I think of Veterans Day largely as a remembrance for World War I vets, like my Grampa Clinton Foster in the photo at left taken at Camp Custer, Battle Creek, Michigan, 1917. Standing behind him, far left in the white dress is my Gramma Edith Deits. She was 21. He was 25. They would be married six years later. (Also in the photo is Grampa's sister Agnes and Gramma's younger sister, Mary.)
Grampa was the oldest sibling left at home to work the farm when the war broke out. His father spent a lot of time away from the family as a timber assessor. When Grampa reported for duty in 1918, it was September, and several of his letters home show he was worried about the corn crop:
You did not say if the corn got ripe, and I have not seen any signs of frost here yet & it stays damp nearly all the time.
Did you folks find the pumpkins I carved my name on in the cornfield? It is on the north side in about the 4th row. Is the corn ripe yet?
I saw an airplane land, and it was sure fine! It was the first seen since I have been here.
Grampa had a lot of experience with horses and mules from working the farm and in the Michigan lumber camps where he worked winters sometimes. When he first got to Camp Custer, he didn't have much use for mule training:
I have been under the weather for 4 or 5 days but feel better now, but was excused from drill this p.m. It is the next thing to the grippe, and lots are in the same boat. It is just because we are drilled in the cold rain taking notes on how to groom Old Adam's jack ass.
They transferred a bunch into the infantry this a.m., including 2 corporals, so I may go [overseas] next, but I don't give a darn. The more mules I see, the more I cuss the Kaiser.
However, Grampa was turned out to be a crack mule trainer and he was promoted to corporal:
Tell Father that we were out with the mules & carts and went through places that would make the banks & gullies on the Clam River [at home] look like a pavement. We had to help the mules in some places & in others we had to lock the cart wheels. It was quite exciting & I liked it, too. Sgt Rutledge said that if he told the First Platoon to put them mules up a tree he would be damned if he wouldn't believe we'd do it!
When he wasn't training mules, Grampa worried about his War Risk Insurance, a policy issued to all soldiers for $4,500 (about $100,000 today) to cover death or disability. There was no Veterans Administration until 1930, so the War Risk Insurance might be the only benefit a soldier or family received:
I was sure surprised and I can hardly believe that Kenneth [a cousin sent overseas] is dead, but we all have the same thing to face & they tell us here that they would rather lose several men than one piece of a machine gun.
I wish you would let me know immediately whether you have ever received my insurance policy or not. If you have not, I will look the matter up. I have been thinking about it quite a lot lately.
Later-- In regards to any insurance, I guess there is no need to worry as it surely was made out all right, and it seems that none of the boys who came with me have heard about theirs, so I presume they are held up in Washington.
Grampa, as it turned out, was so good with mules that he was stationed stateside for the duration of the war toughening up the mules with marches over mucky terrain and getting them used to artillery noises by shooting blanks over their heads.
Grampa's brother-in-law, Martin Keehn, was not so lucky. He was hit in the leg in a trench in France. He said he was lucky not to get gangrene or to get gassed, and he used to get out his Purple Heart for the kids to look at on November 11.
After the war, Grampa went back to his family farm. Gramma had saved a lot of money to buy her own farm, and Grampa tried to make it work. But by 1936, he was sick of farming and got a job as a letter carrier. Gramma sold the farm and they moved into town. By the time I came along, Grampa was a taciturn old man who enjoyed cats, chain smoking, reading Westerns, and tippling from the whisky that Gramma made him keep in the garage. That's him with my brother in 1960 at right.Grampa was not an introspective person. If he thought anything about the politics or moral aspects of World War I, he never talked about it. I suspect that wars, like droughts or a horse with a broken leg, was just something you learned to deal with. It was accepted that there were parts of life you couldn't do anything about. You did what you were told and hoped your War Risk Insurance went through.
I sometimes wonder if Grampa ever read the British War Poets and what he would have made of Wilfrid Owens' poem, Dulce Et Decorum Est, a piece I taught for many years that never failed to grab students. I'm thinking of it today:
Bent double, like old beggars under sacks,
Knock-kneed, coughing like hags, we cursed through sludge,
Till on the haunting flares we turned our backs,
And towards our distant rest began to trudge.
Men marched asleep. many had lost their boots,
But limped on, blood-shod. All went lame; all blind;
Drunk with fatigue; deaf even to the hoots
Of gas-shells dropping softly behind.
Gas! GAS! Quick boys!--An ecstacy of fumbling
Fitting the clumsy helmets just in time,
But someone still was yelling out and stumbling
And flound'ring like a man in fire or lime.--
Dim through the misty panes and thick green light,
As under a green sea, I saw him drowning.
In all my dreams before my helpless sight,
He plunges at me, guttering, choking, drowning.
If in some smothering dreams, you too could pace
Behind the wagon that we flung him in,
And watch the white eyes writhing in his face,
His hanging face, like a devil's sick of sin;
If you could hear, at every jolt, the blood
Come gargling from the froth-corrupted lungs,
Obscene as cancer, bitter as the cud
Of vile, incurable sores on innocent tongues,--
My friend, you would not tell with such high zest
To children ardent for some desperate glory,
The old Lie: Dulce et decorum est
Pro patria mori.
Jean, that's an interesting story! I'm glad you got to hear your grandpa's memories of WWI. There is no one left alive now who would remember that war. Hopefully they shared their stories so they could be written down.
ReplyDeleteMy paternal grandpa, Martin Nielsen, was a WWI vet too. He was barely 20, recently immigrated from Denmark. You could fast-track citizenship by enlisting. I'm not even sure he was fluent in English yet. He went through basic training at Fort Riley, Kansas, and then ended up at a base out east, I'm not sure which one. There's no one to ask now. Anyway he never saw action, because his whole unit came down with influenza. It killed some of them, but he lived. However I think it weakened his heart and lungs. He died when I was a toddler, at age 58. I have only shadowy memories of him. One of them was watching him milk the cow out in the barn. My parents said he let me tag along with him when he was doing chores. He was said to be a gentle, soft-spoken man. My grandma always stayed in touch with his sisters back in Denmark after his death. She had to have a friend who was a Danish speaker translate their letters.
Gosh, who has the sisters' letters? Hope someone saved them. Do you know how/why your grampa came over here? Lots of Scandinavians in Nebraska, no? I have heard that wartime service fast-tracked you to citizenship. Might have started in the Civil War?
DeleteMy grampa was never a talker. I remember his sisters, Grace, Agnes, and Olive, and they talked enough for 10 people. After my mom died I found his Army letters, excerpted above. Those were more words than I ever heard him talk in person in my whole life.
My friend’s father was a tank commander in WWII in the European theater. They have all his letters. Interestingly enough, they used a photostatic system that reduced the size of the handwritten letters before sending them to the US, presumably by air. I read a few. Pretty gritty and not sanguine about germans, combatants or otherwise.
DeleteBasically I think Grandpa came over because he was the youngest son of a tenant farmer, and there wasn't much in the way of opportunity for him there. An older brother had already come over, and found him a job working on a farm. There are some Scandinavian communities in Nebraska, but not so much at the western end of the state, where we were.
DeleteWe did save some of the letters, they used to send some pretty Christmas cards. But they were all super thin, air mail paper. It cost more for postage, the more a letter weighed.
My nephew took a semester to study in Denmark when he was in college. He was able to find an address from one of the letters and connected with some of the relatives while he was there.
The great-aunts names were Ana Christina, Kirsten, and Karen. One of my sisters is named Kirsten, and Aunt Kirsten sent her a silver spoon and fork with some Hans Christian Andersen figures when she was born.
DeleteI love family stories--anybody's family! That's interesting that your nephew found some relatives. All my Dutch relatives came from the same small town north of Amsterdam. I have seen photos of it. The church and windmill would have been there when they left. Out of a family of 8, only my g-g-grandmother and her two brothers made it over. The others died on the ship and were buried at sea. Spoke no English when they got to New York, but somebody who did got them all jobs. They pooled their money and came to the Dutch settlement in Michigan.
DeleteJean, I'm sorry that five of your relatives died at sea. What wss the time period when it happened?
DeleteI'd have to look it up, but 1870s. Hendrik and Krinas eventually went to Oklahoma, maybe as part of the land rush out there. Info about them was sketchy. Mary married a Dutchman and they moved to northern Michigan. Not a happy marriage, but he died young, and she kept things together cooking in lumber camps. She eventually moved in with a married daughter and had a very happy old age.
DeleteJean, have you ever gotten on Google Maps and taken a street view tour of your ancestors’ town? I have so toured the small villages of Poryte and Słucz in Poland. If I make another visit to Poland, I plan to walk down those streets physically and hopefully find my grandmother’s farm. What would I find, if anything? It would be the closing of a 120 year old circle.
DeleteI've seen aerial shots, but doesn't seem to be a street view. Still looks pretty farm-y out there still. Part of what was called Friesland. I read a lot of interesting stuff about land reclamation efforts out there that started in the early Middle Ages.
DeleteWith climate change, unless it’s stopped by economic collapse, we’re going to have to learn how to handle water. The Dutch are the experts. Amazing accomplishments at an almost terraforming level.
DeleteThere are some downsides to tampering with natural terrain. Draining the fens in Friesland meant that the pagans lost the peat bogs they used to dispose of human sacrifice victims.
DeleteThey should have consulted with the Mob. Still haven’t found Jimmy Hoffa.
DeleteHa, on the way to my Gramma's many years ago, we drove past a county garage in the middle of nowhere that was supposedly where Hoffa was buried under the concrete. The rumor was persistent enough for the site to be investigated by the FBI, but it was cleared.
DeleteNobody in my family was in the Great War unless you count my Aunt Steffy as a medical volunteer. My father only served five weeks in combat in WWII. Those weeks were all in Iwo Jima. Big deal. My mother was a spot welder at Budd Co. This past Sunday, at the end of Mass, the priest asked the veterans to stand up to get a show of appreciation. Two pews behind me, I heard a man groan out, “Ohhh God”. I didn’t turn around to look. Instead of saying “thank you for your service”, I’d rather say “sorry some dumbass hot shot politician sent you somewhere in harm’s way for nothing and I hope you never saw action”.
ReplyDeleteEnjoyed your family stories, Jean and Katherine.
Haha! The most traumatic thing Raber endured was being on the open sea in a hurricane. He said he would have been terrified, but the seasickness and dry heaves wiped out all thoughts except wishing you were dead. One guy on the ship, Big Bob from Arkansas, was completely immune to seasickness. After it was all over, the other sailors asked him how he managed: "Well, I'd get a little queasy, but I smoked a cigarette and it settled my stomach."
DeleteI think I would have eaten a cigarette if it would have helped.
DeleteSailors were all handed barf bags and more were placed at intervals around the ship when they got underweigh. "You girls are gonna have a pukin' good time," one of the CPOs observed. Same one who would walk thru quarters when the sailors were playing poker and observe to no one in particular, "Money stays under the table." Gambling on ship was forbidden, but widespread.
DeleteWell, we have no recent war heroes in the family. My paternal grandfather was essentially a draft dodger. He and two brothers left Germany in the 1880 s to avoid being drafted into one of Bismarck’s endless wars in Germany. My maternal grand father was Irish heritage and I don’t think he ever fought in any wars. My husband’s father was exempt during WWII because he was an engineer with the Navy Dept in DC. My father was exempt during WWII because of a bad leg that he had injured as a teenager. My brother was exempt for a long time because of a damaged ear drum ( from body surfing) but was eventually drafted. He never went to Viet Nam though.. My husband was in the Marine reserves for years but was finished by the time Viet Nam was really heating up.
ReplyDeleteGood for all of them for avoiding war, especially fighting for Otto von. Can’t think of a dumber cause. I guess WWII was necessary if not unavoidable (putting the screws to the German people after Versailles).. Some say the European powers hated Hitler for doing to white people what THEY had been doing to dark-complexioned people for centuries
DeleteGosh, not saying my grandfather was a hero or that I'm particularly proud of him, just thought that the firsthand acct would be of some small interest to folks.
DeleteIt is interesting, Jean. You have stories and letters and memories. I never knew my grandparents except for my maternal grand mother. The rest died before I was even born.Everyone here except me ( not sure about David) have family stories and memories that I don’t. You all even go to visit family cemeteries. I don’t even know the name of the cemetery where my father is buried. It’s n LA somewhere and is a Catholic cemetery, but that’s all I know. My mother is buried in her father’s family plot in Corning NY. Too far to visit, so I haven’t been there since 1992. My brother who died when he was 47 is buried somewhere in the San Fernando Valley part of LA. The only aunt I ever knew died 20 years ago.Her husband, my uncle, died when I was 10. Their daughter is the only cousin I know. She now lives in Santa Fe so I no longer see her when I go to California .
DeleteI love everyone’s family stories here because I don’t have many of my own.
Do you write down little details for your grandchildren? One of the frustrations about genealogy is looking at names in the far far distant past and knowing nothing about someone: What was their favorite song? Food? Secret wish? Could they read? Was their marriage happy? My gramma used to sing "Oh, What a Beautiful Morning" when she vacuumed. She took in any cat she found in her doorstep. She crocheted doilies for the chairs, couches, and tables. And she played the radio for her canary to get it to sing. Pretty much tells you a lot right there.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteLast night Jean's interest in the First World War led me to find my copy of a large booklet on the descendants of John Georg Glaser who was my mother's maternal grandfather. Born in 1840 in Germany he immigrated in 1866 and died in 1911. He had 15 children, two to a first wife who died young, then 13 to his second wife. Eleven were male, four were female.
ReplyDeleteOne would think that there must have been some military service among them, however the collector of the family tree spent so much time just tracing the descendants, she tells us little else about their lives. I do know my great uncle "Gus" was a member of the PA State Police. He is of the age where he would likely have been called. Maybe some military service or training led to his career in law enforcement, or maybe a law enforcement career exempted him from military service?
I know more about the Second World War. My uncle Andy was a gunner on a bomber. I think somewhere around Burma. My dad was exempted initially because he was married and working in the steel industry, and then by my birth! My uncle Floyd served briefly stateside during the Korean War, guarding the gold in Fort Knox!
My aunt was a volunteer for the Waves, then got a job in the Pentagon after the war. She met her second husband (the first was a lawyer who died) at the Pentagon. He was a naval officer.
Both of them thought of their service as just normal patriotism, nothing to be especially proud of. I suspect that might have been the normal attitude in past generations. Then came Vietnam when many people thought that those who served did the wrong thing. Since then, I think we have had an over-reaction in the opposite direction. I suspect that many serving in recent years have a hard time reconciling their public honor with their personal experience of war.
My dad's father stayed out out WWI because he worked in a ball bearing plant in Detroit. If you had a job that contributed to the war effort, you were exempt. Fun fact: The Marx Brothers stayed out of the war by purchasing a chicken farm in Illinois. https://fromthemarxives.home.blog/the-marx-farm/
Delete"I suspect that many serving in recent years have a hard time reconciling their public honor with their personal experience of war."
Yes, that's certainly borne out by our niece's experiences in Iraq.