Photo from theguardian.com via Google
UPDATE 12/27/2021 8:38 am CST: I came across this belatedly: it turns out that my wife's view of All I Want for Christmas, while original to her, is not unique. Unbeknownst to both of us, by the time she voiced per opinion about the song, Kyle Smith of National Review already had unintentionally initiated what turned into an international social media kerfuffle regarding the song. Smith's post about the incident is amusing and worth a read, but in brief: he had visited a bar in Dallas and noticed this sign on the establishment's jukebox:
Mariah Carey's All I Want for Christmas Is You will be skipped if played before Dec 1. After Dec 1, the song is only allowed one time a night.
Smith snapped a photo of the handwritten sign and tweeted it out. Somehow, through the magic of tweets being forwarded by other tweeters, Carey herself (or her publicists) became aware of it, and replied via Twitter. I'm pasting an image of her reply here, as the photo is necessary to fully appreciate it:
I say "fully appreciate", but I may be missing the point of it. I take it that it's tongue-in-cheek: I think she (or her publicists) photoshopped her head onto a Xena the Warrior Princess photo. I am reading it as a good-humored response.
I am not what one would call a Mariah Carey fan-boy; frankly, her career blossomed after I had mostly lost interest in popular music, so I sort of missed out on her. I did observe her during the one or two seasons she was a panelist on American Idol, and I kind of liked her: I thought she came across as sensible and well-grounded (or as sensible and well-grounded as a certified diva can be), and inclined to be kind to the teenage and young-adult contestants - which probably is why the show's producers didn't keep her around very long. I think there was back-stage snippiness going on between her and the other panelists, but that seems to me more or less par for the course for that show, and those judges panels crammed together a lot of ego at one table, so I'm not going to assign fault one way or the other for that.
At any rate, after Carey or her publicists deigned to take notice of the tweet, media all over the world picked up the story. But the incident, such as it was, never pinged on my radar until I read about it within the last few days. I'm not one who tunes in DMZ frequently, or at all.
-----
A week or so ago, my wife announced that she can't stand the Mariah Carey insta-classic, "All I Want For Christmas (Is You)" (currently at 238 million views on YouTube, and apparently it has charted on Billboard every single year since its 1994 release). I am happy to say that, while the song is impossible to avoid, it sort of flew under my radar for the last 27 years, except that it's sung by that tween girl in "Love Actually", a film I enjoy. On the whole, it doesn't stir a strong reaction in me.
Then, a day or two ago, I heard Elvis sing Blue Christmas for about the trillionth time, and decided I hate it every bit as much as my wife hates All I want For Christmas. I think it's those annoying "oo-ee-oo-ee-ooh"s that kill the yuletide joy for me.
But - Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree and Feliz Navidad are two songs which would seem to be ripe for hatred (I've probably heard both of them even more than Blue Christmas), but whenever I hear them, I find myself singing along.
Any other holiday song hating going on out there among the NewGathering crew?