights, and protection of the environment. Many people have done much worse. His Christian faith always informed his actions.


A bit of irony which I will enjoy is that the flag will be flown at half mast for 30 days, as it always is with the death of a former president.  Those 30 days will include Trump's inauguration.

32 comments:

  1. I voted for Gus Hall in 1976. I found Carter's tendency to smile when nervous off-putting and his demeanor humorless and holier than thou. He wore his devotion to human rights like a hair shirt, with grim conviction and little joy. Nothing I could relate to at 22. I was busy reading about Emma Goldman and making fun of the Jesus freaks in my dorm.

    I never did warm to Carter as a personality, but as an elderly person now, I admire his faith, his devotion to Christian duty, and his substantial achievements in leading by example.

    One of the interesting things about the Carter administration was the way he dealt with the press--he wasn't combative or fawning. He made himself available, answered questions, didn't play games, and then went back to his job.

    Carter had no history in Washington that the Capitol press corps could leverage for stories. Addicted as they were to political dysfunction and bloated on the drama of Watergate, the press corps resented Carter for being boring. The closest they got to a scandal was when Carter said that he had "sinned in his heart." Then he put on a sweater and told everybody to turn down the thermostat.

    I am happy Carter will be spared a second Trump administration. I wish we all could.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Personally, I liked Carter. He had the right ideas about energy. The solar panels on the WH roof were more symbolic than practical but they showed the way. His big mistake was to expect strength and sacrifice from the American people. His successor knew the real formula was “don’t worry, be happy”. He formulated the Carter Doctrine, considering an “attack” on a friendly mideast oil country an attack on the US, preparing the ongoing mideast cascade of wars. I think, after presidents are elected, they realize they are emperors in charge of a big thing that has to be served at all costs. Good people like Carter are probably surprised and overwhelmed by this, and morally compromised. After he was defeated by Reagan, I think he had a chance to become himself. Perhaps an example of Richard Rohr’s “Falling Upward”, where you find yourself in the second stage of life after a failure. Be with God, James Earl Carter.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "His big mistake was to expect strength and sacrifice from the American people."

      I think that's true to an extent. But I also think he was blind to a lot of domestic problems and resentments--health care, rising cost of higher education, "automation" and its effects on labor, wages not keeping up with the cost of living, inability of small businesses to stay afloat as national chains moved in, etc. It was all there, and personal thrift and sacrifice was not gonna solve those systemic problems.

      Delete
    2. When I say sacrifice, I meant more the need to change lifestyle to conform to physical limitations. Sooner or later, the 1500 kilogram personal conveyance will have to go, internal combustion or electric. And it will go, whether we like it ir not. But even asking Americans to drive 55 mph was impinging on their privilege. But, yes, the neoliberal agenda started under Carter and was then put on anabolic steroids under Reagabushclintobushbamarumpiden. Carter deregulated a lot of things. The process was initiated. Whether he wanted it to go as far as it did, I don’t know. I voted for him twice. This was long before I figured out the Democratic Party was not what I thought it was. I used to have brand loyalty, too.

      Delete
    3. I wasted my vote on John Anderson in 1980. But Carter was ineffective, and Reagan was another Red-baiting rich snob. Anderson's campaign clarified rights for 3rd party candidates to get on ballots, and later in life he pushed the cause of rank choice voting.

      Delete
    4. Anderson represented my district in those days, which for me were my high school years, with 1980 being my freshman year in college. There was kind of a string of interesting representatives from that district, which in those days was centered in Rockford, IL. It's been gerrymandered since. Adam Kinzinger, one of the handful of Republicans who was willing to be booted from his Congressional seat rather than compromise with Trump, recently represented what is essentially the same district.

      Delete
    5. Interesting. Kinzinger seems cut from similar cloth as Anderson. Decent, rational, interested in politics in the interests of the public good, not demagoguing. Anderson had some weird bill he pushed one time declaring the US as a Christian nation, but that failed and he never brought it up again.

      Delete
  3. I remember the Carters' daughter Amy from their time in the White House. She was a spunky little nine-year old when Carter took office. She was a lot younger than her older brothers. She went to public school. I don't think maybe that would be possible now because of heightened security concerns. She was an activist in college years and got arrested three times, but in adulthood has been out of the limelight.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I did not know that a special military unit is in charge of funerals for presidents. But it makes sense, he was their commander-in-chief. They have the resources and the insulation from partisan and family politics to carry out the mission.

    ReplyDelete
  5. What I remember most about Jimmy Carter's post-presidency years was his work with Habitat for Humanity. He not only raised funds for it but dedicated time to actually work on the houses that were being built.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If every Christian put in as much effort in helping the poor as he did, welfare may well have become unnecessary.

      Delete
    2. Raber has experience with Habitat. It behooves people who want to donate to their local Habitat group to research it. Quality of housing, resale policies, and who actually qualifies for purchase varies from locale to locale. The Habitat ReStores are a great resource, and anybody downsizing might want to consider donating there.

      Delete
    3. I know sometimes Habitat remodels/refurbishes existing homes, and sometimes they build new ones.
      They are building new ones in what used to be a field south of our street. It's going to happen over several years. There are now four houses with families living in them. Basic but nice houses, I'm guessing them to be around 1000 square feet. No garages yet, people can add those later if they want to. The new street is called Isaiah Street.
      I miss the field and the open space when I look out, but am happy for the people who have houses now.

      Delete
    4. Habitat is not for "poor people," but for lower-income people with decent credit scores and stable incomes. Typically, you have to make below 60 percent of your area's median income and be able to devote 30 percent of your income to a mortgage. You also have a set amount of "sweat equity" hours you are required to put in. So not like you bang in a few sheets of underlayment or sand some drywall seams and get a free house.

      You get vetted financially just like you would with a bank. Habitat owns the house until you pay it off. Yes, your Habitat home can be foreclosed on and sold to another qualifying buyer.

      Republicans like Habitat because the recipients are "deserving" and it's not a government giveaway. But it can't replace "welfare" for the many groups, such as the homeless, jobless, or those with bad credit.

      Pitching in with helping hands is great. But a certain amount of quality skilled labor is required to ensure the houses are up to code. You get a lot of unskilled do-gooders onsite, and it's two steps forward, one step back fixing their mistakes.

      When the politicians come by for their photo op day with camera crews, nothing gets done.

      That said, Habitat is part of the solution for a relatively small number of folks, and the ReStores can be a source of discount items you can't typically get at other thrift stores.

      Delete
    5. According to the Omaha Habitat site, 39 homes were built in 2023. That's great, but it's a drop in the bucket compared to need. https://habitatomaha.org/

      Delete
    6. Right, it's not a solution for homelessness. But does help some people who might not otherwise be able to own a home. The ones who kind of spearhead the effort here are some church people from a local Baptist congregation who are professional contractors. It's interesting to see where some of the volunteers come from. There are usually a whole bunch of them when they're first framing up a house. We'll see about 20 cars parked around, some with out of state plates, usually on a Saturday.
      What they really need around here are some small basic apartments with reasonable rents for single people. There are plenty of apartments and duplexes, but they are higher end and expensive.

      Delete
    7. My husband has a lifetime collection of tools. Thousands of $ worth of tools in our basement. We don’t want to toss them. A neighbor told us that Habitat will take them as a donation. I hope they will pick up! There is a ReStore near us also - they will probably get donations of household stuff from us as we continue clearing our 52 years of stuff.

      Delete
    8. That sounds like a great donation!

      Delete
    9. I’ve donated stuff to Restore but I usually deliver. I believe they’ll pick up. I usually get a slip for the tax deduction I can fill out myself. I know some people exaggerate the worth but I can’t do that.

      Delete
  6. I don’t remember much about his presidency - stagflation, the attempted rescue of the hostages and the crash of one of the helicopters, the Camp David agreement, and his advice to turn down the heat and put on a sweater. A personal memory - my car was in a garage on 17th St and going home from work I had to cross Pennsylvania Ave.. When trying to go home the night before his inauguration I realized too late that I wasn’t going anywhere because Carters motorcade was coming down Pennsylvania Ave, taking him to Blair House to spend the night before the inauguration. It is on Penn Ave and 17th St so all traffic was stopped there. Blair House is very close to the WH and is the usual night before the inauguration resting place.

    I had a client in an office building next door to the public school that Amy Carter attended and worked onsite about 20 hours/ week. My office window overlooked the school - Just a normal, urban public school - a blacktop playground and not a blade of grass in sight. She is the only presidential child that I remember- before Carter or after - to go to a public school.

    I came to admire Carter after he left office for his humanitarian work and peacemaking efforts. I also admired his genuine faith. It wasn’t just a political gimmick as it has been for most politicians for the last several years.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I was wrong. Nixon’s older daughter attended a public elementary school in DC before going private for high school. I think the younger daughter was in private all the way. George W Bush’s daughters went to public schools in Texas. They were in college by the time he was President. Chelsea Clinton, the Obama girls and Baron Trump all went to private schools. Most of the presidential kids went to the same private school in DC - Sidwell Friends but many politician kids also went to one of the schools at the Washington NationalCathedral. Baron ended up at a school about a mile from our home - a long way from the WH. It’s a school known for designing individual educational programs for kids with “ learning issues” but does take mainstream kids too. Sidwell and the Cathedral schools are very hard to get into and have very challenging academics.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Prayers for blessings for all as we begin a new year🙏

    ReplyDelete
  9. Older story but nice feature about the Carter's decision to send Amy to public school, Thaddeus Stevens Elementary. https://wtop.com/dc/2017/08/flashback-1970s-amy-carter-dc-public-schools/

    NYT had a story yesterday about Amy attending a state dinner and reading "The Mystery of the Screaming Clock" at the table.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I remember the reading at the table incident. Believe it or not it made big news in DC with people cluck clucking about her lack of table manners. I privately cheered for her. I can’t imagine how boring those long state dinners would be for a young child and I fully empathized.

      Delete
    2. Not sure why she attended in the first place. But as a kid who read in corners when the yelling got too loud, I sympathized.

      Delete
    3. I dunno, maybe the Carters thought attending a state dinner might be educational?
      To me, "bad manners" would be interrupting people, and saying you don't like the food. Reading is quiet and doesn't disturb anyone.
      I sort of had to get that across to my in-laws when we were first married. They and my husband liked to watch sports in tv...a LOT. I liked to hang out with them, but have never enjoyed watching sports (I'll make an exception for granddaughters' volleyball games!) They finally figured out that it was better to let me read than to constantly have to answer questions like, "Why is the ball over on that side now?"

      Delete
    4. I remember the SNL skit where “Amy” gets her pigtails pulled by a mischievous boy classmate and the Secret Service agents slam him down.

      Delete
    5. Maybe her parents brought her so they'd have an excuse to ignore the crashing bores. "Sorry, can't converse, I'm too busy parenting."

      Delete
    6. State Funeral livestream information from the Cathedral today in case anyone is interested.

      State Funeral for President Jimmy Carter
      Dear friends,

      Next week, the Cathedral will be honored to host the State Funeral for President Jimmy Carter, a remarkable figure whose decades of public service were anchored by a deep and profound Christian faith. We look forward to joining together with people across the globe to celebrate President Carter’s century of open-hearted outreach and humanitarian activism.

      The State Funeral will be held at the Cathedral on Thursday, Jan. 9, at 10 ET. As you can imagine, the large number of expected dignitaries and security concerns limit the number of invited guests, but we invite all members of the public to join the service online via livestream on the Cathedral website.

      We will be sharing more details about the service in the coming days as plans are finalized. In the meantime, I invite you to visit cathedral.org/Carter to learn more about the rich history of State Funerals at the Cathedral and to bookmark the livestream link for the service.

      Delete
  10. Our New Year’s Resolution in the Lord 2025. Thy Will Be Done.
    Regenerated Will: Through faith in Jesus, believers experience spiritual rebirth (John 3:3), enabling them to will and act according to God's purposes (Philippians 2:13).
    Divine Empowerment: Jesus' promise to raise believers to Paradise (John 14:2-3) inspires hope and motivates obedience.
    Love as the Highest Command: Jesus teaches loving God and neighbors as the greatest commandments (Matthew 22:37-40).
    Sanctification: The Holy Spirit enables believers to grow in love and obedience (2 Corinthians 3:18).

    John 14: 2-3: Jesus promises to prepare a heavenly dwelling for believers.
    Philippians 2: 13: God works in believers to will and act according to His purpose.
    Matthew 22: 37-40: Jesus commands loving God and neighbors.
    1 John 4: 19: Believers love because God first loved them.
    "For it is God who works in you to will and to act in accordance with his good purpose." (Philippians 2:13)
    "And we all, who with unveiled faces contemplate the Lord's glory, are being transformed into his image." (2 Corinthians 3:18)
    "Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind." (Matthew 22:37). The grace of the Lord Jesus Christ, and the love of God, and the fellowship of the Holy Spirit, be with you all. Whereby our New Year will be Happy.

    ReplyDelete