Friday, February 26, 2021

The Fourth Wave?

According to the NYT database new cases of the virus have been steadily falling -until the last few days when they have either plateaued or are reversing themselves.  Will we have a fourth wave based on the variants which are more resistant to the vaccine? 

The Coronavirus Is Plotting a Comeback.

 Here’s Our Chance to Stop It for Good.

Hopefully the NYT is allowing access to this article for everyone. Nevertheless I have excerpted and unlined the key points to facilitate discussion


Americans will win against the virus and regain many aspects of their pre-pandemic lives, most scientists now believe. Of the 21 interviewed for this article, all were optimistic that the worst of the pandemic is past. This summer, they said, life may begin to seem normal again.

But — of course, there’s always a but — researchers are also worried that Americans, so close to the finish line, may once again underestimate the virus.

So far, the two vaccines authorized in the United States are spectacularly effective, and after a slow start, the vaccination rollout is picking up momentum. A third vaccine is likely to be authorized shortly, adding to the nation’s supply.

But it will be many weeks before vaccinations make a dent in the pandemic. And now the virus is shape-shifting faster than expected, evolving into variants that may partly sidestep the immune system.

The road back to normalcy is potholed with unknowns: how well vaccines prevent further spread of the virus; whether emerging variants remain susceptible enough to the vaccines; and how quickly the world is immunized, so as to halt further evolution of the virus.

But the greatest ambiguity is human behavior. Can Americans desperate for normalcy keep wearing masks and distancing themselves from family and friends? How much longer can communities keep businesses, offices and schools closed?


Covid-19 deaths will most likely never rise quite as precipitously as in the past, and the worst may be behind us. But if Americans let down their guard too soon — many states are already lifting restrictions — and if the variants spread in the United States as they have elsewhere, another spike in cases may well arrive in the coming weeks.

Scientists call it the fourth wave. 

The cases and hospitalizations have been falling rapidly but they are still high.

Very, very high case numbers are not a good thing, even if the trend is downward,” said Marc Lipsitch, an epidemiologist at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health in Boston. “Taking the first hint of a downward trend as a reason to reopen is how you get to even higher numbers.”

The vaccines were first rolled out to residents of nursing homes and to the elderly, who are at highest risk of severe illness and death. That may explain some of the current decline in hospitalizations and deaths.

Vaccination cannot explain why cases are dropping even in countries where not a single soul has been immunized, like Honduras, Kazakhstan or Libya. The biggest contributor to the sharp decline in infections is something more mundane, scientists say: behavioral change.

Leaders in the United States and elsewhere stepped up community restrictions after the holiday peaks. But individual choices have also been important, said Lindsay Wiley, an expert in public health law and ethics at American University in Washington.

“People voluntarily change their behavior as they see their local hospital get hit hard, as they hear about outbreaks in their area,” she said. “If that’s the reason that things are improving, then that’s something that can reverse pretty quickly, too.”

Buoyed by the shrinking rates over all, however, governors are lifting restrictions across the United States and are under enormous pressure to reopen completely. Should that occur, B.1.1.7 and the other variants are likely to explode.

“Everybody is tired, and everybody wants things to open up again,” Dr. Tuite said. “Bending to political pressure right now, when things are really headed in the right direction, is going to end up costing us in the long term.”

Looking ahead to late March or April, the majority of scientists interviewed by The Times predicted a fourth wave of infections. But they stressed that it is not an inevitable surge, if government officials and individuals maintain precautions for a few more weeks.

A minority of experts were more sanguine, saying they expected powerful vaccines and an expanding rollout to stop the virus. And a few took the middle road.

We’re at that crossroads, where it could go well or it could go badly,” said Dr. Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases.

Taking into account the counterbalancing rises in both vaccinations and variants, along with the high likelihood that people will stop taking precautions, a fourth wave is highly likely this spring, the majority of experts told The Times.

Kristian Andersen, a virologist at the Scripps Research Institute in San Diego, said he was confident that the number of cases will continue to decline, then plateau in about a month. After mid-March, the curve in new cases will swing upward again.

In early to mid-April, “we’re going to start seeing hospitalizations go up,” he said. “It’s just a question of how much.”

Now the good news.

Despite the uncertainties, the experts predict that the last surge will subside in the United States sometime in the early summer. If the Biden administration can keep its promise to immunize every American adult by the end of the summer, the variants should be no match for the vaccines.

Combine vaccination with natural immunity and the human tendency to head outdoors as weather warms, and “it may not be exactly herd immunity, but maybe it’s sufficient to prevent any large outbreaks,” said Youyang Gu, an independent data scientist, who created some of the most prescient models of the pandemic.

Infections will continue to drop. More important, hospitalizations and deaths will fall to negligible levels — enough, hopefully, to reopen the country.

“Sometimes people lose vision of the fact that vaccines prevent hospitalization and death, which is really actually what most people care about,” said Stefan Baral, an epidemiologist at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health.

10 comments:

  1. If I can avoid death and respiratory crippling, I'll be happy to get the vaccine. MaryAnn and some of former coworkers got their first dose through the federal facility at which they work. Even though I haven't received the vaccine yet, it makes me feel good to have people I know being inoculated.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, me too. I know quite a few people who are vaccinated now.

      Delete
  2. I read an article this week criticizing Biden and Dr. Fauci for not having a positive enough tone about the state of the pandemic. I think they are just avoiding "irrational exuberance", to quote Alan Greenspan. If we can just hang on to precautions a little longer we can get back to normalcy sooner. Unfortunately a lot of governors, including ours, are relaxing restrictions too soon. The archdiocese is following his lead and did away with crowd size restrictions. My husband usually assists with the school Mass on Friday mornings. They had been splitting the kids half and half into the church with distancing, and the other half with livestreaming in the cafeteria. He said this morning that everyone was seated in the church. At least they were still wearing masks. One saving grace is that people are creatures of habit and they have now formed the habit of wearing masks and using hand sanitizer. And they have noticed that other contagious illnesses such as colds and flu are down.
    I am reading in this morning's paper that Nebraska is in line to get 15K doses of Johnson and Johnson vaccine next week. Which is good news, it is one dose, and the more people who get vaccinated, the better. I will take whatever I can get when it's my turn, but I still hope we get the Moderna one, which is the one they have been using in our health district. 60-70% effective is a lot better than nothing, but I'd like 95% better.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, Governor DeWine engaged in some irrational exuberance at yesterday’s news conference announcing that he would be gradually relaxing restrictions in the coming weeks. Of course he did give some caveats that the new strains of virus might complicate things.

      The difficulty is that many people, especially businesses, want to get back to normal. We have allowed the virus to run rampant, essentially telling old and vulnerable people that it is up to them to keep themselves isolated.

      That means that we are allowing the virus a big chance of developing resistant strains that will be harder to stamp out. If we had practiced stronger containment efforts like a lot of the countries of Asia, it might have been possible to vaccinate enough people to make it very difficult for the virus to come back.

      Ultimately we stand a good chance of prolonging this virus, and making it unsafe for the elderly and vulnerable to go out for a long time. Maybe younger people are planning a return to normal by the end of summer, I am going to wait a lot longer than that.

      Betty has several medical conditions that mean she will likely wait until there is a lot of evidence that persons with her relatively rare conditions can take the vaccine without complications. After I get the vaccine I intend to maintain isolation with her until she decides she can get the vaccine, or they have strong proof that my vaccination makes it unlikely that I could transmit the virus if I get a mild case of it.

      Delete
  3. In other COVID news, the WaPo reported that about half the states are not prioritizing patients most at risk because of co-morbidities and risk factors. There is a big public pushback against smokers and the obese getting a jump in the line. Snip:

    <>

    Vaccine lotteries and personal appeals: The medically vulnerable find their priority status slipping away (probably behind a paywall).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oops, the snip disappeared. Here it is:

      An estimated 81 million adults have conditions that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention identifies as posing an increased risk for severe covid-19, the illness caused by the coronavirus. In December, the CDC designated that group a vaccination priority — after health-care workers, nursing home residents and staff, older adults and some front-line essential workers.

      But those recommendations have plainly become unworkable, as states veer from federal guidelines and chart their own paths, often in seemingly random ways. The result: Access to a shot can depend on what side of a state line you live on.

      Jonathan L. Temte, associate dean for public health and community engagement at the University of Wisconsin and a member of the CDC advisory panel that issued the guidelines, called the result a “free-for-all.”

      Delete
    2. "Access to a shot can depend on what side of a state line you live on." Yes. If we still lived in our hometown we could have gotten ours by now. My sister was trying to talk me into coming out there. But no thanks, having to deal with public restrooms and eating places, and some of my relatives who aren't very careful, isn't tempting me right now.

      Delete
    3. In Michigan, some venues will only take residents in their service areas. For ex, the county health dept here checks to make sure that you reside in the county. People trying to jump the line by going elsewhere may find they made the trip for nothing. If they lie and use a local relative's address, sadly, they're elbowing out qualifying locals.

      Delete
    4. Yeah, I don't want to crowd out the locals. They do seem to be doing it more orderly out there, maybe just because there are fewer people to cover.

      Delete
  4. Have had an up and down on an off mild fever the last couple days with a cough and lowered appetite. Got a COVID test at CVS which came up negative. First illness in fourteen months. I guess one can still catch the regular stuff. Happy to not have a nasty virus in my body looking to do mischief.

    ReplyDelete