Thursday, June 19, 2025

Therapy Culture: Blaming One's Parent

The  NYTimes recently had an opinion piece in which the author claims that one of the reasons that young people are not marrying and having children is because they have too high expectations of parenting, that many of them feel their parents have failed them, and therefore they believe they will fail their children. 

I am not interested in the author's thesis, but I am interested in the existence of a therapy culture on the internet which seems to have hooked many young people into blaming everything upon their parents.  I have placed that portion of the article on my website; it has a link to the full article.



1. There is no doubt in my mind that the presence of Alcohol Abuse, Drug Abuse, Physical Abuse and Sexual Abuse in a person's history causes very high mental health costs. I did a study in our system in which I compared persons for each major diagnosis (depression, schizophrenia, etc.) comparing the cost of people within each diagnosis who did or did not have these various problems. Taking the conservative assumption that people who had these problems would have had depression, etc. without these problems, the problems were responsible for much of the costs of our system.  Therefore, figuring out how to deal with these problems is just as important as dealing with depression, schizophrenia, etc.

2. There is no doubt in my mind that parents in many cases are the abusers, and that children of abusers become abusers themselves.  But children do have exposure to persons other than their parents, who are often abusers. So, we can't blame it all on the parents.

3. There is no doubt in my mind that parents often set unrealistically high goals for themselves and their children. One of my psychology professors in graduate school said he was a convinced behaviorist until he had children. One of them was simply a bundle of energy from day one; the other was calm and placid from day one. He said a managed to calm the first down a little and liven the second up a little bit over the years.  In other words parenting 101 should say don't think that your children will be like you because they have your genes or because you raised them. Rather start with the assumption that a random number has assigned you a child, and deal with it in the same way as if a random number had assigned you a coworker. 

4. My discipline of social psychology says that the social environment determines our behavior far more that any internal traits, values, etc.  Therefore when you want to change the behavior of anyone (child, spouse, coworker) think about how you might change their environment rather than their personalities.  I have found it surprising easy to change environments, even large organizational environments, in comparison to trying to change personal behaviors, beliefs, values, etc.

5. Finally, to what extent do you think internet subculture environments such as therapy cultures exist and have a large influence over internet users.   







4 comments:

  1. I think there are a lot of groups on the Internet that harden and radicalize people's existing opinions and perceptions along certain grooves, for example QAnon. But I can't quite envision a therapy-pushing, parent-blaming Internet group. Sounds pretty niche. But as you say, parent-blaming, especially mother-blaming, has been around since Freud.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I used to read a lot of advice columns, which I don't anymore because I let my WaPo subscription lapse (for some reason NYTimes doesn't have any entertaining ones) But I definitely noticed a lot of mother blaming. And mother-in-law blaming. And what I would say to that, is yes, mothers (and fathers) can be a-holes. But so can kids. I'm not speaking personally, my kids are great. I don't know that I was a great mom, but at least I didn't screw them up too bad.
      Jack, that's interesting about changing people's behavior by changing their environment.

      Delete
  2. Right now, I’d blame the culture, which presently includes the internet, social media and smart phones everywhere. Now we have AI. No matter how parents try to raise their kids today, the electronic culture has more influence. I don’t mean necessarily in a propaganda way but mostly a McCluhanesque way. It’s the media itself.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Jack, I know you take a dim view of talk therapy as self-perpetuating and not very helpful (never mind prohibitively expensive except for the well off and we'll insured). Having tried therapy twice (and been forced to deal with Social Services counselors as a teen for a year in high school), I would agree.

    I got a lot further with behavior mod programs like AlAnon (tho that is self-perpetuating in its way for some folks).

    But I would say that neither therapy nor AlAnon indulged me in parent-blaming. Both took the tack that adults were responsible for their own lives and errors. Therapists perhaps try to ease people into that realization. AlAnon is much more astringent, but blaming your parents was viewed as backsliding and a symptom of your co-dependency.

    I do think that people throw a lot of psychological terms around. The way people try to psychoanalyst Trump and obsess about his family dynamic seems to be the Left's favorite game, though IMO it distracts from discussing the flaws in his EOs, policies, and proposals.

    Anyway, I sense there's some point about mental health care, behind your post that maybe you'd like to clarify.

    ReplyDelete