We celebrated our 65th April 24 together with lunch at a neighborhood Italian restaurant. We have had flashier anniversaries of the night we met, but flash fades over time. We were talking about great restaurants we will never visit again.
Not because of us.
Because of time.
Deacon Jim misses department stores. I miss restaurants.
Charlie's Cafe Internationale in Minneapolis. Ate there once and swore I'd get back to Minneapolis just to do it again. It was replaced by a glass high rise in 1982. Seiple's in St. Petersburg, FL. Amazing cold raspberry soup, but once had to be enough. Chateaubriand, a neighborhood restaurant (our neighborhood!) with international pretensions. When you come out raving about the vegetables, you know they did everything right. But don't anymore. The Barbary Room in New York, gold utensils while you drank your cocktail. There for us on our honeymoon. No more.
Speaking of New York, I told Faith Stewart-Gordon herself that I woudn't be moving to Miami, when I did, without knowing Air Florida could get me back to the Russian Tea Room, just to the left of Carnegie Hall, regularly. She said the Tea Room would be there. Soon Air Florida was gone. Then the RTR, although when I was checking my memory, I see that it has re-opened under new ownership. Anyhow, cold borscht in the summertime, Gorkis anytime, and that's where I learned what chicken Kiev is supposed to taste like.
I can't tell if the Steamboat Cafe in Mystic, Connecticut, is back or not. It was there in the '70s when I had the lobster bisque for dinner and liked it so well we returned for breakfast, lunch and dinner the next day so I could have it three more times. We strongly recommended it to our daughter and her husband a few years later, and when they looked they couldn't find it.
Mike Gordon's in Miami, on the Intercoastal with pelicans perched outside waiting for the garbage. Only place to be, especially on a rainy day. The kids didn't want the hassle. It was no hassle for the patrons.
In Milwaukee, John Ernst Cafe has given way to a Japanese sushi place up the street. Ernst had three kinds of schaum torte -- raspberry, chocolate and the standard strawberry -- and one afternoon my wife's brother-in-law and I had all three, in a row, for dessert. Schaum torte is something I do not believe is available once you get more than 40 miles away from Milwaukee in any direction.
And, then there was Karl Ratzch's, with Empress Maria Theresa's glassware, and the string trio that missed the same note on "Happy Birthday" every Sunday, and the dumpling soup, and the roast duck and the sauerbraten und der schnitzel and the Mosel wines. And the schaum torte. It's where Dean J. L. O'Sullivan took the Marquette Tribune staff after we fell afoul of important university officials for reporting news. It's where we celebrated my graduation. It's the first place I paid a restaurant bill of $100. That was for a party of eight. Back in the '60s. It's also where, later, I interviewed the Jesuit philosopher Bernard Lonergan, although I do not claim to understand a word of it. He was very patient. And it WAS one of two restaurants we always went to when we were back in Milwaukee.
I won't tell you the name of the other one. Don't want to jinx it.
As we were leaving the restaurant yesterday, we noticed a sign on the door that we missed when we came in. It's closing for good on April 30. I'll remember it as the place where the waiter, Fluvio, would address us as "Signor et Bella," speak only to "Bella" and forget me until it was time for the check.
Is it just the usual attrition, Tom, or is something happening similar to displacement of small stores by Walmart and now Amazon? I always try to patronize individually owned restaurants and such as opposed to megachains.
ReplyDeleteI don't think it's one thing. Mike Gordon's was a decision by the generation following the founder. The Russian Tea Room and Charlie's were sideswiped by real estate developers. I suspect that's what happened to Chateaubriand in Kansas City, too.
DeleteThe death of two of Milwaukee's Big Three German restaurants probably was due to a generational shift to "healthy" eating. The thought of salad with bacon dressing followed by liver dumpling soup, followed by beef rouladen with red kraut, followed by Black Forest cake, preceded by brandy Manhattans, accompanied by beer and followed up by coffee and cognac makes the younger generation cringe. The only one of my children who was up to that is the one who is now a Visitation nun and can't have it. The others would prefer arugula and quinoa sauteed in canola or something equally off-putting. All I can say is we never elected the people we do now when we ate like we did then.
Yep, great post.
ReplyDeleteThere was a cheap Italian restaurant in Evanston called Dave's Italian Kitchen. For a lot of years it was on Church Street (or maybe Davis), hard by the suburban train line. Then it moved to Chicago Ave. We started going there when we had friends at Northwestern in grad school. It was grad-school-friendly: the food wasn't foodie-great but it was pretty good, and they had this Italian dinner salad that for some reason was to die for - never figured out why, as I'm not much of a salad guy as a general rule; and they had inexpensive and drinkable wines by the glass. Original art on the walls - art for which the Art Institute wouldn't pay a thin dime, but it was part of the charm of the place. A few years ago, Dave got tired of being a restauranteur and closed it. We're still looking for an alternative.
The dining here in suburbia isn't very special, one the whole. There was a great little French bistro in Barrington that we discovered, but then it closed a year after we found it. These days, if we want to have a dining adventure, we head for the city. I don't know why the good and risk-taking chefs congregate there instead of out here, but they do.
Look, I ain't got nuthin' against these interesting, substantive comments on Tom's post. But what I'm here to say is: HAPPY 65th ANNIVERSARY, Tom and Marilyn!!
ReplyDeleteOnly eight more to go, before you catch the Bushes. To be sure you get there, maybe go a bit heavier on the repugnant arugula and quinoa sauteed in canola.
Guadalupe and I send our love.
Yes, Happy 65th Anniversary to the Blackburns!
ReplyDeleteSpeaking of special places that have fallen by the wayside; for years our go-to place for anniversaries and such was the Hilltop Inn, which was on a hill by a big lake near our hometown. It was a local icon for about 60 years. It had a steakhouse menu, and the food was good. Some specialties were the homemade apple butter they served with their rolls, and the cinnamon apple dumplings topped by ice cream for dessert. But for me the best part was the spectacular view of the sunset over the lake. Unfortunately it closed a couple years ago.
Yes, happy 65 Signor et Bella! Many of our favorite joints are gone now, too.
ReplyDeleteI have fond memories of Ernst's and Ratzch's from my Marquette days in the late 50s/early 60s ... even though I couldn't afford those places. Always relied on the kindness of strangers or family. San Francisco has lost so many: Trader Vic's, many old North Beach family places, et al.
ReplyDelete