Tax collectors have been in the Gospel lately. Last week, it
was the humble one who was justified in contrast to the boastful Pharisee. This
week it was Zacchaeus, treed, who was described as both rich and a tax
collector. In both stories, the tax collector comes out well, in spite of being
one of a despised class of citizens.
Somebody
had to collect the tax.
We were
wondering who, in this land of the free, might stand in for tax collectors if
the Gospel stories were told in this day and age, when tax collectors are mostly a
computer program. My friends suggested: journalists.
Yeah, there is
something in that. The president has called us “enemies of the people” 36 times, and Tweeted “fake news” 558 times. Sometimes he points out
reporters and gets his cult to chant, “Lock them up.” Customs and Border Patrol
agents seem to be on board.
Last month, an American reporting for a military news
Website was held up by an agent at Dulles International Airport who said, “So
your are a propagandist, right?” The reporter replied, "No. I am in
journalism. Covering national security. And homeland security.” The agent allegedly repeated, "So
you write propaganda, right?" The reporter agreed to avoid further hassle
and got his passport back.
That incident
followed the same scenario as one that transpired across in the continent, in Los Angeles, in August. Again the CPB was venting. This time it was with a British journalist: “He wanted
to know if I’d ever worked for CNN or MSNBC or other outlets that are
‘spreading lies to the American people’,” the reporter tweeted. “He
aggressively told me that journalists are liars and are attacking their
democracy.”
The trope that
the press is against them is on a well-thumbed page in the political playbook. In sports, it is called “working the
refs (or umpires),” and you do it in hopes that next time he is about to call a
play against you something in the back of his head tells him it would be unfair
to sweet, little you. It works better with the press, which is eager to be, and
more eager to look, even-handed. If “both sidesism” applied to crime reporting
you would read: “The mass murderer
was finally shot to death, but criminals quickly pointed out that the police
broke several traffic laws on their way to his murder scene.”
Donald Trump is
very good at accusing others of doing the same thing he has done, so there is
always a traffic law violation by Democrats or the media to be included in stories about him.
What is
different about working the ref lately is that uniformed officers of the government have taken it up. They
are only following the example of their chief executive, but they used to maintain a
professional attitude with the people who pay their salaries or, in the Los Angeles
case, with visitors who will spend money in the country.
With KellyAnne
Conway in contumacious violation of the Hatch Act, the restraints of law, as
well as professionalism, seem to be removed.
I think I
mentioned here earlier that I eventually tired of hearing the Trump version, as
mediated by FoxNews, of the Never-Trump Left Wing Socialist Media, from a conservative
I was having lunch with every two weeks. I blew up and said, “That’s me you are
talking about.” Oh, no, he assured me he didn’t mean me. Then he went ahead and
repeated the whole recitation in a group of people a few days later.
The lunches
ended for another reason, but he still prefers alternative facts to “fake news.”
Because journalists are the new tax collectors.
One more point: "Enemy of the people" is, like everything else Trump tweets, over-used to the point of meaninglessness. But when Henrik Ibsen used it as the title of a play in 1882, the "enemy" was a doctor who discovered the town's famous spring was filled with bacteria that would eventually kill everyone in town and the medical tourists the spring attracted to the town. Nobody wanted to hear it, and they shut the doctor down. A major revival of the play would be too much like what people don't want to hear from those repulsive tax col... er, journalists.
I read about that outrageous incident. Stupid bastard should be fired. Otherwise it's just another sign that fascism is here and building.
ReplyDeleteNow the Orange Poltroon is talking about a "surge", not in Afghanistan or Iraq, but here. He wants to further militarize the cops and assault crime in THIS country. I think I know how that will work out. Watch what they do to African-Americans. That will eventually be done to everyone who's not a real Merkan.
Pontius Pilate famously said, "What is truth?" Is seem that the powers-that-be often have an uneasy relationship with truth. They like to mold it to suit their purposes. Now journalists are more important than ever, to preserve the truth from the ever-running spin machine.
ReplyDeleteThat's an interesting thought, that Zacchaeus might make a good patron for journalists.
A couple of qualities that Zacchaeus had that journalists need are persistence and moxie.
DeleteMoxie. Hmm. That can really start to piss off your sources. I always found--maybe because I'm a woman--that the "help me understand this" approach worked pretty well.
DeleteI once had to cover a story about the town atheist who was trying to sue Catholic Social Services for discriminating against the non-religious when adopting out children (Michigan had given over infant adoptions to private groups under Reagan).
CSS said that providing a child with a religious upbringing of any denomination was just one of many criteria and was not a deal-breaker. The atheist said it shouldn't be a criteria at all if CSS was getting state funds (which it was) because it was promoting religion.
The people on both sides of the story were thoughtful and articulate. I was persistent (interviewed them both three times and talked to a lawyer on background), but it was not the kind of story I approached with my sh*t-kickers on.
Perhaps determination is a better word than moxie. Because there would be a lot of stories where they would want you to just give up and go away.
DeleteThose journalists who were harassed at the airport should file complaints.
ReplyDeleteIt's hard for Americans to identify with the people who would have hated Zacchaeus, because we're fundamentally free in the US. But for someone of our generations who immigrated here from Poland or Russia, I am sure it is no problem to imagine collaborators with the evil regime.
Isn't that how the brown shirts started intimidating people, not just journalists?
ReplyDeleteJawohl. How many World War II spy movies have the scene in which the uniformed official says, "Show me your papers"?
ReplyDeleteNext thing it will be the press...and then?
ReplyDeleteHerewith, even as I speak:
All five members of the Citrus County commission [Florida] rejected the library's request to fund digital subscriptions to the New York Times during an Oct. 24 board meeting. The Trump administration announced plans to cancel federal agencies' subscriptions to the Times and The Washington Post on the same day.
Tom: maybe you can take your copy of the Times over there (wherever it is) and let library readers scan the headlines.
I have a cousin in Homosassa Springs, which is in Citrus County. It is largely retired midwesterners who couldn't force themselves to go south as far as the palm trees; the foliage isn't that different from western Wisconsin. I suspect most of them vote for Trump. I also suspect Trump has read the NYTimes on his twitterphone ever since it became possible: no ink rubbing off on his long neckties.
Delete